勛圖弝け���s Commitment to Providing a Safe and Respectful Educational Environment Free from Discrimination Based on Race, Color, and National Origin

CUNYstands firmly against antisemitism, Islamophobia, and discrimination of any form, including retaliation, on our campuses. As described in 勛圖弝け���s Policy 6.02 on Discrimination and Equal Opportunity, the Diversity, Equity and Inclusion Hub, and Our CUNYinitiative, CUNYis proud of its diversity and is committed to maintaining and fostering an educational environment free from all discrimination. The safety of students, faculty, and staff is paramount, and an inclusive campus environment is essential to 勛圖弝け���s success as an institution of higher learning. For reference, see the Chancellor���s July 10, 2024 letter, ���Reaffirming Our Position Against Hate of Any Kind.���

Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964

Title VI and its regulations require that colleges and universities receiving federal financial assistance provide all students with a school environment free from discrimination, or harassment, based on race, color, or national origin. This right extends to discrimination or harassment based on shared ancestry or perceived shared ancestry or ethnic characteristics or citizenship or residency in a country with a dominant religion or distinct religious identity. ��This means that students have a right to be free from ethnic or racial slurs, harassment for how they dress or speak, and from any stereotypes based on actual or perceived shared ancestral or ethnic characteristics.

Disparate Treatment

Title VI prohibits educational institutions from treating students differently because of their actual or perceived national origin absent a legitimate, nondiscriminatory reason for denying or limiting a student���s ability to participate in an educational program or activity.

To prevent instances of disparate treatment, CUNYcampuses must ensure CUNYpolicies and procedures are enforced equally and fairly among students, student organizations, and campus event requests. If a campus denies a student organization from holding an event on campus, the campus must have a legitimate, nondiscriminatory reason for its denial.

Title VI Prohibits Retaliation

It is unlawful to intimidate, threaten, coerce, or discriminate against any individual for the purpose of interfering with their Title VI rights, such as filing a complaint, providing testimony or participating in an investigation. As stated by the United States Department of Education���s Office for Civil Rights (���OCR���) in the , ���the ability of individuals to oppose discriminatory practices, and to participate in OCR investigations and other proceedings, is critical to ensuring equal educational opportunity in accordance with Federal civil rights laws.���

OCR is Responsible for the Enforcement and Oversight of Title VI

The United States Department of Education provides federal funding to schools, colleges, and other educational programs in the United States. The United States Department of Education���s Office for Civil Rights, commonly referred to as OCR, enforces Title VI and has the authority investigate complaints of discrimination where an individual alleges exclusion from educational programs, services or activities, or harassment based on race, color, national origin or shared ancestry such as students of Jewish, Israeli, Palestinian, Muslim, Arab, and/or South Asian descent.

OCR has interpreted Title VI to extend to protecting individuals of any religion from discrimination, including harassment, based on a student���s actual or perceived shared ancestry or ethnic characteristics or citizenship or residency in a country with a dominant religion or distinct religious identity. This means that students have a right to be free from ethnic or racial slurs, harassment for how they dress or speak, and from any stereotypes based on perceived shared ancestral or ethnic characteristics.

Harassing conduct can be physical or verbal that creates a hostile environment that is so offensive and severe or pervasive that it limits or denies a student���s ability to participate in or benefit from the school���s educational programs, services, or activities.

勛圖弝け-Wide Title VI Voluntary Resolution Agreement

On June 10, 2024, CUNYentered into a Voluntary Resolution Agreement (���VRA���) with the United States Department of Education���s Office for Civil Rights (���OCR���) to resolve nine open national origin/shared ancestry discrimination claims filed with OCR across five CUNYcampuses and the Central Office. In this Agreement, CUNYdid not make an admission to violating Title VI. Rather, CUNYaverred that it has been and remains committed to providing a safe educational environment free from all forms of discrimination, including discrimination based on (actual or perceived) shared Arab, Israeli, Jewish, Muslim, Palestinian and/or South Asian ancestry and/or the association with these national origins/ancestries. To comply with the VRA, CUNYagreed to take the following actions, several of which are already in progress or have already been addressed:

  1. Review its nondiscrimination policies and procedures;
  2. Conduct an annual orientation/refresher and new hiring training for Office of Diversity and Compliance employees who investigate claims and reports of discrimination;
  3. Conduct additional training for 勛圖弝け���s Campus Peace Officers related to 勛圖弝け���s Title VI obligations;
  4. Perform an audit of Title VI complaints and reports for academic years 2023-2024 and 2024-2025 at specified ���captioned colleges��� as identified in the VRA;
  5. Administer a 勛圖弝け-wide climate survey for students;
  6. Issue a statement to all CUNYstudents and employees reaffirming 勛圖弝け���s commitment to address discrimination, including harassment, on the basis of national origin, including shared Arab, Israeli, Jewish, Muslim, Palestinian and/or South Asian ancestry and/or the association with these national origins/ancestries; and
  7. Reopen or initiate investigations of national origin/shared ancestry discrimination at colleges specified in Action Item 7 of the VRA.

Recent OCR Guidance

OCR has issued several recent Dear Colleague Letters that address the nationwide rise in hate crimes and harassment, including a rise in complaints filed with OCR alleging discrimination, and harassment based on national origin, including shared Arab, Israeli, Jewish, Muslim, Palestinian and/or South Asian ancestry and/or the association with these national origins/ancestries on college campuses nationwide. These Dear Colleague Letters serve as a reminder that colleges and universities receiving federal funding, such as 勛圖弝け, have an obligation to provide a learning environment that is free from discrimination.

OCR Dear Colleague letters

OCR Fact Sheet

On July 2, 2024, OCR issued a which provides frequently asked questions and answers, including examples, that is designed to assist schools regarding its Title VI obligations.

Title VI Officers

Campus Name Title Contact Information
Baruch College Olga Dais VP, Legal Counsel and Labor Designee
Borough of Manhattan Community College Princess Lyles Interim Deputy Director of Investigations & Title IX Compliance
Bronx Community College Sabine Rospido Chief Campus Counsel and Labor Designee
Brooklyn College Danielle Haynes Chief Diversity Officer
College of Staten Island Tara Mastrangelo Director, Office of Diversity, Equity, & Inclusion, Title IX & ADA 504
  • 718-982-2688
  • Tara.Mastrangelo@csi.cuny.edu
CUNYGuttman Community College Jewel Jones Chief Diversity Officer/Title IX Coordinator/504-ADA Coordinator
CUNYMacaulay Honors College &
The Graduate Center &
The Craig Newmark Graduate School of Journalism &
CUNYSchool of Labor and Urban Studies
Jessica Morak Executive Director of Institutional Equity
CUNYSchool of Law Taejong Kim Executive Counsel and Labor Designee
CUNYSchool of Medicine Marissa Harrison Associate Legal Counsel
CUNYSchool of Professional Studies Danelle McClanahan Title IX and VI Coordinator/ADA-504 Coordinator
CUNYSchool of Public Health Donna Canfield Executive Counsel and Labor Designee
Hostos Community College Philip Oliveri Chief Diversity Officer
Hunter College John Rose Dean of Diversity and Compliance
John Jay Alisa Cupid Chief Diversity Officer
Kingsborough Community College Corina M. Lozada Smith Chief Diversity Officer
Laguardia Community College Maria Cook Executive Counsel to the President/ Labor Designee
Lehman College Maritza Rivera Chief Diversity Officer
Medgar Evers College Lance Houston Interim Executive Legal Compliance Officer, Chief Diversity Officer
New York City College of Technology Patricia Cody Chief Diversity Officer
Queens College Dennis Cohen Executive Counsel/Labor Designee
Queensborough Community College Lois Florman Executive Counsel and Labor Designee
The City College of New York Sheryl Konigsberg Chief Diversity Officer
York College Dr. Daniel Holmes Chief Diversity Officer

Frequently Asked Questions

Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 is a federal law that prohibits discrimination on the basis of race, color, and national origin, including shared ancestry in any program or activity that receives federal funding. This means that all people are entitled to equal treatment free from discrimination in any program or activity that receives federal financial assistance. This includes educational programs, services and activities offered by The City University of New York.

