BRES Reflections On The Significance of a Ph.D. Program in Black, Race, and Ethnic Studies
As states across the United States begin to ban DEI programs in their colleges and universities, we asked the BRES Fellows to reflect on why a Ph.D. Program in Black, Race and Ethnic Studies is important to our society. We also asked for them to share how their scholarship is currently contributing to it.
“In these moments, it is important to become a critical voice of contemporary injustice and state violence all over the world.”
Q: How significant is a Ph.D. program in Black, Race and Ethnic Studies and how is your scholarship contributing to it today?
One of the most intellectually rewarding experiences at CUNYwas working with Marc Edelman as my advisor, an utmost expert on Central America and Critical Agrarian Studies. The title of my dissertation is “The Anti-Plantation Uprising: Indigenous Kinship, Territories, and Communal Politics in Guatemala, 1966-1982.� In this work, I rethink Maya indigenous politics through visual anthropology, ethnography of memory, and communal struggles during Guatemala’s Cold War. Currently, I am an assistant professor at the College of William and Mary’s Department of Anthropology and Native Studies Minor. I teach courses like “Indigenous Politics and Plantations in Latin America,� “Exploring Kinship,� and “Visual Anthropology in the Americas.�
In 2023, I was part of ³Ô¹ÏÊÓÆµâ€™s Black, Race and Ethnic Studies (BRES) fellows. There, I met colleagues working on rethinking critical theory and the challenges humanity faces in the current world crisis. In these moments, it is important to become a critical voice of contemporary injustice and state violence all over the world. The BRES doctoral program could foster and teach past and current critical traditions at CUNYand become a voice that shows the interrelation between capitalism, racial formation, and the possibility of rethinking – nowadays and under new historical circumstances – revolutionary utopia.
“Black Studies plays an integral role in academic freedom, expression, and understanding of how the past influences the present and those who control the present shape the future.”
Q: How significant is a Ph.D. program in Black Studies and how is your scholarship contributing to it today?
Black Studies plays an integral role in academic freedom, expression, and understanding of how the past influences the present and those who control the present shape the future. Moreover, Black Studies, broadly, has shaped my academic career. While an undergraduate student I was a double-major with Africana Studies and political science. While in graduate school, pursuing my doctoral degree in sociology at the Graduate Center-City University of New York, I earned an Africana Studies Certificate. In both instances, these endeavors broadened the number of theorists, frameworks, and scholarship, giving me a richer and more nuanced way of articulating the social problems and structural inequalities within my field of research. Often, traditional academic disciplines, even with the best of intentions, continue to center White scholars and, in some cases, Black and other scholars of color are pushed to the margins. However, Black Studies shifts our lens by moving, “from the margin to center.�1
The tradition of Black Studies does not simply qualify Black voices based on credentials but rather through epistemology and the lived experience. My scholarly work focuses on the U.S. criminal legal system, specifically issues surrounding the mass imprisonment of American residents, which are disproportionately Black, and the collateral consequences in the reentry process having been incarcerated. Much of my work relies on text from individuals such as Malcolm X, George Jackson, and Assata Shakur,2 who have all been justice-impacted individuals. The former two, Malcolm X and George Jackson, became radicalized while imprisoned, showing that even within these institutions of despair, folks can find liberation. I utilize these frameworks in the scholarship I produce and the work I do with justice-impacted youth who are incarcerated. Black Studies has provided me the tools to empower the youth to situate, contextualize, and articulate their experiences. Ultimately, Black Studies is not simply an academic discipline but a liberatory praxis.
1 bell hooks, 2000. Feminist Theory: From Margin to Center (Boston, MA: South End Press) 2 For more on these people, see: Malcolm X-The Autobiography of Malcolm X; George Jackson-Soledad Brothers; Assata Shakur-Assata: An Autobiography.
