Promoting Equitable and Inclusive STEM Teaching and Learning
Tuesday May 30 ��� Monday June 5
Facilitator: Dr. Sandie Han, CUNYOUSAP Leadership Fellow and Professor of Mathematics at New York City College of Technology
Background: Studies have shown that women and students of color face greater challenges in academic areas of Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics (STEM) and are more likely to give up their STEM studies. [3] Socio-economic, cultural, religious, and linguistic factors all may have played a role in limiting their opportunities so far. Undesirable classroom environments, difficulty transitioning to college for first-generation college students present academic challenges,[2, 6] and lead to high withdrawal rates and failure in many introductory STEM courses. Other sociocognitive factors such as a sense of inadequacy, stereotypes, social and academic isolation, and lack of role models in the discipline further impact STEM persistence.[1, 7]
Research has revealed that the effectiveness of certain intervention strategies such as, academic support, culturally and socially responsive curriculum, peer mentoring, or research mentoring, has helped improve STEM retention.[8, 5]
The U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics Occupational Outlook Handbook identifies jobs in STEM fields as among some of the fastest growing and highest paying occupations.[9] The role of higher education institutions in encouraging STEM learning, diversifying STEM participation and investing in equitable and inclusive STEM pedagogy is identified as critical. CUNYChancellor Matos Felix Rodriguez described the improvement of instructional practices as ���a key part of student success��� so that we have less students dropping out, more minorities and women taking STEM courses ��� all the things that we know happens with better teaching.��� [4]
The CUNYInnovative Teaching Academy (CITA) Summer Institute
The CUNYInnovative Teaching Academy (CITA) Summer Institute aims to enhance equity and inclusion in STEM teaching and learning by examining the framework for building socially and culturally responsive pedagogy that implements the principles of justice, equity, diversity and inclusion (JEDI) principles. The institute seeks faculty who are motivated by a strong desire to explore, develop, implement, or expand on strategies that act to increase participation and work to support the success of undergraduate students in STEM learning, particularly among women, underrepresented minorities, first generation college students, or any students who stand to benefit from the support system.
The summer institute seeks to support faculty in developing projects that implement high impact practices in promoting equitable and inclusive teaching and learning in undergraduate STEM courses. Projects may include curriculum development, new course proposals, course redesign, student learning activities, or student support activities. Collaborative projects are encouraged. Suggested areas of focus may include but are not limited to:
- Incorporating high-impact practices in the teaching and learning of STEM
- Supporting first-year students in STEM classes
- Transforming introductory STEM courses
- Improving STEM learning environment
- Addressing the learning disruption caused by the pandemic and bridging the learning gaps in STEM
- Goal: Promoting high impact, equitable and inclusive STEM teaching and learning to enhance undergraduate student success in STEM
- Participants: The institute seeks STEM faculty participants or 2-member interdisciplinary teams that include one STEM faculty participant. All participants must be full-time CUNYfaculty at professorial or lecturer ranks.
- Proposed idea/project: The institute seeks to support ideas or projects that will incorporate high impact practices in STEM pedagogy and directly impact STEM teaching and learning
- Stipend for Successful Completion of the Institute (See ���Expectations���, ���Deliverables��� and ���Timeline��� below): $1,000 per individual participant (15 – 20 participants)
The Summer institute offers a 5-day intensive professional learning and support workshop to fellows from among STEM faculty experts in 勛圖弝け. The faculty fellows will learn about overcoming implicit bias and decolonizing the curriculum. They will examine, develop and incorporate JEDI or culturally or socially responsive pedagogy into their courses. They will also learn about STEM education funding opportunities for possibly expanding and scaling up their work. Fellows will contribute to the dialogues surrounding issues of equity and inclusion in STEM teaching and learning by sharing their work on the CITA website.
Applications: Applications for ���CUNYSummer Institute Fellow��� are due Friday, March 10, 2023 and selection decisions will be made by March 31, 2023. CUNYSummer Institute Fellows are selected by the (CITA) team. Selection criteria will include the feasibility of project completion and potential for greater impact, along with considerations such as the diversity of CUNYinstitutions, discipline areas, and faculty rank. See the rubric below for application criteria.
We encourage collaborative and/or interdisciplinary projects and will consider funding up to two members working on the same project. The scope of the project and the responsibilities of the team members must be appropriate for a collaborative project.
STEM faculty or interdisciplinary teams of two that include one STEM faculty member are invited to submit proposals. The will ask for the following information:
- Your name, email, college and department information. If this is a collaborative project, please include the name, email, college and department information of your collaborator.
- What you hope to accomplish in the summer institute.
- Project goal: Please discuss the goal of your project as well as any pertinent background information to the project, this may include course(s) you wish to focus on.
- Project description: Please provide information about your plan for carrying out the project including project activities and timeline.
- Project impact: Please discuss the potential of your project to contribute to the achievement of equity and inclusion in STEM teaching and learning.