The United States Department of Education provides federal funding to schools, colleges, and other educational programs in the United States. The United States Department of Education���s Office for Civil Rights (���OCR���) enforces Title VI and has the authority to investigate complaints of discrimination where an individual alleges exclusion from educational programs, services or activities, or harassment based on race, color, national origin, or shared ancestry such as students of Jewish, Palestinian, Muslim, Arab, and/or South Asian descent.

OCR investigates and resolves Title VI complaints against educational institutions (that are recipients of federal funds) alleging that such institutions have failed to protect students from discrimination or harassment based on race, color, or national origin. Where OCR identifies concerns or violations, educational institutions often resolve them with agreements requiring the educational institutions to adopt effective anti-harassment policies and procedures, train staff and students, address the incidents in question, and take other steps to restore a nondiscriminatory environment.

Discrimination on the basis of race, color, or national origin includes discrimination based on a person���s actual or perceived race, color, national origin, ethnicity, or ancestry. OCR has interpreted national origin to extend to discrimination or harassment based on shared ancestry or perceived shared ancestry or ethnic characteristics or citizenship or residency in a country with a dominant religion or distinct religious identity. This means that students have a right to be free from ethnic or racial slurs, harassment for how they dress or speak, and from any stereotypes based on actual or perceived shared ancestral or ethnic characteristics.

Racial and national origin harassment is unwelcome conduct based on a student���s actual or perceived race or national origin. Harassers can be students, school staff, or even someone visiting the school, such as a student or employee from another school. Racial and national origin harassment can take many forms, including slurs, taunts, stereotypes, or name-calling, as well as racially motivated physical threats, attacks, or other hateful conduct. Although none of the laws OCR enforces expressly address religious discrimination, OCR can investigate complaints that students were subjected to ethnic or ancestral slurs; harassed for how they look, dress, or speak in ways linked to ethnicity or ancestry (e.g., skin color, religious attire, language spoken); or stereotyped based on perceived shared ancestral or ethnic characteristics. Hindu, Jewish, Muslim, and Sikh students are examples of individuals who may be harassed for being viewed as part of a group perceived to exhibit both ethnic and religious characteristics.

Title VI prohibits discrimination on the basis of race, color or national origin under any program or activity receiving federal financial assistance.

Title VII prohibits discrimination in employment on the basis of race, color, religion, sex, or national origin.

Title VI requires an educational institution to respond to racial or national origin harassment that is sufficiently serious to deny or limit a student���s ability to participate in or benefit from the recipient���s education programs and activities (i.e., creates a hostile environment).

When an educational institution knows or reasonably should know of possible racial or national origin harassment, it must take immediate and appropriate steps to investigate or otherwise determine what occurred. If an investigation reveals that the harassment created a hostile environment, the educational institution must take prompt and effective steps reasonably calculated to end the harassment, eliminate the hostile environment, prevent its recurrence, and, as appropriate, remedy its effects.

The University has a legal obligation to investigate claims of an alleged hostile environment even if no formal or informal complaint is made. CUNYis on constructive notice of a hostile environment if ���upon reasonably diligent inquiry in the exercise of reasonable care, it should have known of the discrimination.���

Simply put, if CUNYshould have known about the harassment or could have known about the harassment had it made a proper inquiry, then CUNYhas an obligation to investigate. A formal complaint is not a prerequisite for conducting an investigation. OCR guidance from recent case determinations is clear; educational institutions must not wait for a formal complaint to be made.

While students, faculty, and staff have the right to say what they want on their own private social media accounts, a campus is still obligated to take prompt and effective steps to address the allegations of discrimination flowing from speech that is protected by the First Amendment.

If a social media post contributes to a hostile environment, the University may need to take action to address the impact, even if the post itself is protected speech. Each case is analyzed individually based on the totality of the circumstances, including the severity, pervasiveness, and impact of the social media post on a student���s ability to participate in or benefit from educational programs or activities.

Although the University may not be able to impose disciplinary action for protected speech, the University may have the right to take action if that speech violates University policies or rules governing codes of conduct.

If a Campus Chief Diversity Officer determines that protected speech contributed to a hostile environment, non-disciplinary, remedial measures may be warranted, such as: counseling, academic adjustments, or supportive resources for affected students to ensure students can access educational programs in a safe and supportive environment. This balanced approach aims to protect students, faculty, and staff from discrimination while respecting free speech rights.

Harassing conduct can be physical or verbal conduct that creates a hostile environment that is so offensive and severe or pervasive that it limits or denies a student���s ability to participate in or benefit from the school���s educational programs, services, or activities.

Generally, offensive speech, standing alone, is insufficient to establish a hostile environment in violation of Title VI. The harassment must be sufficiently serious to deny or limit a student���s ability to participate in or benefit from the educational programs, services, or activities.

OCR has defined a hostile environment as unwelcome conduct that based on the totality of the circumstances is subjectively and objectively offensive and is so severe or pervasive that it limits or denies a person���s ability to participate in or benefit from a recipient���s educational program or activity.

Harassing acts need not be directed at the complainant to create a hostile environment. In most cases, to establish a Title VI violation, harassment must consist of more than casual or isolated incidents based on national origin.

Title VI prohibits educational institutions from treating students differently because of their actual or perceived national origin absent a legitimate, nondiscriminatory reason for denying or limiting a student���s ability to participate in an educational program or activity.

To prevent instances of disparate treatment, CUNYcampuses must ensure CUNYpolicies and procedures are enforced equally and fairly among students, student organizations, and campus event requests. If a campus denies a student organization from holding an event on campus, the campus must have a legitimate, nondiscriminatory reason for its denial.

The City University of New York receives various forms of federal funding, most importantly in the form of financial aid to our students and is therefore subject to Title VI. This means that the University has an obligation to respond to allegations of discrimination, including harassment, based on race, color, national origin or shared ancestry. The University is required to take prompt and effective steps to end any such harassment, eliminate any hostile environment and its effects and prevent harassment from recurring. The response must be prompt, consistent and fair.

The University must fully and fairly investigate any and all such allegations which fall under the protections of Title VI. Depending on the investigation���s outcome, resolutions to Title VI complaints can be wide ranging and depend on the unique facts and circumstance of each case.

Some remedial measures may include:

  • Engaging in a conversation with a faculty or staff member about an offensive social media post, or an off-topic class conversation and its impact on students.
  • Offering supportive measures to an affected student, such as counseling services or an academic adjustment (e.g., transferring to a different class section, if available).
  • Issuing public statements condemning discrimination.
  • Providing increased security on campus, if necessary.
  • Implementing educational programs to raise awareness and prevent future incidents.

Individuals who believe they have experienced discrimination should file a report on the 勛圖弝け-wide Discrimination and Retaliation Reporting Portal or contact the campus Chief Diversity Officer.

Once a complaint is filed, the CDO or a designated investigator will conduct a thorough investigation, which will include evidence gathering, witness interviews, and review of any relevant documents. During the investigation, CUNYmay implement temporary measures to protect the complainant or any other individuals, as needed, and ensure a non-discriminatory environment. After the investigation has been completed, the complainant will be notified of the determination and any actions to be taken.

CUNYis committed to maintaining a structured and consistent process for the reporting and handling of Title VI cases, providing a clear pathway for addressing and resolving issues of discrimination.

Free Speech & Social Media

While students, faculty, and staff have the right to say what they want on their own private social media accounts, a campus is still obligated to take prompt and effective steps to address the allegations of discrimination flowing from speech that is protected by the First Amendment. Each case is analyzed individually based on the totality of the circumstances, including the severity, pervasiveness, and impact of the social media post on a student���s ability to participate in or benefit from educational programs or activities. If a social media post contributes to a hostile environment, the University may need to take action to address the impact, even if the post itself is protected speech. Although the University may not be able to impose disciplinary action for protected speech, the University may have the right to take action if that speech violates University policies or rules governing codes of conduct.

If a Campus Chief Diversity Officer determines that protected speech contributed to a hostile environment, non-disciplinary, remedial measures may be warranted, such as: counseling, academic adjustments, or supportive resources for affected students to ensure students can access educational programs in a safe and supportive environment. This balanced approach aims to protect students, faculty, and staff from discrimination while respecting free speech rights.