Responsible Conduct of Research (RCR)
Responsible conduct of research means conducting research in a way that is honest, trustworthy, reliable and accountable by:
- Claiming credit appropriately – avoiding plagiarism (outright research misconduct) and allocating authorship fairly
- Gathering and analyzing data honestly – avoiding fabrication and falsification (outright research misconduct), avoiding questionable research practices that misrepresent results, and managing data conscientiously
- Knowing and complying with requirements for outside interests and commitments, financial accounting, protection of human subjects, animal welfare, biosafety, and research security
- Acting ethically as a supervisor, supervisee, mentor, mentee, collaborator, and peer reviewer
When research is not carried out with integrity, consequences can include but are not limited to:Ìý
- harm to individuals or society when patient care, government policies, social services, etc. are designed based on such research
- waste of funds and other resources
- loss of credibility and public trust in research and science
- reputational damage to individuals and institutions and
- inaccurate research records that inform future research.
³Ô¹ÏÊÓÆµâ€™s Research Integrity Officers
The President of each CUNYCollege designates a Research Integrity Officer (RIO) for their campus. Each RIO is responsible for promoting the responsible conduct of research through training and education at the college and for implementing ³Ô¹ÏÊÓÆµâ€™s research misconduct policy.
To promote responsible conduct of research, CUNYrequires training by all researchers. View the policy at RCR-
All CUNYfaculty members, staff, postdoctoral scholars, graduate and undergraduate students involved in research are required to complete the CITI RCR training within six weeks of initiating their research (see here for instructions). RCR training certificate will be valid for four years. CUNYresearchers are required to take a refresher CITI RCR training course every four years. In addition to CITI training, live interactive training workshops are offered by the Office of Research at least once per year. Workshop attendance at an in-person training is required for postdoctoral scholars within 12 months of their completing the on-line training. Workshop attendance is encouraged for research faculty, staff and students. Upcoming training is listed on the Training & EducationÌýpage. Contact your college Research Integrity Officer or Eleanor.Knutson@cuny.edu to find out more.
Slides from recent Responsible Conduct of Research workshops can be found here.
Research Misconduct
CUNYaims to foster an environment that promotes the responsible conduct of research, discourages research misconduct, and deals promptly with any allegation of research misconduct. It is ³Ô¹ÏÊÓÆµ’s basic expectation that all research conducted by members of the CUNYcommunity will adhere to the highest ethical and moral standards.
The CUNYPolicy Regarding the Disposition of Allegations of Research Misconduct describes the procedures to be followed in connection with an allegation of research misconduct at ³Ô¹ÏÊÓÆµ. Research misconduct is defined in federal regulations and CUNYPolicyÌý as plagiarism, fabrication, or falsification in proposing or performing research, reviewing research, or in reporting research results. A finding of research misconduct means that (1) There was a significant departure from accepted practices of the relevant research community (2) The misconduct was committed intentionally, knowingly, or recklessly (3) A preponderance of the evidence proves misconduct occurred.
Behaviors that do not constitute research misconduct but show a lack of research integrity include:Ìý
- Questionable research practices; p-hacking (see below)
- Honorary authorship; demanding authorship for previously collected data or materials; denying authorship to those who deserve it
- Noncompliance with regulatory, institutional, or sponsor requirements
- Abusive or irresponsible publication practices by journal editors and peer reviewers
- Failing to make data, code, or other research materials available as specified in institutional or sponsor policies, or standard practices in the field
- Neglectful or exploitative supervision in research
- Inadequate institutional policies to foster research integrity and address research misconduct allegations ​
Questionable research practices are misleading statistical analyses and reporting that fall short of fabrication or falsification, but that inflate the significance of the results (also called p-hacking)
·¡³æ²¹³¾±è±ô±ð²õ:Ìý
Failing to report:
- all dependent measures
- all conditions
- negative results
Altering the research plan by
- Collecting more data than planned if results are not statistically significant
- Stopping data collection as soon as results are statistically significant
- Excluding data without scientific justification
- Changing or adding hypotheses after analyzing data (HARKing – Hypothesis After Results are Known)
This policy describes the procedures to be followed by CUNYin connection with an allegation of research misconduct.Ìý View the Policy at .
Resources to Support and Provide Training in Responsible Research Practices
Provided here are links to general resources for CUNYresearchers interested in learning more about how to conduct research responsibly. Also provided are resources for delivering training in responsible conduct of research. These materials can be used by CUNYResearch Integrity Officers, College leadership, faculty instructors, and mentors to provide ongoing training in responsible research practices. If you are aware of resources not listed here or encounter broken links, etc. please contact Ellie Knutson at Eleanor.Knutson@cuny.edu
-
- Professional Skills for Researchers Coaching Program
- Free tools to download:
- The Lab Leadership and Management Best Practices Checklist
- The SMART Approach – guidelines for professional decision-making
- Bioethics Research Center at the Washington University in St. Louis
General Resources
- at the Washington University in St. Louis
Research Misconduct
ORI Videos:
The United States Government awards more than $500 billion in Federal Assistance Agreements, most commonly in the forms of grants.Ìý This vignette introduces issues related to falsifying test results or other data in a grant applications in order to receive additional funding for future research/studies.
This video highlights ethical decision making; a faculty adviser suggests that students should break research protocol to get the desired results.
This video introduces the concept of plagiarism and the implications of plagiarism on the collegiate level.
Have you ever found yourself rushing to complete a project? This video sets up issues related to survey practices, falsifying data, and the importance of time management.
ORI Infographics:
Case Studies from ORI:
Data Management
Video:
- University of Nebraska-Lincoln:
Case Studies from ORI:
Responsible Authorship and Publication
Videos:
- ORI Video: . Missing authors and changes to author order, this video sets up a common authorship dilemma, and just how tricky it can be to resolve.
- University of Nebraska-Lincoln:
ORI Infographic:
Case Studies and Role Play from ORI:
Peer Review
Video:
- University of Nebraska-Lincoln:
Case Studies and Role Play from ORI:
Conflicts of Interest
Video:
- University of Nebraska-Lincoln:
Case Studies from ORI:
Role Play:
Mentor/Mentee Responsibilities and Relationships
ORI Video:
This video introduces the impact of mentorship effects on young researchers and the importance of providing support and advice to guide mentee’s professional development.
ORI Infographic:
Case Studies and Role Play from ORI:
Collaborative Science
Case Studies and Role Play from ORI:
Laboratory Safety
Role Play
Biosafety
- Biosecurity and Dual Use Research,
Human SubjectsÌý
Role Play
Animal Subjects
Role Play
Social Responsibility: Scientists as responsible members of society
Case Studies and Role Play from ORI:
Contemporary ethical issues in biomedical research
- Stem Cell Research:
Research Security
Training:
-
- What is Research Security
- Disclosure
- Manage and Mitigate Risk
- International Collaboration
Export Controls
Videos, US Department of Commerce, Bureau of Industry and Standards: