September 9, 2025 |

To See the Housing Issue, Widen Your Gaze

By Anna Leah

What can century-old prison writings from Southern Europe tell us about high-stakes housing policy debates in today���s New York City? According to City College professor it can help us to understand them in a far broader historical context.

The Italian Communist Antonio Gramsci pioneered an approach to social analysis. He was part of an international socialist movement steeped in writing. ���Leaders wrote a lot because they were working out for the movement, for themselves, a theoretical approach��� to guide their organizing, says Krinsky.

The Russian revolution surprised many Marxists. They expected that a revolution would occur first among Europe���s ���more mature��� working classes. Rejecting the idea that revolution was a ���structural��� by-product of capitalism, Gramsci sought to understand the potentials for revolutionary change in his native Italy by understanding what was ���conjunctural���. Among other factors, he looked at the political results of the Catholic Church���s patronage networks and contradictions in Italy���s unification of Italy itself, with a rural and desperately poor south and an urbanized North. These efforts, and his political agitation, landed him in Mussolini���s fascist prison in 1926. He remained until just before his death in 1937.

Krinsky explores conjunctural analysis in a on New York City���s housing movement, published in February this year. For decades, he���s been interested in ���social housing,��� or housing removed from the marketplace, Krinsky studied it as an advocacy planner in the 1990s after working as an organizer with a homeless rights group. Nearly 15 years ago, he returned to the topic as an advocate and scholar when another homeless rights group proposed another model of social housing ��� community land trusts.

���Conjunctural analysis refuses a separation between ��� allegedly ��� apolitical and political research, because there���s a basic recognition that if you���re doing social and historical research, you���re not ever really starting out from a position of neutrality. Even if you think you are,��� explains Krinsky.

���My use of conjunctural analysis is little quirky,��� says Krinsky, who says that researchers who are truer to Gramsci���s own work try to explain big moments of change. Instead, he contextualizes activists��� present choices in a larger intersection of economic, social, and political forces. ���We don���t know ever until afterwards what���s going to be a big deal or not,��� he says. ���So, let���s look at where we are now, think about which ways it can pivot, and understand how we got here.���

Where we are, in New York City housing, is somewhere new and complex. Tenants have more leverage and rights than ever before. Landlords, who have recently lost some of their political clout, still earn record profits.

In 2017, a city-wide housing group coalition won a right to counsel in housing court, which helped significantly reduce evictions. In 2019, a broad, statewide coalition, , forced Albany to adopt sweeping reforms of regulations that had grown lax over a quarter-century of pressure from the real-estate industry. They, and fellow organizers, continue to push for local and state expansion of social housing. Krinsky asks, how did movement solutions become prominent in the public agenda?

He traces the developments of successive rounds of movement, both within and adjacent to housing. For example, federal anti-union labor reforms in 1947 exiled Communists from the labor movement. This pushed some, like Harlem���s Jesse Gray, into housing organizing. He led rent strikes in the early 1960s, alongside civil rights groups and other leftwing tenant organizations. This pushed the state to pass a law allowing tenants to pay rent payments into escrow to pay for maintenance if landlords remained neglectful.

Abandonment and arson swept the city during its financial and economic collapse of the 1970s. Groups formed to pressure the city to fix up neighborhoods, guard against displacement, and house a growing population of homeless New Yorkers. Using the rent-strike law from the 1960s, and laws making it easier to form tenant cooperatives, organizers pioneered nonprofit and cooperative housing models that no longer relied on for-profit landlords.

Since the 1980s, banking deregulation, rezoning, and tax-incentives made housing profitable again. Organizations saw their neighborhoods gentrify. They now work to protect renters from rising costs and displacement.

Many form the basis of today���s housing movement, alongside groups that focus on workfare, HIV/AIDS, police violence, and immigrants rights. In the wake of Occupy Wall Street and Bernie Sanders��� 2016 presidential campaign, organizations like the Working Families Party and the Democratic Socialists of America have supported successful legislative candidates at the state level. They brought movement allies to Albany, including mayoral candidate, Zohran Mamdani.

The real estate industry started regrouping after the housing movement���s victories, arguing that rent-regulated housing isn���t profitable. They had taken out speculative mortgages based on the old rules and had planned to de-regulate those apartments. Banks like Signature, which encouraged this predatory speculation, . Krinsky explains, ���Being a slumlord in New York is no longer the viable business that it used to be.���

The city���s longtime reliance on private landlords to provide affordable housing appears to be losing purchase, too. The housing supply and mandates for developers to provide ���affordable��� units does not make enough housing available to low- and moderate-income renters. ���Focusing on for-profit development to get us out of this – it���s the definition of madness,��� Krinsky says. ���We���ve been doing that, and it hasn���t worked, and we keep doing it.���

To do conjunctural analysis, Krinsky recommends embedding with a movement. He says, ���It���s an academic enterprise, arguably, but the question is a political one.���

Krinsky adds that his work is a chance for reflection ���inside the movement itself, because I do work with the housing movement, not just as academic, but as a participant.���

Intertwined histories of movement groups and policy changes show how long-fought battles can reappear as resources for contemporary activism. Though it can get complex, the complexity of conjunctural analysis is not itself a virtue. ���Conjunctural analysis that doesn���t have a movement-centered question,��� says Krinsky, ���that���s just kind of hyperactive.���