Diversity Action Plan, 2012
Assessment & Recommendations
September 14, 2018
In May 2012, The City University of New York launched its Diversity Action Plan (DAP) prepared by the Ad Hoc Committee on Strengthening Faculty Diversity, composed of trustees, chancellery, presidents, and a faculty and student representative. The DAP addressed the major findings and recommendations of the Diversity Study Report conducted by Cambridge Hill Partners, a consulting firm with extensive experience in diversity strategic planning in higher education. The Study identified the need for the University to re-focus its attention on Vision, Leadership, Recruitment, Climate, and Accountability. The DAP also required that each college develop a 5-year Faculty Diversity Strategic Plan (FDSP) with programs that reflected its distinctive characteristics. The Office of Recruitment and Diversity (ORD) was designated to oversee the implementation of the DAP and provided Guidelines for the Faculty Diversity Strategic Plan to assist each campus align its proposed solutions with ³Ô¹ÏÊÓÆµâ€™s DAP. The DAP’s goal was to create a greater degree of transparency, innovation and accountability on faculty diversity.
The purpose of UACD’s Assessment is not to provide an inventory of all steps taken – our overarching objective is to provide information on the programmatic activities of the University and the campuses that enhance the recruitment and retention of a diverse faculty and foster a welcoming and supportive climate for ³Ô¹ÏÊÓÆµâ€™s students and workforce. Our aim is to identify the strategies, including processes, programs and procedures, that the central administration and the colleges implemented to achieve the stated goals of the DAP. Colleges that achieved the greatest success in diversifying their faculty provide exemplary strategies worthy of replication at other schools and are woven into the Assessment’s recommendations.
The Assessment is divided into two parts following ³Ô¹ÏÊÓÆµâ€™s federated organizational structure: the first section evaluates the roles of the Board of Trustees and the Office of the Chancellor, and the second addresses the success the colleges attained in fulfilling the diversity goals. With the focus on recruitment, retention, climate and accountability, key strategies are identified that contributed to their progress. Absent specific metrics in the FDSP Guidelines to determine the DAP’s effectiveness, this report identifies several qualitative and quantitative indicators. Although not all of the best practices highlighted can be validated through measurable outcomes, several metrics served as markers of performance and provided answers to the following questions:
- Which variables impacted implementation and outcomes?
- To what extent did faculty become more diverse?
- Did the campus climate improve?
The analyses include statistical information only about the federally protected racial/ethnic and gender groups. The review of the quantitative reports provided a basis to compare the demographics of the faculty from 2013 to 2017, University-wide and by colleges. Reports about the representation by race/ethnicity and gender within faculty ranks also provided information about the advancement of the federally protected groups within the professoriate. These measures indicated whether efforts to recruit and retain underrepresented groups (URGs) have contributed to the diversification of the faculty.
Reports about the participation of URGs in sponsored programmatic activities were also informative and the analyses of the subsequent rank of participants served as gauges of their persistence/retention and advancement. And thus these metrics indicate the effectiveness of the programs in fulfilling the diversity goals.
In addition, an examination of the results of the utilization analyses by colleges and disciplines from the annual Affirmative Action Plans facilitated the identification of colleges that achieved the greatest success in raising the representation of URGs, and reported no underutilization or experienced the reduction or elimination of the underutilization (disparity between labor market availability and incumbency within affirmative action units/by disciplines).
Based on these criteria, the FDSPs and their annual progress reports of the colleges with the best performances were reviewed to ascertain the strategies/programmatic activities implemented at these campuses to serve as benchmarks of best or emerging practices.
Since 2013, the University has amplified its efforts to sustain its guiding principle of academic excellence imbued with its commitment to diversity, equity and inclusion. CUNYhas adopted a more intentional, coordinated and coherent assessment process enabling it to gauge its overall progress and identify challenges that provide opportunities for additional innovations. The Board of Trustees and the Office of the Chancellor demonstrated the University’s commitment to diversity and academic excellence as indispensable components of ³Ô¹ÏÊÓÆµâ€™s educational mission by reviewing and modifying policies and practices and instituting additional initiatives. The Office of the Chancellor has demonstrated its commitment by providing budgetary support for ongoing projects and new programmatic activities that broaden outreach to URGs, promote the retention and advancement of all faculty and staff, and encourage the production of insightful knowledge engendered through diversity. The Chancellor’s Diversity Fund offered support for campus diversity endeavors and activities and provided resources for University-wide programs: the Faculty Fellowship Publication Program (FFPP), the Diversity Projects Development Fund (DPDF) and three Biennial Faculty Diversity and Inclusion Conferences.
To fulfill its responsibility for coordinating the University’s diversity efforts, including measuring and reporting institutional progress, ORD has provided technical and programmatic assistance to the central administration and colleges, conducted evaluations of CUNYpolicies/practices, and used these results to offer recommendations as data and analyses dictated. The proposed revisions of policies and practices were posited on empirical evidence gleaned from a variety of in-depth statistical reports and solid academic studies. These steps have fostered accountability through thoughtful planning and assessment that built on existing systems, and an improved means for self-assessment by the colleges.
These diversity efforts reinforced the University’s strong foundational aspirations. The willingness to revise the proposed strategies of the DAP, when needed, both by the central administration and at the colleges, including broadening accountability with a more active participation of the presidents, has led to incremental growth in the number of faculty from underrepresented groups.
