By Anna Leah
Behind Aaron Kozbelt, a host of painted faces looks out from the wall. Black-and-white representations of the physicist and writer Heinz Pagels rest in a blue-and-red shape of Colorado, where Pagels died. Kozbelt as a baby sits amid the professor’s quotaÂtions and ideas. If the picture is seen as a chart over time, at the halfway point of 25 years the images beÂcome more complex and numerous.
Painting as a graduate student, Kozbelt experienced what he would spend his career studying: ideas perÂcolating through the process of creation.
He developed his dissertation while continuing to paint, “partly as a way of getting research ideas and figuring out what were the important questions to ask,” he says. “It does foreshadow that whole line of research.”
For the last 25 years, Kozbelt, a at Brooklyn College, has studied the interplay between creativity and cognition. His discoveries include new insights into the lifespan of creators, differences in artists’ visual processing, and exploÂrations of how artworks capture attention.
“If you’re too wacky, people don’t know what to do with it. It’s too much. There’s like this nice zone where you’re pushing the envelope a little bit,” KozÂbelt explains.
Artists work in a delicate balance between challengÂing audiences and remaining relatable. In his 2021 article, “,” Kozbelt identifies characteristics that make work appealing: exaggeration, surprise, metaphor, and connections between ideas. They help dictate whether audiencÂes give their attention to a piece – and stay interÂested.
From self-portraits to religious iconography, visual art often centers the human form. “These questions of human identity have been the cornerstone of art from cave paintings onward,” says Kozbelt. “What made the 20th century interesting, artistically, wasn’t simply a break from realism that had been finally mastered. And now, with the advent of photography, oh heck, what do we do now?”
Over the last millennium of Western art, depictions of people became increasingly realistic before beÂcoming abstract roughly 100 years ago.
“Basic proportions of the body, people will figure out very early how to do that. But they’re still stiff and the shading isn’t quite right, and facial expresÂsions are really tough,” says Kozbelt. “Probably by 1500, most of the problems have been solved. And then what? And then you have artists — MichelanÂgelo exaggerates these figures. You get these long figures — Mannerism or El Greco. Departures from the solution, because the solution has already been achieved.”
Cubism famously departed from realism, breaking forms into different perspectives. But one of its inÂventors, Pablo Picasso, lived through many artistic eras. Kozbelt points out that the painter was active until his death in the early 1970s.
Kozbelt studies not only artistic movements, but the lifespans of individual artists. He spent six years , measuring their minor works through great masterpieces.
Like creative movements, creators often develop. The ones who have long careers certainly do.
“There are artists who get better and better, and there are artists who peak early and get worse, and they approach the creative process very differentÂly,” says Kozbelt. “The ones who get better are inÂcrementalists. They try the same thing over and over… The ones who peak early are trying to break all the rules. They have a clear sense of what they’re doing. Then they do it, and then they’re done.”
In another experiment, subjects rated paintings of students and masters at various points in the proÂcess. Pictures that had a smooth, upward trajectory ended with middling satisfaction from the audience. Highly successful paintings rated with jagged ups and downs along the way. “Basically,” says Kozbelt, “The more interesting the process, the more interÂesting the product.”
Artists that continue to experiment, building on an established foundation, can remain relevant their entire lives. In his study on composers, Kozbelt found that those artists peak in their mid-50s before experiencing a slow decline.
Visual artists not only develop their own style, but they develop how they see the world.
In 2017, Kozbelt published “.” His team gave subjects dark tape to outline a picture of a face. In essence, they creatÂed a line drawing. “What you find is that the artists are just much, much better at allocating where to put things to suggest the form or identity of the obÂject that way, the capacity to know what information is important to focus their attention,” he explains. “Matching their perception to what tools they have to use to make the depiction.”
Kozbelt says audiences can understand even simÂple line drawings.
Caricatures can be even more recognizable than reÂalistic, faithful representations. Kozbelt points out traditions like ancient Indian statues, where female forms have exaggeratedly small waists. He says those body shapes are physically impossible, but code the figure immediately as women by emphaÂsizing the differences between gender expressions.
Old wisdom suggests that artists have better visual perception because they learn to “unsee” their subÂjects and draw what is strictly in front of them. KozÂbelt disagrees. He says, instead, skilled drafters can make educated decisions.
“If you forget what you know, then you’ll avoid some rookie mistakes. But that’s not going to allow you to put together a really compelling depiction of something that you’re looking at,” he explains. “You have to decide what aspects of this thing are important to include.”
From deities to everyday people, artists see people in a different light than we do. Their secret to evolution — as a movement or a person — is to experiment with surprises while staying familiar.
