Applying a Scholarly Lens to Our Instructional Practice, A CITA Institute for CUNYSoTL Fellows

June 1-June 7, 2022

Project Presentations September 2022

Facilitator: Dr. Laura Baecher, CUNYOUSAP Leadership Fellow and Professor of Education at Hunter College

Overview: This CUNYInnovative Teaching Academy (CITA) Institute supported the scholarship of teaching and learning (SoTL). The Scholarship of Teaching of Learning (SoTL) ���involves faculty undertaking systematic inquiry about student learning ��� informed by prior scholarship on teaching and learning ��� and going public with the results���. SoTL as a process and a product advances individual faculty, courses, programs, institutions, and the field of higher education. SoTL research and is doubly important as we explore new modes of instruction, and researchers have already begun to observe and document lessons learned during the COVID-19 pandemic (Rapanta et al., 2020).

To advance research-informed teaching practices across 勛圖弝け, this Institute offered supplemental support for faculty members to (1) participate in a week-long intensive professional learning program on SoTL, (2) receive one-to-one feedback to develop a SoTL study, and (3) develop a manuscript for publication.

  • Purpose: Supporting and advancing scholarship on teaching
  • Eligibility: All full-time CUNYfaculty at all professorial ranks are eligible to apply.
  • Amount: $1,000 per individual participant (up to 15 total participants)

Applications: Applications to be a ���CUNYSoTL Fellow��� were due March 30, 2022 and selection decisions made by April 15, 2022. CUNYSoTL Fellows were selected by the Innovative Pedagogy Working Group, which coordinates The CUNYInnovative Teaching Academy. Criteria such as merits of the proposed research, feasibility of project completion, along with considerations such as diversity of CUNYinstitutions, discipline areas, and faculty rank, informed the selection process.

and asks faculty (assistant, associate or full) to submit their proposed ideas for a SoTL project in the following genres:

  1. academic book
  2. academic book chapter
  3. grant proposal
  4. academic conference proposal
  5. empirical study for a peer- reviewed journal
  6. conceptual, theoretical, or practice-based article for a peer-reviewed journal
  7. public scholarship (blog series, opinion piece, reflective essay

As part of the application, faculty were asked to provide 200 word responses to the following questions:

  1. What do you wish to investigate in your instructional practice/student learning as your SoTL project?
  2. How does your SoTL project relate to teaching/learning at the college/university level?
  3. What goals can be accomplished within the time frame of the institute, and how will you devote adequate time to the SoTL project?
  4. Why do you wish to participate in the SoTL Institute, and how will it impact your field and 勛圖弝け?

Expectations: If selected, faculty committed to actively participate in 5, 3-hour workshops via Zoom.�� These were led by Dr. Laura Baecher (with invited guests as relevant), from 9 AM-12 AM on June 1, 2, 3, 6, 7, Faculty were also expected to work intensively on their project over the weekend of June 4-5.�� Faculty then entered the summer months ready to develop their SoTL projects and commit to presenting on their work at an open session in September 2022.�� Successful completion of the workshops and presentations led to a stipend of $1,000 for a total of 15 participants.

Readings were provided in a folder along with a digital notebook to correspond to workshop sessions once faculty are accepted.�� Faculty were expected to read the materials and spend time outside of workshop hours reading these and one another���s drafts.�� During the intensive 2-weeks of workshops, faculty received 1 to 1 conferences with Dr. Baecher to review their projects, receive feedback on their writing, gain suggestions on publication venues and get support with IRB and project design.

During the summer months (June, July and August 2022), Dr. Baecher maintained an online community of practice with participants and checked in on faculty progress biweekly.�� Ongoing support in designing projects, analyzing and interpreting data, and revising manuscripts was offered throughout the summer.

Workshops:

Part 1: Understanding SoTL. In Part 1 we…

  • read and discussed preliminary SoTL materials
  • framed research questions based on observations of our own teaching and learning experiences

Part 2: Getting Inspired. In Part 2 we���

  • examined SoTL publications across a wide range of disciplines (and looked at overlaps with Discipline-Based Educational Research-DBER)
  • explored a wide variety of genres of SoTL in a wide range of publication outlets

Part 3: Laying the Groundwork. In Part 3 we���

  • discussed the requirements for becoming certified to do research with human subjects and submitting an IRB application
  • looked at a variety of classroom assessment techniques

Part 4: Designing the Project. In Part 4, we…

  • considered various research designs for exploring our dilemma of practice
  • discussed the structure of SoTL articles, including conceptual framework, lit review, methods, evidence, and reflection

Part 5: Going Public. In Part 5, we…

  • identified appropriate places for publishing work
  • Understood reviewer criteria and provided peer feedback to draft designs

Brief Introduction to SoTL:

  • :�� McKinney���s brief collection of definitions
  • :��Bass���s article from invention (1998), an early text of the SoTL canon
  • :�� A helpful introductory essay
  • :��McKinney���s brief overview of possible research methods for SoTL
  • : Felten���s article from the inaugural issue of Teaching & Learning Inquiry, articulating hallmarks of effective SoTL
  • :�� McKinney���s tips for getting published

SoTL Blogs

  • from Illinois State University
  • from the Society for Teaching and Learning in Higher Education
  • from the University of Calgary���s Taylor Institute for Teaching and Learning

Books on Doing SoTL

  • Bishop-Clark, Cathy, & Dietz-Uhler, Beth. (2012).. Sterling, VA: Stylus.
  • Gurung, Regan, & Schwartz, Beth. (2008). >Malden, MA: Wiley-Blackwell.
  • McKinney, Kathleen. (2007). . Bolton, MA: Anker.

Rubric to Evaluate SoTL Institute Applications

Criterion Highest Priority for Funding (4) High Priority for Funding (3) Moderate Priority for Funding (2) Low Priority for Funding (1)
Articulation of Interest The proposal includes a description of a clear, specific area of interest related to teaching/learning at the college/university level The project pertains to learning and/or teaching at the college/university level but needs some clarification. The proposal pertains to learning and/or teaching but it is unclear whether the focus is at the college/university level. The proposal does not indicate an interest in teaching/learning.
Articulation of Goals The applicant clearly outlines achievable goals that can be accomplished within the time frame of the course, and discusses plans for how they will devote adequate time to the institute. The applicant refers to goals and time-management plans, but does not articulate them clearly. The applicant fails to provide goals for the project or goals for time management. The applicant does not provide either goals for the project or goals for time management.
Articulation of Importance The proposal as a whole demonstrates the importance of this SoTL work to the field/勛圖弝け. Great enthusiasm to participate is conveyed. The proposal as a whole somewhat demonstrates the importance of this SoTL work to the field/勛圖弝け. Some enthusiasm to participate is conveyed. The proposal as a whole is limited in demonstrating the importance of this SoTL work to the field/勛圖弝け. Limited enthusiasm to participate is conveyed. The proposal as a whole is limited in demonstrating the importance of this SoTL work to the field/勛圖弝け. Limited enthusiasm to participate is conveyed.