Judy-Lynne Peters, Ph.D., Assistant Professor, John Jay College of Criminal Justice on Black Studies
“The search for racial justice will never succeed until the entire history of this country is on the table.�
Q: How significant is a Ph.D. program in Black Studies and how is your scholarship contributing to it today?
Documenting slavery restores the dignity, humanity, and history to people who, solely on the basis of the color of their skin and their assumed inferiority, were kidnapped from their homeland and subjected to lives of involuntary servitude. The Northeast Slavery Records Index (NESRI) was established to advance justice and equity by bringing their stories to light. NESRI is an online searchable compilation of records that identify individual enslaved persons and enslavers in the Northeast United States. NESRI indexes census records, slave trade transactions, cemetery records, birth certifications, manumissions, ship inventories, newspaper accounts, private narratives, legal documents and many other sources. We serve scholars of slavery by providing access to records that they could not otherwise efficiently locate. NESRI restores names and identities to many enslaved people and holds their enslavers to account.
This research has never been more important. In a country where seven states have banned critical race theory–and another sixteen are considering doing so, despite the fact that it is not taught in any public school in the US—the search for racial justice will never succeed until the entire history of this country is on the table. Black history is American history. The need for more Black history scholars has never been more critical. There is a critical need to continue to recover, index, and, when necessary, digitize more records.
We will continue to seek out opportunities to participate in BRESI initiatives. Our BRESI experience was enhanced by our shared commitment to advancing racial and social justice. It boosted our profile within CUNYand energized our determination to position NESRI as the hub of black history research in The City University of New York
“Black and Ethnic Studies, as an interdisciplinary and academic discipline is significant in these very perilous times where we are currently witnessing, across the country, the systematic dismantling of curricula, programs, and services that are focused on the lived experiences, history, and genealogy of the African and Black diaspora.”
Q: How significant is Black Studies and how is your scholarship contributing to it today?
Black & Ethnic Studies, as an interdisciplinary and academic discipline is significant in these very perilous times where we are currently witnessing, across the country, the systematic dismantling of curricula, programs, and services that are focused on the lived experiences, history, and genealogy of the African & Black diaspora. It is important that programs such as ³Ô¹ÏÊÓÆµâ€™s Black, Race, & Ethnic Studies Initiative Council (BRESI) and Collaboration Hub support and contribute to the larger body of contextual information that is based on academic research and frameworks that rigorously examines the intersectionality of race, colorism, gender, sexuality, religion, and decolonization, among other praxes, that help to shape policy, advocacy, and curriculum.
As a BRES Curriculum Development Faculty Fellow, my collaborative scholarship will help to contribute to BRESI Â and the Collaboration Hub with the development of a course centered on anti-racist methodologies and research ethics for Black participatory community engaged research which supports narratives that are rooted and based on ancestral and generational cognizance, lived experiences, and chronicled history that is embedded in social justice from a racial and ethnic perspective that will help to deepen our understanding of diverse perspectives and converging viewpoints.
“I believe that gender and women’s studies are integral to understand social structures and systematic oppression faced by racialized groups.�
Q: How significant is a Ph.D program in gender studies and how is your scholarship contributing to it today?
From Sojourner Truth’s early intersectional activism, to Fannie Lou Hammer’s concept of “double jeopardy,� Black women’s activism and organic theories have long established the importance of intersectional analysis of oppression and struggles for freedom. Similarly, socialist feminist theories of production and social reproduction, indigenous women scholar activists’ writings on de-colonization of land and knowledge production, as well as anti-imperialist third world feminist theories of liberation have all put forward a simultaneous critique of intersectional oppression, and argued for the agency of women in liberating themselves and their societies. I believe that gender and women’s studies are integral to understand social structures and systematic oppression faced by racialized groups, as well as to reveal that women and their intersectional organizing and activism have been at the core of racial justice and anti-colonial movements.
