Last Updated November 14, 2019

 

This Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ) document is intended to provide further detail related to the Academic Policy Brief OAA-19-01 and Technical Guidance Memorandum OAA-19-01 released on September 4, 2019 The content below reflects responses to questions ³Ô¹ÏÊÓÆµâ€™s Office of Academic Affairs (OAA) has received from a range of college and Central Office stakeholders regarding the planned implementation of a proficiency index and other topics related to ³Ô¹ÏÊÓÆµâ€™s comprehensive developmental education reforms.

For the purposes of implementation, these FAQs are part of official OAA policy regarding the proficiency index and corequisite education. OAA will update the FAQs on a regular basis as we continue to receive feedback from stakeholders.

If you have questions about the proficiency index and/or practices and policies related to corequisite and developmental education courses, please contact academicaffairs@cuny.edu.

Introduction to ³Ô¹ÏÊÓÆµâ€™s Developmental Education Reforms

In the fall of 2015, then University Provost Vita Rabinowitz convened a CUNYTask Force on Developmental Education to review all aspects of the University’s developmental education practices and make recommendations.1 The Task Force was inspired by a wave of new research and innovative practices related to developmental education, both from across the country and taking place within ³Ô¹ÏÊÓÆµ, and the sheer scale of developmental education at ³Ô¹ÏÊÓÆµ. At that time, approximately 20,000 students each fall—more than half of all freshmen who started at CUNYcolleges—were assigned to developmental education in at least one subject, especially mathematics. In associate programs, 74 percent of freshmen were assigned to developmental education in math in fall 2015, 23 percent in reading, and 33 percent in writing.

The national literature also strongly suggested that many students do not benefit from, and may even be harmed by, being assigned to conventional developmental courses. For example, at ³Ô¹ÏÊÓÆµ, students who place into math developmental education are about half as likely as other students to complete an associate degree within three years. Developmental education comes at a high personal and financial cost to students: Traditional developmental courses do not advance students toward a degree, but they do consume time and financial resources. Because black and Hispanic students are almost twice as likely as white and Asian students to be assigned to developmental education at ³Ô¹ÏÊÓÆµ, developmental policies can contribute to racial gaps in educational attainment.

The Task Force launched a thorough and wide-ranging review of ³Ô¹ÏÊÓÆµâ€™s developmental education policies and practices and made many recommendations. Since that time, the staff of OAA has been working to implement the Task Force’s recommendations while integrating promising practices and lessons from research that have become available since the Task Force concluded its work.

1 The 19 members of the Task Force included the faculty chairs or co-chairs of the Mathematics, Reading, and English Discipline Councils, four chief academic officers from colleges offering developmental instruction and two from senior colleges, and members of OAA. The Task Force’s report is available online.

General Questions

Currently, applicants who meet benchmark scores on the SAT, ACT, or Regents exams are considered proficient and eligible to enroll in credit-bearing courses in the subject (math or English).2 In the past, applicants who did not meet those benchmarks were required to take placement tests at a CUNYcollege to determine whether they were eligible for credit-bearing courses or required to complete developmental interventions.

Under ³Ô¹ÏÊÓÆµâ€™s new developmental education assignment policy, students will still be considered proficient if they meet the benchmark scores on the SAT, ACT, or Regents exams. Rather than using placement tests for applicants who do not meet the benchmark scores, CUNYwill now use a proficiency index that combines overall high school grade point average with SAT and/or Regents exam scores.3 The proficiency index will allow the University to determine whether the applicant has a good chance of earning a C or better in a credit-bearing math or English course without any additional support. Scores on the proficiency index, rather than scores on placement tests, will be used to make the final determination of whether students are proficient or not and guide them to appropriate levels of developmental interventions.

2 See the CUNYtesting webpage for the benchmark scores on each exam that demonstrate proficiency.

3 Note that while ACT benchmark scores may be used to demonstrate proficiency, ACT scores are not yet used in the proficiency index because CUNYhas insufficient data on their relationship to performance in CUNYgateway math and English courses. Historically, very few CUNYapplicants have submitted ACT scores rather than SAT scores for admission.

In 2016, ³Ô¹ÏÊÓÆµâ€™s Developmental Education Task Force recommended that CUNYincorporate high school grades and multiple measures of students’ skills into determinations of proficiency, following emerging . Since that recommendation, OAA staff have been analyzing how well various indicators predict students’ success in college courses and developing an efficient method for incorporating grades and multiple measures into the new ³Ô¹ÏÊÓÆµfirst admissions system. Throughout the development process, OAA staff met with college administrators, faculty, and staff to discuss plans for the new proficiency index and respond to their questions and concerns.

