Established in 1970 by the CUNYBoard of Higher Education,1 the University Advisory Council on Diversity (UACD), formerly known as the University Affirmative Action Committee (UAAC), has been active for 50 years. Its role was reinforced in December 20, 1973 when plaintiffs began a suit against the University alleging violations of Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964. The suit resulted in a Consent Decree, effective September 10, 1984.2
At the May 28, 1985 meeting, the Board of Trustees reaffirmed its commitment to affirmative action as mandated by the statute and went beyond by stating: �����宇he concept of affirmative action, which is not identical to the concept of equal opportunity, is coming under increasing attack.��� The Board further stated, ���Affirmative Action goes beyond equal opportunity principles, goes beyond enlarging an applicant pool, and goes beyond the removal of discriminatory practices. Affirmative Action principles affirm an institution’s commitment to the taking of positive steps that will result in the hiring, tenuring, and promoting, of more minorities and women by setting realistic goals and moving resolutely to achieve them.���3 The Board���s Resolution was based on recommendations submitted by UAAC.
UAAC���s early focus was one of compliance and affirmative action planning and this approach evolved over the years when it moved beyond a review and analysis of workforce representation of underrepresented groups (diversity) to UACD���s broader embrace of the values of equity and inclusion. Over its 50 years, one clear theme is that UAAC/UACD���s overall effectiveness has been enhanced by the support of the Chancellor, the Board of Trustees, the University Faculty Senate, and the Council of Presidents. Further, when DEI principles and practices have been aligned and embedded with the University���s Master Plans, progress accelerates.
1Minutes of Proceedings, December 28, 1970 ���The Chancellor will establish a Committee with university-wide representation to provide policy direction for the University���s Affirmative Action Program��色��
2Melani Consent Decree, September 10, 1984, ���The Chancellor will establish a University Affirmative Action Committee (���UAAC���) of no more than 21 members with University-wide representation to provide policy and programmatic direction for the University���s Affirmative Action Program���.���
3Minutes of Proceedings, May 28, 1985
As with most emerging policies and practices, UAAC recognized that campus partnerships were essential. By 1987, UAAC developed a job description for the Affirmative Action Officer (AAO) and the responsibilities of the Affirmative Action Office. The Office utilized a three-pronged approach:
- To analyze affirmative action data;
- To oversee the development, implementation, and monitoring of the total affirmative action program;
- To submit a written report describing the degree of progress in meeting the college���s goals and timetables, among other things, at least once a year.
In 1988, a charge was created to guide UAAC���s work. The charge was bolstered by the BOTs��� statement at its March 21 meeting: ���The Board of Trustees received a report on pluralism prepared by President Bernard Harleston of City College in June 1987. The report, which included materials submitted by the University Faculty Senate, was discussed by the Trustees. Chancellor Murphy appointed a Council of Presidents Ad Hoc Committee on Pluralism in The City University, which prepared both a statement of principles and recommendations for actions by the Trustees, the Central Administration, and the campuses. The Council of Presidents unanimously endorsed the report at its January meeting.���4
4Minutes of Proceedings, March 21, 1988
Chancellor Ann Reynolds met with UAAC on April 19, 1991. This meeting resulted in a series of proposals that were submitted to the college presidents in January 1992 for review and comment prior to University-wide implementation. UAAC���s work was becoming widely known and respected, garnering an article in the Fall 1996 issue of CUNYMatters, attached.
CUNYleadership was working on a wide variety of diversity initiatives and programming. The concept of ���Inclusive Excellence��� was promoted. Led by a nationally-recognized consultant (Alma Clayton-Pedersen, VP, AACU), a draft strategic plan In Search of the Next Generation, 2008-2012 was developed, a 2008 conference in collaboration with HERC was offered, and the Diversity Projects Development Fund (DPDF) and the Faculty Fellowship Publication Program (FFPP) continued.
The CUNYMaster Plan 2012-2016 Investing in Our Future noted that ���A diverse faculty promotes intellectual vibrancy and enhances the teaching/learning experience. A representative workforce also fosters a climate of inclusion that has a positive impact on student retention.���5 The Plan integrated the goals of the 2012 Diversity Action Plan (DAP) whose objectives were leadership and accountability, recruitment, and climate and retention. Taking into account lessons learned from the current compliance model, UAAC was renamed UACD.