My research on colonialism, state violence, and social movements in the Middle East are highly informed by intersectional theories and organizing. I am specifically working on two different projects with this focus at the moment. The first project looks at intersectional and anti-imperialist notions of feminism, as well as internationalist solidarity across different feminist movements. The second related project looks at the development and transformations of the Kurdish women’s movement since the colonization of the Kurdish people in the early 20th century to the women-led revolution of Rojava (Western Kurdistan/North-East Syria) and to the spread of the jin-jiyan-azadi (women-life-freedom) movement from Rojhelat (Eastern Kurdistan) to the rest of Iran. As women’s resistances grew into a full-fledged organized effort in the Kurdish Freedom Movement in the 1990s, I pay specific attention to women’s self-organizing, as well as the role this type of organizing plays in shaping the broader Kurdish movement. I believe that the construction of multiple spaces for self-organizing, from self-defense to education, have been critical in transforming the Kurdish Movement. In my future research I aim to look at theories and practices of women’s self-organizing and self-defense in other anti-colonial movements and contexts, and also look into practices of solidarity-building between these movements.
Women and Gender Studies programs are crucial in allowing us to recognize how gender dynamics shape our societies. They offer us a lens from which to challenge the pervasive, often naturalized (that is to say, unquestioned) power dynamics that discriminate against women and other marginalized groups.�
Q: How significant is a Ph.D. program in gender studies and how is your scholarship contributing to it today?
Women and Gender Studies programs are crucial in allowing us to recognize how gender dynamics shape our societies. They offer us a lens from which to challenge the pervasive, often naturalized (that is to say, unquestioned) power dynamics that discriminate against women and other marginalized groups. With a strong antiracist and environmental ethos, Women’s Studies pursue social justice above all: a world in which everyone can live and thrive to their full potential, regardless of gender and sexual identity, race, class, ability, religion, age, weight, and physical appearance. By amplifying the voices of those who have been relegated to the margins, Women’s Studies decenter hegemonic ways of perceiving the world in order to acknowledge, reverse, and redress discriminatory practices and, in so doing, empower those traditionally ignored in mainstream culture and discourse.
In my own work as a literary studies scholar, a feminist intersectional perspective has been central in critically examining genderized and racialized inequities: What ideological mechanisms become activated to still dismiss the trafficking of more than 200,000 (mostly Korean) “comfort women� who were forced into sexual slavery during World War II? How do we explain the alarming numbers of feminicides of indigenous women and girls at the US Mexican border during the 1990s, and the little attention and action they garnered in comparison to male drug-related deaths? What role do race and gender play in transnational migration today, and how is trafficking discourse (mis)appropriated to legitimize anti-immigration agendas and exclusion? How can gender-based violence, especially of a sexual nature, be represented aesthetically and ethically? These are some of the questions that continue to inform my research.
It is clear to me that ignoring these power dynamics will always render an incomplete picture of problems that, in fact, demand intersectional approaches towards inclusive and equitable solutions.
“I have been inspired the most by the personal stories of my students who, regardless of their racial identities, shared the impacts of taking an Asian/Asian American studies course and how it helped shape their identities and find their voices.�
Q: How significant is a Ph.D. program in Asian Studies and how is your scholarship contributing to it today?
As an immigrant from Taiwan, I consider myself extremely lucky to teach at the Department of Ethnic and Race Studies (DERS) at Borough of Manhattan Community College (BMCC), where diversity and inclusivity are not policies or concepts, but the ethos and legacy inherited from the Civil Rights movement in the 1960s-1970s. To be more specific, Asian/Asian American Studies (ASN), along with other ethnic studies, found its home at BMCC because the students demanded to have them in the college president’s office in 1970.1 Thanks to the unwavering efforts and ongoing endeavors of the students, staff, faculty, and others who helped establish the Ethnic and Race Studies as an academic department, I am now part of the team that offer ASN courses such as Chinese Culture and History, Asian American History, Introduction to the Middle East, Asian Americans in NYC, and Asian American Literature.