The new proficiency index predicts students’ success in credit courses more accurately than placements tests have done. It also removes the barrier of placement testing from the enrollment process and allows prospective students to learn their proficiency status earlier than they have been able to in the past, which will give them more time to learn about and participate in low or no-cost interventions before matriculation.

The use of this index will inform our efforts to replace outdated remediation strategies with more effective corequisite math or English courses, or high-quality, targeted interventions before matriculation.

There are separate proficiency indexes for math and English. Both use information that is already part of the application for freshman admissions: student’s overall high school GPA at the time of application, SAT scores, and Regents scores.2 If applicants have both SAT scores and Regents scores, the index formula will use both scores, but if they have only Regents or only SAT, it will use whichever is available. If applicants have only high school grades, the index will use only grades for placement. High school grades have the greatest impact on the proficiency indexes because research has proven they have a stronger relationship to college grades than the standardized test scores do, but higher test scores can help offset lower grades and vice versa.

2 See the CUNYtesting webpage for the benchmark scores on each exam that demonstrate proficiency.

Despite differences in grading practice among high schools, extensive research at ³Ô¹ÏÊÓÆµ and has found that high school grades do a better job of predicting grades in college courses than standardized test scores. High school grades are also significantly better for predicting persistence into a second year and on to college graduation. The new CUNYproficiency index uses both grades and standardized test scores, so if an applicant attends a high school with strict grading standards, their test scores can boost their overall proficiency index value.

Although the relationship between high school grades and college grades is indeed stronger, standardized test scores still have some value in predicting performance in college courses. Given that, we had two related motivations for continuing to recognize these single-exam exemptions: First, our partners at the NYC Department of Education (DOE) strongly favor continuing to have clear markers of proficiency on the SAT or Regents exams that students can aspire to and meet while in high school. Second, continued use of the Regents and SAT/ACT exemptions provides some continuity with the current system and reduces uncertainty for applicants and high schools.

At either 60 or 65, the chances are substantially better that students will succeed in a first entry-level course rather than fail it. (Note that the index predicts how likely the student is to earn a C or better in a first entry-level course — students will have an even higher probability of simply passing the course.) These dividing lines are also roughly consistent with past practice (OAA used a 65 percent probability of success as the target for setting cut scores on Accuplacer exams). Until more corequisite courses are available, OAA research suggests that more students around these borderlines will benefit from gaining direct access to a credit-bearing course than from enrolling in a traditional remedial course. The proficiency index cut scores are different in math and English because OAA has determined that optimal balances between overall probabilities of success and failure are different between those subjects.

These cut-points are subject to possible adjustment as we monitor their impact and the availability of high-quality corequisite and developmental interventions.

No. Developmental education reforms do not affect the requirements for passing credit-bearing courses, accumulating credits, or graduating from a CUNYcollege and so do not represent any lowering of academic standards. The reforms are designed to more accurately and efficiently identify students who are likely to succeed in credit courses without developmental support and improve the quality of developmental education for students who are likely to benefit from additional support. Students will still be required to meet the existing learning standards in order to earn credit in their courses and satisfy graduation requirements.

This change in determining proficiency does not necessarily change colleges’ use of tests to place students within credit-bearing course sequences. Individual colleges may still administer local placement tests to determine which credit-bearing courses a student should take (e.g., which level of a foreign language, a pre-calculus or calculus class). Exams for placement within the credit-bearing sequence will be scheduled and coordinated by individual colleges.

Because of changes in the Accuplacer exams, colleges will no longer use the College-Level Math test to place students into credit-bearing math courses. A working group of math faculty convened by OAA has recommended practices that colleges can use to place students into STEM math courses based on their high school math grades and test scores without additional placement testing. These recommended placement practices are separate from proficiency index calculations, but based on similar principles and data.

