By Andrea Tamayo
When Dwayne Baker was a graduate student at Binghamton University in New York, the city cut bus lines that served neighborhoods outside the city center, making it harder for many residents���including Baker���to commute to work. ���I was like, okay, this kind of sucks,��� said Baker. ���How does that happen?���
This event kick-started his interest in urban planning. He opted out of his doctoral studies in Philosophy to pursue a Master���s degree in Urban Planning at Jackson State University in Mississippi, before earning a PhD in Urban Planning at the University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign. Today, Baker is an associate professor at Queens College, studying the relationship between transportation planning and neighborhood change.
New York City is a unique place to study that relationship, says Baker. In 2019, the city had the among all U.S. metropolitan areas with at least one million residents, but these commuting experiences vary widely.
In 2021, Baker and David Lop矇z-Garcia, a colleague from the University of Illinois at Chicago, . They discovered that some people have long-distance commutes that take relatively short amounts of time. ���We call their commutes wormholes,��� said Baker. ���Those people tend to have higher incomes or be white households that might live in the suburbs. [They might be] next to a commuter rail or express road, just zipping right in.���
On the other hand, some commutes cover short distances but take a long time. Baker calls these ���transit hells,��� because someone may only have a two-mile commute but still face significant delays. ���The transit hells were largely Hispanic, Latino, and Black populations,��� said Baker.
Baker and his wife are keenly aware of this difference. The couple lives in Astoria, Queens. While it takes Baker���s wife about twenty minutes to reach her job in Midtown Manhattan via public transit, it takes Baker nearly an hour to get to Queens College.
While discussing this discrepancy with Lop矇z-Garcia, the pair dug into NYC���s average commuting time differences and found that from 2000 to 2016, average commuting times increased by only about a quarter of a second across all transit modes. That tiny change didn���t make sense to Baker. ���So we dug a little further into that data,��� he said.
It turns out that when the data is parsed by census tract, many people experienced extreme increases or decreases in commuting times. While the citywide average increased by just a quarter of a second, some individuals saw their commute times rise by as much as 30 minutes.
Racial and ethnic minorities faced the largest commuting disadvantages. Census tracts with increases in Black, Asian, and Hispanic or Latino residents experienced the highest increases in commuting times.
Meanwhile, tracts with growing white populations were more likely to see extreme decreases in commuting time���as were those with rising income levels, rental occupancy, housing burdens, and proximity to subway infrastructure. Overall, this suggests that racial and ethnic minorities are more likely to experience longer commuting times compared to white residents. Those areas with increases in extreme commuting times may be the same areas with limited targeted transportation or economic developments, said Baker, but more research is needed in this area.
���The disparate impacts go beyond just commuting times. They also affect overall well-being. The more time commuting means less time with family, friends, the community, etc. While the actual increases may be relatively small (~15 minutes), this adds up over time,��� said Baker. ���That���s an extra 1.5 hours a week or 6 hours a month or 72 hours a year, give or take. That means that much less time helping kids with school-work, caring for family, engaging in hobbies, or just being active in the community. This commuting disparity can be detrimental to households and communities when compounded over time.���
���Transit for the most part���and the infrastructure around it���has stayed the same,��� said Baker. ���But the one thing that did change was that certain neighborhoods saw huge influxes of white residents, Black residents, Hispanic and Latino residents, and Asian residents.���
Areas surrounding Manhattan���such as northern Manhattan, Washington Heights, Harlem, the eastern waterfront of Brooklyn, Long Island City, and Greenpoint���saw significant increases in white populations. While these residents are still moving away from job centers, they���re not as far removed. They can reach their destinations with just a few stops. Meanwhile, Black populations saw large increases in areas like southeastern Brooklyn and southern Queens. ���They���re getting farther in terms of distance.��� It might take these residents three or four train transfers to reach their destination.
Disparities continue to shape our cities, said Baker, but he believes the implications go beyond transit. ���If you can’t afford to live close to where you work���or within a reasonable commute���you may have to spend more time in transit,��� said Baker. ���That cuts away from quality time you could spend with your family, your kids, your community, maybe social relationships.���
