Transfer Opportunity Project (TOP)

The Transfer Opportunity Project, or TOP, is a series of research projects funded by the federal Department of Education’s Institute of Education Sciences (IES).  The overall scope of this research, which is being conducted by CUNYand , is to identify “leaks� in the transfer pipeline from community colleges to bachelor’s degree programs More information can be found here.

TOP has six participating colleges (Bronx Community College, Guttman Community College, Hostos Community College, Lehman College, Brooklyn College, and Queens College), but some types of data will be collected from all 19 of ³Ô¹ÏÊÓÆµâ€™s undergraduate colleges, and all of the findings will be pertinent for all of these colleges because transfer is such a critical issue facing CUNYstudents.

Results will be made public throughout the research process.  You can check on our progress here .

Campus leadership, including presidents and provosts, along with experts in the transfer process (advisors, admissions staff, financial aid counselors, and faculty) are integral to our research process.  Additionally, CUNYstudents are also essential to our understanding of the transfer process and are providing detailed accounts of their experiences.

TOP is mainly focused on “vertical transfer,� or transfer from associate’s- to bachelor’s-degree programs, but recognizes that students move between degree programs in other ways as well.

Student transfer has long been a challenging policy issue at CUNYand across the country.  Access to technology and student data have now made it far easier for us to understand where the difficult points in the transfer process are.  In turn, there is an obligation to point out those barriers and to craft policy revisions to correct them.  We believe that our work joins with the social justice mission of CUNYto provide equitable and accessible postsecondary education to the people of the City of New York.

The research is funded a grant of $1.4 million from the federal Department of Education’s Institute of Education Sciences (IES).

Transfer is a universal concern at ³Ô¹ÏÊÓÆµ. The participating colleges will provide examples from their campuses that will no doubt relate to the other colleges in similar ways.  Study results will be shared with senior leadership on all CUNYcampuses throughout the research process.

There are many.  Certainly we are interested in understanding pre-matriculation, including where prospective transfer students begin the transfer process but fail to enroll at the receiving institution.  Additionally, we recognize the first semester post-transfer is a critical juncture for students.  During this semester, students typically experience “transfer shock,� or a reduction in GPA, that is a result of shifting environment, expectations, and peer groups.  Throughout the process, we are looking into advising practices, the utilization of articulation agreements, financial aid protocol, and how information related to transfer is communicated to students and their families.

We are relying on a range of methodologies to help us understand the transfer process.  For example, we are drawing upon quantitative data from the CUNYOffice of Institutional Research which has made accessible a vast database.  This database is allowing us to follow cohorts of students through the transfer process, track their outcomes, and identify stages where problems arise.  We are also conducting focus groups with key staff and students.  Furthermore, we are fielding surveys both for college staff and for students so that we can augment our statistical and focus group data with a diverse set of experiences that will be made available through detailed survey questions related to transfer.

Growing Transfer in the Humanities (GROWTH)

GROWTH, or Growing Transfer in the Humanities, is a three-year study funded by the Andrew W. Mellon Foundation that focuses on issues related to students with interests in the humanities who transfer from associate’s- to bachelor’s-degree programs. This research is being conducted by ³Ô¹ÏÊÓÆµ, initially at Guttman Community College, and then the GROWTH research will be expanded to other community colleges.  For more information on GROWTH, click here.

Although both research projects are focused on issues related to student transfer, GROWTH is particularly focused on evaluating the transfer pipeline for students with interests in the humanities.

Our hypothesis is that there are fewer support systems for humanities students along the transfer pathway.  We believe that students in STEM programs, for example, have clear pathways and multiple supporting programs for propelling them toward the bachelor’s degree.  Our analysis will compare humanities student transfer outcomes and patterns with other disciplinary categories, including both the Natural and the Social sciences.

GROWTH is funded by a $550k award from the Andrew W. Mellon Foundation.

Guttman Community College will be the first study site for the project.  Guttman is small in comparison to the other community colleges, enrolling fewer than 1,000 students.  Starting with Guttman will allow us to test our research methods before expanding to other community colleges in the second year of the project.

You can look for our results as we begin to present and publish them on our research page.

Presently, the Guttman Community College administration, faculty, other staff, and students are all active participants in the research process.

We are using quantitative data from the CUNYOffice of Institutional Research to understand transfer in students with interests in the humanities.  Additionally, we will be surveying students in all the participating colleges for their interest and knowledge related to transfer as well as speaking to groups of students in focus groups.

Articulation of Credit Transfer (ACT)

ACT (Articulation of Credit Transfer) is a project funded by the Heckscher Foundation for Children.  ACT is being conducted by and ³Ô¹ÏÊÓÆµ, and consists of implementation of innovative solutions to facilitate transfer students’ credit transfer and other aspects of the transfer process.  ACT takes its name from the articulation process by which credits earned at one college are counted towards degree requirements at another college to which the student transfers.  ACT is developing model transfer processes at Hostos Community College and Lehman College.

Multiple studies, at CUNYand nationally, have identified credit transfer (or the lack of it) and the processes surrounding it as one of the primary obstacles to transfer student success.  Other factors also affect transfer students’ success, but students’ difficulties with credit transfer are large and have proven particularly difficulty to overcome.

ACT is funded by grants from the Heckscher, Petrie, and Ichigo Foundations.

ACT is being directed by two Principal Investigators:  Martin Kurzweil, Director of the Educational Transformation Program at Ithaka S+R, and Alexandra W. Logue, a Research Professor in the Center for Advanced Study in Education at the Graduate Center of ³Ô¹ÏÊÓÆµ.

Many people at both colleges are intimately involved in ACT, including the colleges’ senior leadership, staff, and faculty.  The principal investigators, staff from Ithaka S+R and from ³Ô¹ÏÊÓÆµâ€™s Office of Institutional Research and Assessment, and members of the Hostos and Lehman communities, are collaborating closely to effect this project’s novel solutions to credit transfer challenges.

TOP and GROWTH are more focused on obtaining information that will be used later to design interventions to help transfer students, whereas ACT is focused in implementation of interventions.

Hostos and Lehman have a long and strong history of facilitating transfer between their institutions.  The leadership and others at these two colleges are dedicated to becoming the best possible example of seamless transfer through creativity and hard work.

In this project we first obtain baseline measures, then institute various new processes designed to help transfer students, and then measure the effects of these new processes.  The new processes will all involve facilitating the transfer of credits that apply to degree requirements.

The results of ACT will be made public, and steps will be taken to give other CUNYcolleges the opportunity to adopt ACT’s innovations.