The ESL Discipline Council voted to continue using the CATW for ESL placement purposes through spring 2020 while it works with OAA to develop better ESL placement tools. The general proficiency index, which relies heavily on high school grades, cannot be used to assess the English proficiency of students who attended high school in a non-English speaking environment unless they also have an English Regents exam score. The ESL Discipline Council and OAA were not able to develop feasible alternatives to the CATW by fall 2019. Colleges may also administer the CATW exam to students flagged by the admissions process as potential ESL who do not meet the English proficiency index cut score to determine appropriate placement in the ESL developmental course sequence. Note that there is no change in developmental education testing exemptions for ESL students: students who meet proficiency benchmarks on the English SAT, ACT, or English Regents exam will continue to be deemed English proficient, regardless of where they attended high school.

No, instruction in English as a second language (ESL) is distinct from developmental education in English. ESL students are foreign language learners who require additional language training in English, separate from the supports for developing academic literacy and writing skills that student may get in regular developmental English courses or interventions. OAA’s guidance on eliminating zero-credit remedial courses in math and English by fall 2022 does not apply to ESL courses.

Although incoming student placement testing is being replaced by the proficiency index. there are some exams that the Testing Office will still administer. In addition to the CATW for ESL placement, the office will continue to administer the University final exams in top-level developmental math and writing interventions. The Ability-to-Benefit test, used for NYS TAP eligibility, will also continue to be administered by the Testing Office.

In most cases, no. Each CUNYsenior college has admission requirements and admission review processes, which are separate from determinations of proficiency. In most cases, students have to meet proficiency standards in math and English for admission into a bachelor’s program, but merely meeting the proficiency standards does not guarantee admission to a bachelor’s program. ³Ô¹ÏÊÓÆµâ€™s senior colleges also have special programs for admitting some students who have not yet met proficiency, but show potential to succeed in college, such as the SEEK program. The proficiency index will not impact admission through these programs.

Not necessarily. In the first term of the index’s implementation, we anticipate that the percentage of incoming students assigned to developmental education will be similar to the proportion assigned to developmental education in recent years (about the same as in the previous year for English and between the rates of assignment in 2017 and 2018 in math). Cut points on the indexes are subject to possible adjustment by OAA based on their impact, the availability of high-quality corequisite and developmental interventions, and consultation with college stakeholders.

OAA will monitor pass rates in credit-bearing courses and evaluate how well the proficiency index predicts performance in those courses, adjusting elements of the index as needed. OAA will also monitor retention rates (to the second year) and seek feedback from colleges about implementation and impacts. OAA will judge the overall success of the proficiency index implementation, and broader developmental education reforms, based on the percentage of each associate freshman cohort that earns gateway course credits within their first year of entry and on the percentage on track for graduation (earned at least 20 credits, in good academic standing, and retained into the second year).

Index Implementation and Proficiency Status

The new proficiency status will be available when CUNYevaluates the student’s application for admission. Students will be able to see if they have met proficiency standards in the ³Ô¹ÏÊÓÆµfirst Student Center. If a student has met proficiency standards, there will be labels that say “Math Proficient,â€� “Read Proficient,â€� and “Write Proficientâ€� in the Milestones section of the Student Center. If they have not met proficiency standards, the Milestones section will be empty.

Students who are not deemed proficient at point of admission will have several different options for achieving proficiency, which vary by college offerings (e.g., varieties of corequisite courses and targeted USIP offerings, in addition to Math Start and CUNYStart). Prospective students should meet with an advisor at their chosen college as soon as possible to discuss which developmental options are best for them. It is also crucial for students to discuss their intended major with an advisor to determine which math courses are required so that they can enroll in the appropriate corequisite course or other intervention. Science, engineering, and economics majors will all require algebra and calculus courses. Social science majors, like psychology and sociology, will likely require statistics rather than algebra. Humanities majors, like English, music, or art, will likely require a more general mathematical or quantitative reasoning course.

Training for admissions and enrollment staff on the campuses, including explanations for how the proficiency index will run for direct admits, will be offered in early fall in preparation for the spring 2020 admissions cycle.

The answer depends on how and when proficiency status is assigned. Historically, students who met ³Ô¹ÏÊÓÆµâ€™s English proficiency benchmark scores on the SAT, ACT or Regents exams were deemed proficient in both reading and writing. Students who did not meet English proficiency benchmark scores were required to take separate placement tests for reading and writing. Although most students assigned to developmental education in reading were also assigned to writing and vice versa, it was possible for a student to pass the placement test in one subject but not the other.

