Procurement Policy & Procedures
Supplier Diversity and Inclusion
Administrative Guidance ��� Contract Award Protest Procedures
Updated: November 2020
Part 1: Intent
1.1. The City University of New York (���勛圖弝け��� or ���University���) offers any Protesting Party an opportunity to administratively resolve any Contract Award Protests as it relates to procurement actions pursuant to the Procurement Policy and Procedures of The City University�� of New York as adopted by the CUNYBoard of Trustees on February 21, 2017 and amended on December 16, 2019. All such matters will be accorded full, impartial and timely consideration.
Part 2: Definitions.
2.1. As used herein, the following terms shall have the respective meanings set forth below:
CUNYor University �����The City University of New York, including its Central Office, senior and community colleges, professional and graduate schools.�� For purposes��of this Policy, ���勛圖弝け��� and ���University��� also includes the following types of entities and their subsidiaries: college associations, student services corporations, childcare centers, performing arts centers, and art galleries. These Procedures do not apply to college foundations, separately incorporated alumni associations or auxiliary enterprise corporation; however, those entities are strongly encouraged to establish contract award protest procedures of similar scope to provide for open and free competition to the maximum extent practicable and consistent with the NYS Not-for-Profit Corporation Law.
Contract Award ��� a written determination by the University to an offeror stating that the University has accepted a bid submission, proposal or offer.
Designated Contact ��� the authorized procurement contact person for the subject procurement or contract during the procurement process, except where otherwise authorized by law or University policy.
Purchasing Director ��� CUNYCollege Director of Purchasing (or equivalent title) or designee who is directly responsible for the acquisition of goods and services at their respective CUNYcollege or school, including CUNYCentral Office.
Protest����� a written challenge by a Protesting Party to a Contract Award.
Protesting Party ��� an actual or prospective bidder or offeror whose direct economic interest would be affected by the award of a contract or by the failure to award a contract.
Vice President of Finance and Administration ��� CUNYCollege Vice President of Finance and Administration (or equivalent title) or designee, who is to receive, review and determine Contract Award Protests.
Solicitation or Contract Number ��� a unique identifier assigned by CUNYto each procurement and/or Contract Award.
Part 3: Submission of a Contract Award Protest.
3.1. After attempting to informally resolve any questions, the Protesting Party may submit a Protest to the Vice President of Finance and Administration, in writing, setting forth the basis on which the Protesting Party challenges a Contract Award by 勛圖弝け.
3.2. The Protest must include the following:
3.2.1. Name, address, e-mail address, telephone numbers of the Protesting Party or its Designated Agent.
3.2.2. Solicitation and/or Contract Number.
3.2.3. Detailed statement of the legal and factual grounds for the protest, including a description of resulting prejudice to the Protesting Party.
3.2.4. Copies of all relevant documents.
3.2.5. Statement of the relief requested.
3.2.6. Request for a determination by the Vice President of Finance and Administration.
3.2.7. Information establishing that the protest or inquiry was timely filed in accordance with this Contract Award Protest Procedures.
3.3. Contract Award Protests concerning a pending or awarded contract must be filed by the Protesting Party within ten (10) business days of the earliest to occur of the following, as determined by the Vice President of Finance and Administration: (1) after the Protesting Party knows or should have known of the facts which form the basis of the protest; or (2) after the Protesting Party received a debriefing offered by 勛圖弝け. An untimely Protest will not be considered and will be returned to the Protesting Party.
3.4. All Protests must be sent by certified mail return receipt requested or a similar tracked mail delivery service to the Vice President of Finance and Administration at the address provided in the solicitation document for the Designated Contact.
3.5. A copy of all correspondence and supporting documentation accompanying a Protest must also be sent by certified mail return receipt requested or a similar tracked mail delivery service to the following two addresses:
3.5.1. University Office of Budget and Finance, Attn: Chief Procurement Officer, 230 West 41st Street ��� 5thFloor, New York, NY, 10036
3.5.2. University Office of the General Counsel, Attn: General Counsel, 205 East 42nd St ��� 11th��Floor, New York, NY 10017.