With the interdisciplinary approach and my performing arts background at the core of my pedagogy, I continue to learn from the works by experts across the fields. However, I must say that I have been inspired the most by the personal stories of my students who, regardless of their racial identities, shared the impacts of taking an ASN course and how it helped shape their identities and find their voices. Attempting to broaden and deepen such impacts, I have intentionally and strategically incorporated arts and cultural activates into my curriculum so that the knowledge my students gained can be shared more easily among their communities. And that is why I am excited that a new course I developed and titled Asian American Activism and Creative Expression is making its way to get the ³Ô¹ÏÊÓÆµâ€™s final approval. I look forward to exploring how arts and arts activism can help tell the diverse stories of Asians and Asian Americans.
1 https://www.diverseeducation.com/social-justice/article/15383854/bmcc-conference-celebrates-50-years-of-ethnic-studies
A deficient historical knowledge of Asian Americans shrouds the contributions made by members of this population and neglects the historical legacies of racism and how they persist today.
Q: How significant is a Ph.D. program in Asian Studies and how is your scholarship contributing to it today?
On May 17, 1954, Brown v. Board of Education ended state-sanctioned school segregation by race. As we celebrate the 70th anniversary of school integration, do we recognize the path that led to this momentous case? Sixty-nine years before Brown, in 1885, there was Tape v. Hurley where a Chinese American family challenged race-based exclusion from a predominantly White school in San Francisco, California. Although the Tape family did not win their case, this precedent, a consequential footnote of US educational history, is analogous to the experiences, value, and place of Asian Americans in this country.
Why is it significant to know that some Chinese American children – like their Black/African American counterparts – also experienced school segregation? In short, learning this history provides a better understanding of Asian American experiences. A deficient historical knowledge of Asian Americans shrouds the contributions made by members of this population and neglects the historical legacies of racism and how they persist today. For example, restrictive citizenship laws targeting Asian immigrants leaned on stereotypes of them as unassimilable foreigners. Referencing the Chinese migrants as “celestialsâ€� in the 19th century is not unlike wondering where an American person of Asian descent is “really fromâ€� in the 21stÌý³¦±ð²Ô³Ù³Ü°ù²â.
My research on the professions seeks to make visible the experiences of Asian American professionals and describes how racism is coded differently for different racialized groups. Holding constant the professions, I interrogate how implicit biases and discrimination persist in these elite spaces for Asian American physicians, attorneys, and professors. Because we – as a society – do not know much about Asian Americans, we do not yet know how to identify prejudice toward members of this community. We also do not know how to advocate when we witness discrimination, and we are often unaware of ourselves falling into the traps of assuming Asian Americans are foreign-born, passive, math whizzes. Ignorance allows inequalities to persist. Uplifting experiences of Asian Americans allows us to truly understand race and how racism may vary among racialized groups.
“In these moments, it is important to become a critical voice of contemporary injustice and state violence all over the world.”
“Black Studies plays an integral role in academic freedom, expression, and understanding of how the past influences the present and those who control the present shape the future.”
“The search for racial justice will never succeed until the entire history of this country is on the table.�
“Black and Ethnic Studies, as an interdisciplinary and academic discipline is significant in these very perilous times where we are currently witnessing, across the country, the systematic dismantling of curricula, programs, and services that are focused on the lived experiences, history, and genealogy of the African and Black diaspora.”
“I believe that gender and women’s studies are integral to understand social structures and systematic oppression faced by racialized groups.�
Women and Gender Studies programs are crucial in allowing us to recognize how gender dynamics shape our societies. They offer us a lens from which to challenge the pervasive, often naturalized (that is to say, unquestioned) power dynamics that discriminate against women and other marginalized groups.�
“I have been inspired the most by the personal stories of my students who, regardless of their racial identities, shared the impacts of taking an Asian/Asian American studies course and how it helped shape their identities and find their voices.�
A deficient historical knowledge of Asian Americans shrouds the contributions made by members of this population and neglects the historical legacies of racism and how they persist today.