Going forward, new students who meet the English proficiency benchmarks on the SAT, ACT, or Regents exam, or meet the English proficiency index cut score, will be deemed proficient in both reading and writing and receive both proficiency milestones. However, students who are not proficient may still participate in separate reading and writing interventions if their college chooses to offer them separately. Some colleges’ developmental education courses and CUNYStart integrate reading and writing developmental instruction and therefore can lead to proficiency determinations in both areas, while other courses and interventions are specific to reading or writing and lead to a proficiency determination in only that area. OAA encourages colleges to consider offering integrated reading and writing supports.

Continuing students who have achieved proficiency in either reading or writing, but not both, will not automatically be granted proficiency in the other area as a result of these policy changes. OAA encourages colleges to allow such students to enroll in corequisite courses where they have a chance to both demonstrate proficiency and earn gateway course credit.

UPDATED NOVEMBER 14, 2019

For Spring 2020, applicants with HSE credentials will be assessed for English and math proficiency using a version of the proficiency index that calculates index values based on subtest scores on HSE exams. For English, scores on the Test Assessing Secondary Completion (TASC) Reading test or the GED Reasoning through Language Arts test will be used to calculate proficiency index values. For math, scores on the TASC Mathematics or GED Mathematical Reasoning exam will be used to calculate proficiency index values. The proficiency index values determined for HSE recipients can then be used to guide students to appropriate developmental interventions in the same way the proficiency index values are used for high school diploma recipients who have not demonstrated proficiency.

HSE recipients who previously attended high school before transitioning to an HSE program may also demonstrate proficiency through the SAT, ACT, or Regents exam benchmark scores and are encouraged to include those scores in their applications. This is especially important for applicants who have Regents-based exemptions to the TASC Mathematics or TASC Reading exam who will not have TASC scores to be used in the proficiency index. The easiest way for an applicant who took Regents exams at a NYC DOE high school to make those scores available to CUNYadmissions staff is for the applicant to enter their NYC DOE OSIS number on their CUNYapplication. The OSIS number gives CUNYaccess to the applicant’s official high school transcript, including Regents exam scores.

We expect that the percentage of HSE applicants assigned to math and English developmental education under the new index formulas for spring 2020 will be very similar to the percentage previously assigned via placement tests. OAA will reassess proficiency formulas for applicants with HSE credentials for future terms as we gather more data on the relationship between HSE exam scores and other indicators and performance in CUNYcourses.

CUNYwill use the high school GPA and SAT scores submitted as part of the application for admission to calculate the proficiency index. Either the Common Core-aligned or traditional Algebra 1 and English Composition Regents exam scores can be used in the proficiency index. Note that most applicants to CUNYwho have been out of high school for several years apply as transfer students with previous college credit rather than as first-time freshmen. There is no change to ³Ô¹ÏÊÓÆµâ€™s proficiency policy for transfer credits: Applicants who transfer in three or more credits in a subject will be deemed proficient and will not be assessed using the proficiency index.

Of students over the age of 25 who enter as first-time freshmen, OAA’s simulations show that the math proficiency index resulted in the same placement determination for about 90 percent of students as the placement tests did. Nonetheless, it is reasonable to expect that students who have been away from school for several years and enroll directly in regular credit courses may require additional support. An important companion to our developmental education reforms in the future will have to be strengthening supports for students who have been placed directly in credit courses, but who may want or need additional help. This is especially important for returning or first-time adult students who may have been away from school for some time. OAA strongly encourages colleges to consider optional variations of supplemental supports for students in gateway courses.

No. Applicants should submit SAT scores if they have them. Submitting more information will allow CUNYto make a more accurate determination of proficiency. CUNYrequires SAT scores from recent high school graduates for consideration of freshman admissions to its bachelor’s programs, including through the SEEK program. SAT scores that are submitted for admissions consideration will also be used for proficiency calculations.

There is no change in proficiency policy regarding AP or College Now: if a student has earned an AP test score that any CUNYcollege honors for credit in English or math, the student will be considered proficient. Similarly, if a student has earned math or English credit, or has completed a developmental intervention through a College Now or Early College Initiative (ECI) course, the student will be considered proficient.

As is the case now, high school students can demonstrate proficiency by meeting the proficiency benchmark scores on the SAT, ACT, or Regents exams. Individual colleges may also establish additional criteria for admitting high school students into certain courses. The proficiency index will not be available until a student applies to matriculate at CUNYand therefore will not be available to demonstrate proficiency for the purposes of dual enrollment programs.