3.6. The Purchasing Director may, at his or her discretion, suspend, modify, or cancel the disputed procurement action prior to the review or issuance of a formal dispute decision.
Part 4. 勛圖弝け���s Review and Response of Contract Award Protest.
4.1. Upon receipt of the Protest, the Vice President of Finance and Administration shall review the documentation submitted by the Protesting Party and any other documents available to 勛圖弝け.
4.2 The Vice President of Finance and Administration, may take any action or make any requests he or she deems necessary in order to investigate the Protest in order to obtain all evidence and other pertinent information.
4.3. The Vice President of Finance and Administration, at his or her discretion, may convene an informal conference with the Protesting Party, and/or any other interested party to resolve the Protest by mutual consent.
4.4. The Vice President of Finance and Administration shall issue a written determination within thirty (30) business days after receipt of the Protest, where feasible.
4.4.1. The Vice President of Finance and Administration reserves the right to waive or extend the time requirements for decisions and final determination on appeals herein prescribed when, in its sole judgment, circumstances so warrant.
4.5. A copy of the written determination, stating the reason(s) upon which it is based and informing the Protesting Party of the right to appeal the determination to the College President shall be sent to the Protesting Party or its agent by certified mail.
Part 5. Appeals.
5.1. The written determination rendered by the Vice President of Finance and Administration to resolve the Protest shall be final and conclusive, unless, within ten (10) business days after receipt of the written determination, the Protesting Party appeals the determination to the College President.
5.1.1. The appeal must be in writing and sent by certified mail return receipt requested or a similar tracked mail delivery service to the President at the address provided for in the solicitation document or as stated in the written determination sent by the Vice President of Finance and Administration.
5.1.2. A copy of all correspondence and supporting documentation to an appeal must also be sent by certified mail return receipt requested or a similar tracked mail delivery service to the following two addresses:
5.1.2.1. University Office of Budget and Finance, Attn: Chief Procurement Officer, 230 West 41st Street ��� 5th Floor, New York, NY 10036.
5.1.2.2. University Office of the General Counsel, Attn: General Counsel, 205 East 42nd St ��� 11th Floor, New York, NY 10017.
5.1.3. The College President, at his or her discretion, may designate a cabinet level employee of the College, other than the Vice President of Finance and Administration, to review relevant documents and make a final determination.
5.1.4. The College President, at his or her discretion may suspend, modify, or cancel the disputed procurement action prior to issuance of a formal appeal decision.
5.2. The final determination on the appeal shall be issued within thirty (30) business days of receipt of the appeal and shall be sent to the Protesting Party or its agent by certified mail.
5.2.1. The College President may take any action or make any requests he or she deems necessary, including extending the time to issue a decision in order to render a written decision on the appeal to the College President.
5.3. An appeal of the decision made by the Vice President of Finance and Administration shall not include new facts and information unless requested in writing by the College President.
5.4. Unless otherwise provided in Part 6 below, the decision of the College President shall be the University���s final and conclusive determination of the Protest.
Part 6. Appeals to the Office of the New York State Comptroller.
6.1. If the Contract Award let by the University is from a New York State operated institution, specifically including the senior colleges, and graduate, honors and professional schools, and the Contract Award is subject to approval of Office of the New York State Comptroller pursuant to State Finance Law section 112 and Education Law section 6218, or is otherwise submitted to the Office of State Comptroller for approval, then the��Protesting��Party may submit an appeal of the College President���s determination to the Office of the New York State Comptroller in accordance with the guidelines on Contract Award Protest Procedure as fully set out at .
Part 7. Legal Appeals.
7.1. Nothing contained in these provisions is intended to limit or impair the rights of any vendor to seek and pursue remedies of law through the judicial process.