December 1, 2025 |

We Should Think CUNYChild Care As A Crisis, Not Just During A Crisis

By Leandra Manon泭

On January 31, 2020, the secretary of the U.S. Health and Human Services declared the 2019 novel coronavirus a public health emergency. All facets of daily life in the country changed. In New York City, what started as a two-week school closure became a series of re-openings and closings. Families were forced to embrace their children���s new educational setup while trying to balance at-home child care with caregivers��� employment.泭

John Jay College of Criminal Justice professors and ��� 2020 study makes it abundantly clear: when the child-care system is under stress, women in the workforce are significantly impacted.泭

������ demonstrates how the pandemic’s effects on child care exposed an underlying gender equity issue. Data showed that lack of affordable and consistent child care affected the workplace presence of women, who disproportionately perform more child-care labor. Many have to leave work to care for their children. This is especially true for women of color.泭

���Child care became the crux of who can go to work, who couldn’t go to work, what those environments looked like, and were they safe,��� says Elias.泭

According to a , 32% of women cited at-home care needs as an impediment from rejoining the workforce.泭

In New York City, women make up 60% of the essential workforce. In social services, they represent 81% of employees and 75% in healthcare.泭

Elias, an associate professor in the Department of Public Management, explains that decisions about income and who should stay home were significant pain points for essential workers. During the pandemic, issues pertaining to equity within social, political, and economic structures ���were really at the forefront of our minds,��� she says.泭泭

D’Agostino and Elias��� work focuses on the government and public service sectors. They co-founded the in 2013. It conducts research and provides workshops and consultation to help public sector organizations build towards gender equity.泭

���One of my areas of interest, in terms of research, has been women in leadership positions and gender in the workplace ��� that coincided a lot with what Nicole did,��� reflects D���Agostino.泭

When Elias joined John Jay, they realized their shared interests. Through their initiative, they���ve uncovered patterns of inequity and gaps in representation and leadership.泭

COVID-19 served as a catalyst for pre-existing issues to fester and rise to the surface. D���Agostino says, ���Not only did it reveal that [the child-care system] was broken, but I think in many ways it revealed what we think about child care and our values towards child care.���泭

She explains that for many families, the ���default method��� is to rely on schools for child care. Schools provide reliable child-care options that enable caregivers to work. However, the school system does not account for issues like conflicts between standard school and work schedules or calendars. These issues burden low-income families the most.泭

During the pandemic, the federal government introduced regional enrichment centers under the CARES Act. Essential workers could access affordable child care and re-enter the workforce. While crucial, program did not go without challenges.泭

These centers faced issues regarding questionable COVID-19 safety protocols, distance from low-income households, and unexpected closures. There were also gaps in who benefited. ���Care in Crisis��� reports that the focus on essential workers overlooked caretakers who worked from home.泭泭

As in-person learning resumed, families went back to relying on schools and child-care centers. The burden persisted for households with children under five years old. According to the city���s Economic Development Corporation, parents who left New York or cut back on working hours to mitigate child-care expenses cost the city $23 billion in lost economic output in 2022. With child-care costs from 2019 to 2024, the gap between city officials’ actions and parents looking for reprieve only seemed to widen.泭

Earlier this year, Mayor Adams cut from 3K, PromiseNYC, and early childhood education programs from the preliminary budget. As well, leases for five daycare centers serving low-income neighborhoods were terminated.泭

���I think what happened is that COVID slowly dissipated and people are back in school full-time and that conversation about child care is no longer at the level, in my opinion, where it should be,��� says D���Agostino.泭

To re-structure the current system to better fit the diverse needs of families and gender equity, D���Agostino and Elias���s case study advocates for an affordable, universal child care system that is high-quality, federally-funded, democratized, and provides flexibility for families.泭

D���Agostino and Elias believe pandemic-era enrichment centers can serve as examples. Their study draws connections to child-care centers during World War II, which yielded similar benefits.泭泭

As the war raged, women participated in the workforce ��� many for the first time. Lack of child care highlighted the same issues seen during the pandemic. The Lanham Act widened child-care access through subsidized programs. Although federally funded, they were largely localized. Local officials, nonprofit organizations, and mothers had a say in the centers��� practices.泭

Like the enrichment centers, the program faced hardships. Some localities could not match federal grants. There were not enough facilities to meet demand – 600,000 children were served by 3,000 centers.泭

���Basic, federally-funded, locally-implemented [child care] accounts for the unique circumstances that someone in Nebraska might face versus New York City,��� says Elias. ���That creates an attempt at equity in terms of funding and resources, but also accounting for the particulars of what’s going on in each place.���泭

Both programs left room for improvement, but they proved that they could let women work more equitably while providing affordable child-care options. Once government systems account for consistent child care that works with families��� schedules, families of all kinds can choose to remain in the workforce.泭

D���Agostino also notes that universal child care can support diverse family groups, such as single-parent households.泭

In New York City, there were an estimated in 2023. According to the Citizens’-parent households in the city pay over three times more than dual-parent households for childcare, as a percentage of household income.泭

������It’s not just a woman’s issue, and I think that’s really important as we frame this discussion about child care that it really impacts everybody and it impacts society as a whole,��� says D���Agostino.泭