No. A proficient student must have access to at least one credit-bearing course in a subject — not to any credit-bearing course. An English-proficient student is eligible to enroll in a course that satisfies the Pathways English Composition requirement. Likewise, a math-proficient student is eligible to enroll in at least one course that meets the Pathways Mathematical and Quantitative Reasoning requirement. College faculties may set different standards for placement into some entry-level courses than others (e.g., they may require that students demonstrate a higher level of math preparation to enroll in a college algebra course than to enroll in a statistics or quantitative reasoning course).

Colleges will also continue to require that students demonstrate a higher standard of readiness for placement into pre-calculus, calculus, and further mathematics courses than for entry-level math courses. A working group of math faculty from multiple CUNYcolleges was convened by Associate Dean for Undergraduate Studies Michael Guy to review data and recommend placement practices for these credit-bearing courses that make use of students’ grades and Regents exams.

UPDATED NOVEMBER 14, 2019

The Accuplacer exams that CUNYpreviously used to determine proficiency are no longer available and students cannot volunteer to take them to demonstrate proficiency. Students may ask to have their proficiency status reviewed by campus admissions staff if they have updated information on their high school GPA, Regents exam scores, or SAT scores that was not available when their application was first processed for admissions. Admissions staff will be able to rerun the proficiency index on an ad-hoc basis to incorporate updated information.

If an applicant has had proficiency determined based on the TASC or GED, rather than a high school GPA, and has math or English Regents exam scores or SAT scores, they are encouraged to present those exam scores to admissions staff who can then determine whether the Regents and SAT scores meet proficiency benchmarks.

A student or prospective student’s default proficiency status is “not proficient� until they demonstrate proficiency. If an applicant has not met any benchmark proficiency criteria and does not have the necessary application data for the proficiency index to run in a particular subject, then the applicant is considered not proficient in the subject and should be enrolled in a corequisite course or an appropriate pre-matriculation intervention.

Individual colleges have the authority to enroll non-proficient students in regular credit courses if they have reason to believe the student will be successful in the course (for example, if the applicant presents newer or additional academic credentials that were not evaluated during the initial admission process, or there is a section of the course designed for non-proficient students in special programs like Opportunity for Student Success). In that case, the student can demonstrate proficiency (and earn a proficiency milestone in the subject) by passing the credit-bearing course. The milestone will automatically post to the student’s ³Ô¹ÏÊÓÆµfirst record after the passing grade has been recorded.

Corequisite Courses

Corequisite remedial courses typically follow one of two models:

One-Course Model: Students enroll in one course that combines credit-bearing and developmental non-credit-bearing instruction. Instructors assign only one grade for this course. Proficiency milestones in ³Ô¹ÏÊÓÆµfirst are triggered by students receiving a passing grade in the course. In this model, the corequisite course is a newly developed course that is not typically offered to proficient students. Note that colleges who utilize the one-course model should ensure that the course has been approved as a Pathways MQR or ENG course and is clearly identified as a Pathways course that will be accepted for transfer across ³Ô¹ÏÊÓÆµ.

Two-Course Model: Students enroll in one credit-bearing course and one linked non-credit developmental intervention. Instructors assign separate grades to the credit course and developmental intervention. In this model, the credit-bearing course is most often an existing course that has already been approved for Pathways. The two-course model is generally more efficient and less labor-intensive for colleges to maintain because it does not require the college to seek Pathways approval for a new course or establish new course equivalencies for transfer. The two-course-model also makes it easier for instructors to indicate that students have demonstrated proficiency even if they do not pass the credit-bearing course (see below for more detail on this matter). The non-credit developmental intervention that serves as the corequisite to the credit course can take a range of forms from a required one- or two-hour weekly supplemental instruction workshop taught by master tutors to a one-to-three-equated-hour course taught by faculty.

Yes. A recent randomized controlled trial study4 of CUNYstudents finds significant differences in outcomes among these curricular and pedagogical approaches. Corequisite courses are found to increase momentum toward a degree; reduce the number of courses needed to pass college math, thus preserving financial aid eligibility for a longer time; increase the number of students that take and pass advanced math courses; and result in almost 50 percent more students obtaining an associate’s degree in three years, while also decreasing racial/ethnic graduation rate gaps.