The DAP also involved reorienting the mindset of the AAOs and develop their capacity to become strategic partners as part of the president���s cabinet ��� the AAO title was changed to CDO, Chief Diversity Officer. The CDO plays a lead role in the articulation, promotion and support of DEI values for the campus community. A comprehensive approach is required to embed DEI in the strategic plan so that it is woven into the fabric of the campus climate ��� DEI becomes a public good that pays off in a more competent workforce and better-informed and engaged citizens. Leadership was aligned with UACD, and progress was being made.
Notwithstanding substantive leadership transitions in 2018, UACD persisted. Noting that it was time for review, UACD produced a comprehensive assessment of the DAP which was shared with the Interim Vice Chancellor in January 2019, among others. It is unclear whether this was brought to the attention of the Chancellor or Board of Trustees. One compelling recommendation was the need to embark on the next cycle of DEI strategic planning.
5CUNYMaster Plan 2012-2016, Investing in Our Future, p18
Chancellor Matthew Goldstein stated: ���In recent years, the University reaffirmed its commitment to transformative change to ensure that diversity and inclusion remain central to our core academic values. Several years ago, to provide greater focus on recruiting and retaining a diverse full-time faculty and staff, we established the Office of the University Dean for Recruitment and Diversity. In addition, the innovative programs established as part of the Chancellor’s diversity initiatives attest to our continuing efforts to enhance faculty diversity. To continue building on our successes, last year I appointed a Diversity Study Steering Committee and asked Cambridge Hill Partners, a consulting firm with extensive experience in the areas of diversity and strategic planning in higher education, to work with Vice Chancellor Gloriana Waters and Dean Jennifer Rubain to assess 勛圖弝け’s recruitment and retention challenges and opportunities. Their efforts resulted in the completion of a study that identified best practices to recruit and retain faculty and promote inclusion.
This Diversity Action Plan was prepared by the Ad Hoc Committee on Strengthening Faculty Diversity, a committee composed of trustees, members of the chancellery, presidents, and faculty and student representatives. In her report to the board tonight, Trustee Valerie Lancaster Beal will share with you some of the pertinent points of the plan which is entitled, ���Building on a Strong Foundation: A Strategy for Enhancing 勛圖弝け’s Leadership in the Areas of Faculty Diversity and Inclusion.��� Now and in the years to come, CUNYhas a critical role to play in advancing diversity and inclusion on national and even international levels. The Diversity Action Plan outlines a comprehensive approach to strengthening the University’s leadership role. I am confident that with the unwavering support of the campuses we will move to successfully implement some of these important recommendations.���
Report of Faculty, Staff, and Administration Committee Chair Valerie Lancaster Beal:
���I would like to add my thoughts to the Chancellor’s remarks about the Diversity Action Plan, which Vice Chancellor Gloriana Waters and Dean Jennifer Rubain shared with the Committee in great detail in our meeting on April 2nd. I had the opportunity to work very closely with Vice Chancellor Waters and Dean Rubain on this initiative, and wish to recognize their diligent efforts along with those of the members of the Ad Hoc Committee on Strengthening Faculty Diversity, on which I was privileged to serve.
Developing the Diversity Action Plan involved months of research, analysis and in-depth discussions with interested parties throughout our University community. The Plan’s strategies are designed to promote a supportive work environment and an inclusive University community, which are essential to organizational excellence. The Plan considers diversity and inclusion systematically as well as on the campus level, and addresses the opportunities available to increase faculty diversity and promote inclusion. The Plan acknowledges the impact that governance rules may have on achieving diversity goals, and allows the campuses to develop solutions within their own frameworks.
It also ensures that diversity continues to be a priority because of its elevated standing within the key PMPs. The City University of New York has a history of developing innovative diversity enterprises such as the Black Male Initiative. Equally significant are the successes of existing programs aimed at diversifying the professoriate, including the Latino Faculty Recruitment Initiative, the Decade of Science with its stellar Women in Science component, the Diversity Projects Development Fund and the Faculty Fellowship Publications Program. The Diversity Action Plan builds on those successes by creating new Postdoctoral Fellow and Scholar-in-Residence Programs, which will allow us to leverage the benefits of a University-wide system.
I believe that the CUNYDiversity Action Plan provides the impetus for renewed thinking, energy, and action devoted to the recruiting and hiring of talented and diverse faculty in all disciplines. I urge each of you to read and review its recommendations, and to join me in committing ourselves to sustaining and enhancing 勛圖弝け’s role as one of the most diverse institutions of higher education in the nation.���6
6Minutes of Proceedings, April 30, 2012