Expectations: If selected, Summer institute fellows commit to actively participating in the 5-day workshop consisting of two days in-person and three days via Zoom). The workshop will be led by Dr. Sandie Han, and will include invited guest presenters. Reading materials and assignments will be offered, and faculty fellows are expected to share preliminary project ideas on the last day of the workshop. Fellows will continue to work throughout the summer months to develop their projects for implementation in Fall 2023. The workshop facilitators will be available to review the work, provide feedback, and participate in one-on-one discussions throughout the summer.
Deliverables:
- Fellows will develop two activities/assignments/lesson plans. One activity will incorporate best practices to mitigate implicit bias in STEM teaching and learning; the second activity will incorporate JEDI principles and culturally responsive pedagogy into STEM curriculum. These activities will be shared as sample high impact activities on the CITA���s website.
- Fellows will implement their project in the Fall 2023.
- Optional: Fellows will present their project either at their campus or at a 勛圖弝け-wide venue or conference.
Timeline and deliverable for Summer Institute 2023
- March 10: Summer Institute fellowship application due date
- March 31: Notice of acceptance to summer institute
- May 30 ��� June 5: Participation in the 5-day workshop
- June 5: Preliminary presentation to the Summer Institute participants
- June 6: Submission of the first draft of the institute assignments/activities/lesson plans that incorporate best practices.
- Summer 2023: Work in June and July to refine the institute assignments and the project
- July 31: Submission of the final draft of the institute assignments
- Fall 2023: Project implementation and optional presentation at participant���s campus or at a 勛圖弝け-wide venue or conference
- Tentative Agenda for the 5-Day Workshop
- Tuesday May 30, 10:00 AM ��� 2:00 PM (in-person)
The Understanding Implicit Bias Workshop
Bridging the gender gap - Wednesday May 31, 10:00 AM ��� 2:00 PM (in-person)
Decolonizing STEM Curriculum
Social justice and culturally responsive pedagogy - Thursday June 1, 10:00 AM ��� 1:00 PM (online)
Civic engagement and responsibilities
Promoting DEI through Experiential Learning - Friday June 2, 10:00 AM ��� 1:00 PM (online)
Building an equitable and inclusive STEM community of support
Scaling up and broader impacts: grants and publications in STEM education - Monday June 5, 10:00 AM ��� 1:00 PM (online)
Fellow presentations and feedback sharing
Rubric to Evaluate Summer Institute Applications
| Criterion | Highest Priority for Funding (4) | High Priority for Funding (3) | Moderate Priority for Funding (2) | Low Priority for Funding (1) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Articulation of Interest | The proposal includes a description of a clear, specific area of interest related to equity and inclusion in STEM teaching and learning at the college/university level. | The project pertains to STEM teaching and/or learning at the college/university level but needs some clarification. | The proposal pertains to learning and/or teaching but it is unclear about its focus. | The proposal does not indicate an interest in teaching/learning. |
| Articulation of Goals | The applicant clearly outlines achievable goals and time-management plan for carrying out the project. | The applicant refers to goals and time-management plans, but does not articulate them clearly | The applicant provides either goals for the project or time- management plan, but not both. | The applicant does not provide either goals for the project or goals for time management. |
| Articulation of Importance | The proposal as a whole demonstrates the importance of this work to enhancing equity and inclusion in STEM teaching and learning. | The proposal as a whole somewhat demonstrates the importance of this work to enhancing equity and inclusion in STEM teaching and learning. | The proposal as a whole is limited in demonstrating the importance of this work to STEM teaching and learning. | The proposal as a whole provides no evidence of the importance of this work to STEM teaching and learning. |
References
- M. Beasley & M. Fischer. Why they leave: The impact of stereotype threat on the attrition of women and minorities from science, mathematics and engineering majors. Social Psychology of Education, 46 (2012), no. 1, 166���171.
- S. Choy, L. Horn, A. Nu簽ez & X. Chen. Transition to college: What helps at-risk students and students whose parents did not attend college. New Directions in Institutional Research, Vol. 2000, (2000), no. 107, 45-63.
- Y. S. George, D. S. Neale, V. Van Horne & S. M. Malcolm. In pursuit of a diverse science, technology, engineering, and mathematics workforce. Washington, DC (2001):��.
- M. Graham, J. Frederick, A. Byars-Winston, A. Hunter & J. Handelsman. Increasing persistence of college students in STEM. Science, 341 (2013), no. 6153, 1455-1456. DOI: 10.1126/science.1240487.
- G. McCarron & K. Inkelas. The gap between educational aspirations and attainment for first-generation college students and the role of parental involvement. Journal of College Student Development, 47 (2007), no. 5, 534-549.
- M. Ong, C. Wright, L. Espinosa & G. Orfield. Inside the double bind: A synthesis of empirical research on undergraduate and graduate women of color in science, technology, engineering, and mathematics. Harvard Educational Review, 81 (2015), no. 2, 172-209.