4 Logue, A. W., Douglas, D., & Watanabe-Rose, M. (2019). Corequisite mathematics remediation: Results over time and in different contexts. Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis. First published online May 20, 2019, at

All non-proficient students should have the opportunity to enroll in corequisite courses rather than traditional, prerequisite non-credit remedial courses. As explained in Technical Guidance Memorandum OAA-19-01, some non-proficient students may benefit from enrollment in one of ³Ô¹ÏÊÓÆµâ€™s evidence-based pre- matriculation programs such as CUNYStart, Math Start, or USIP, depending on their level of need. If a student is not able to enroll in a pre-matriculation program, gathered at CUNYand in other states has demonstrated that students at all levels of academic preparation are more likely to earn course credit when they enroll in corequisite courses rather than in prerequisite remedial courses. Colleges may consider versions of corequisite courses with more or less intensive levels of developmental supports, but research does not suggest that any students are better served by enrolling in a stand-alone prerequisite course rather than a corequisite course.

No. A student is considered proficient after they have successfully completed an exit-level developmental intervention or earned credit in a course in the subject. Students enrolled in corequisite courses demonstrate proficiency when they pass the credit-bearing corequisite course or successfully complete the portion of the course associated with developmental content. As colleges expand corequisite offerings, we also recommend that they review the prerequisites for their entry-level courses in subjects other than math and English to determine which other courses students may take while enrolled in a corequisite course.

Yes. The determination of proficiency would be made by the individual faculty member who assigns grades in the course and handled differently depending on the corequisite course structure:

One-Course Model: If a student has not performed well enough to earn college credit in a corequisite course, but the instructor determines that the student is sufficiently prepared to re-take a gateway course in the subject without corequisite support, the instructor may deem the student proficient. In order to grant proficiency to students who have not passed the credit-bearing portion of a one-course corequisite course, the instructor must submit a list of students to the appropriate party on campus (either the registrar or a college-determined person with proper access) who will then manually populate the Proficiency Milestone for the appropriate skill area in ³Ô¹ÏÊÓÆµfirst. That means the student must attempt another credit-bearing gateway course in the subject, but will not be required to complete additional developmental interventions. (No special action is needed to grant proficiency to students who earn a passing grade in the course; the Proficiency Milestone will be triggered by the passing grade.)

Two-Course Model: The instructor may assign a separate grade/outcome to the credit course and the linked developmental intervention. The non-credit bearing developmental course should be coded with the ‘REME’ course attribute in ³Ô¹ÏÊÓÆµfirst and the subject-specific course attribute value (‘MATH’, ‘READ’, or ‘WRIT’). If the instructor assigns a passing grade to the developmental course, ³Ô¹ÏÊÓÆµfirst will populate a proficiency milestone for the appropriate skill area, regardless of the students’ grade in the associated credit-bearing course. That means the student must attempt another credit-bearing gateway course in the subject, but will not be required to complete additional developmental interventions.

It depends on the corequisite model used:

One-Course Model: Since corequisite courses that follow a one-course model are new courses, they are not automatically equivalent to an existing course. During the course approval process, colleges should include a sentence stating that the new course is equivalent to an existing course for grade replacement purposes. If course equivalencies were not stated at the time of initial approval, colleges should submit this additional information for approval through the ordinary course approval process.

Two-Course Model: If the credit-bearing course portion of a corequisite enrollment is an existing course, then grade replacement policy will automatically take effect. If it is not the same as an existing course, then during course approval colleges must state that the new course is equivalent to an existing course for grade replacement purposes. If this was not stated at time of initial approval, colleges should submit this additional information for approval through the ordinary course approval process.

Non-course-based Developmental Interventions

The standards for successfully completing most non-course-based interventions have not changed as a result of changes in placement policy. Since 2016, CUNYStart and USIP interventions have used results from a common departmental final exam as 35 percent of their final outcome. Students in CUNYStart and USIP will still be deemed proficient using the 65/35 split between coursework and results on the CEAFE or the CATW (the weight of the CEAFE/CATW in USIP interventions can be increased at the discretion of the college Provost).

CLIP is different from CUNYStart and USIP because it results in students re-taking placement tests. Until new ESL placement policies are developed, CLIP students may demonstrate proficiency in reading and writing by re-taking the CATW. They will no longer take the Accuplacer reading exam.

USIP offerings are non-credit-bearing. If a corequisite course follows the two-course model, then the non-credit-bearing enrollment can be part of USIP. The advantage for students in this case is that there would then be no tuition for this portion of the enrollment. The credit-bearing enrollment would still incur tuition and not be part of USIP.