For example, the ORD Dean collaborated with offices in the Chancellery to strengthen the DAP and actively advocated for new initiatives as a member/consultant of University-wide committees on the Master Plan (The Strategic Framework, Connected ³Ô¹ÏÊÓÆµ), climate (Campus Climate Working Group), the presidential task force on faculty diversity (Faculty Diversity Working Group), Mellon Faculty Diversity Career Enhancement Initiative (FDCEI) and faculty leadership development (³Ô¹ÏÊÓÆµ-Harvard Consortium: Diversifying ³Ô¹ÏÊÓÆµâ€™s Leadership) as authorized by the Chancellor to intentionally align and embed diversity in the University’s goals.
Improvements to the search process have enhanced the colleges’ ability to more effectively recruit faculty from diverse backgrounds. University-wide statistics show that the total number of women increased 6.0%, total minorities experienced a 15.3% growth in numeric representation and the number Italian Americans rose 4.2 percent. The percentage representation of these groups among the new hires was substantial: women accounted for 55.6%; Total Minorities comprised 43.8% and Italian Americans 1.9 percent of the new faculty appointments. But the progress achieved by the colleges is uneven and the lack of representation and continued underutilization of URGs within the colleges’ academic units highlights the need to strengthen the engagement of departments in the recruitment process.
Initiatives that support faculty to achieve permanency indicates that participants in those programs persist, publish, achieve tenure and promotion but comparative data for faculty who do not participate in the initiatives and succeed need to be analyzed. Similar initiatives sponsored by the colleges also merit scrutiny. In addition, it is important to determine what concrete patterns will emerge when cohorts of faculty hired since 2013 are tracked from initial full-time appointment to tenure and by rank.
A comparison of the responses in the 2015 COACHE survey to the responses of the 2011 Cambridge Study provided insights about the extent to which the University environment has become more welcoming. Programmatic activities (DPDF, FFPP, Diversity Conferences and Diversity Dialogues) provided opportunities for knowledge creation as well as collegiality among participants. However, the November 2017 draft report of the Campus Climate Working Group noted that students and faculty reported experiencing feelings of isolation and hostile encounters. The campuses have also conducted numerous activities to improve the environment and several noted the positive results of the COACHE survey. Because of the strong interrelation between the recruitment, retention and advancement of a diverse faculty and the fostering of a supportive, respectful climate, continuing attention to this goal remains a pressing need.
The following criteria were used to identify best-performing colleges:
- A high representation of total minorities;
- Increases in numerical and percentage representation of URGs;
- A large number of new hires who are members of protected racial/ethnic and female groups;
- A low incidence of underutilization of these groups at the department level.
The above indicators determined which progress reports and AAPs were reviewed. Few of the annual progress reports presented concrete measurable outcomes about the steps taken. On the other hand, analyses from the federal annual affirmative action plans contained useful metrics but these data were not linked specifically to the colleges’ diversity strategies. Thus, it is not possible to determine conclusively a correlation between the activities instituted and the positive outcomes attained. However, it is evident that for some practices, an association with results exists and this may serve as a benchmark to other colleges making less progress.
This Assessment profiles practices rather than spotlighting specific colleges. Each college used a variety of best practices recommended in FDSP Guidelines and supported by the academic literature. Among the strategies implemented at the top performing colleges were:
- Alignment and support of campus leadership around diversity goals
- The provision of budgetary support including higher salary offerings to assure acceptance by new hires or retention of faculty with external offers
- The creation of faculty lines
- Integration of diversity process and practices with overall strategic planning
- A refined search process with intensified outreach
- Job descriptions keyed to curricular needs, students’ demographics (e.g., ‘best’ can be defined in a variety of ways)
- Increased oversight of searches either by the Chief Diversity Officer or academic administrator
- Use of AAP analyses to design departmental recruitment plans
- Institution of college-wide or department-based mentoring programs
- Weighing service contributions of URGs in tenure and promotion processes
- Creation/support of Centers of Learning and Teaching Excellence
- Sponsored development and discussions of pedagogical approaches and curricular transformation to meet needs of diverse student body
-  Programmatic activities, e.g., workshops and events to enhance the campus environment and curricular transformation to reflect the programs’ contributions to the diversity efforts.
University-Wide
- Based on ‘lessons learned,’ organize structured approach to support next Diversity Planning cycle to include administration (ECP & HEOs)
- Continue multifaceted and intentional approach to faculty recruitment, retention and advancement through diversity planning integrated into overall strategic planning
- Amplify UACD’s role
- expand membership to include presidents or provosts; specify responsibilities; modify charge to include guiding development and assessment of next planning cycle; develop guidelines for campus/departmental strategic plans
- Provide additional resources to include staff, time, funding and external support of consultants
- Establish well-defined measures to assess effectiveness and to evaluate whether outcomes support ³Ô¹ÏÊÓÆµâ€™s goals
- Expand data analyses of hiring, performance evaluations, promotions, departures (separations)
- Identify key performance indicators: new hires, reduction in separations (non-reappointments and resignations)
- Institutionalize structured mentoring programs
- Revisit the job description/workload of the Chief Diversity Officers (CDOs)
- Expand staff devoted to analytics
Colleges
- Develop departmental (discipline) diversity strategic plans based on analyses of needs; articulate vision, identify long and short-term goals (specific, measurable, attainable, relevant and time-bound)
- Programs & services, demographics, curriculum, teaching, scholarship, mentoring, success rates & advancement, retention, and climate issues
- Provide comprehensive orientation for new faculty hires (reappointment, tenure, promotion)
- Align search process with emerging practices based on evidence-based research.