June 1, 2026 |

The Right to Flourish as a Family

By Anna Leah

Some have children naturally, some find them through adoption. But laws have evolving and sometimes contradictory views on other ways to build a family ��� especially through surrogacy.

The law recognizes a human right to reproduce. Murkier is our inherent right to parent. For over 20 years, , a professor at the CUNYSchool of Law, has looked for clarity on how the law defines parental connection ��� practically and philosophically ��� as technology expands possibilities and different jurisdictions disagree.

���Haven’t we evolved in such a way that we’re allowing people to become parents, even though they’re not becoming parents in the traditional way?��� the legal theorist asks rhetorically. ���By and large, as a society we believe that’s a good thing. We don’t want to place roadblocks in front of people who are motivated to be parents.���

Recently, Storrow has been writing about property law. A few years ago, about brought him back to his surrogacy research.

He had already amassed interviews with healthcare professionals in Pennsylvania, which permitted surrogacy. That gave Storrow an on-the-ground view of how birth certificates are written. He for birth certificates as he did for surrogate parents: people have a right to define their own family and identity, regardless of what a DNA test says or an obstetrician sees in a delivery room.

���The child deserves to be identified as a citizen, as a child of their parents,��� says Storrow. ���And that’s what birth certificates do for transgender folks.���

Over the years, as Storrow followed surrogacy laws, he noted a trend towards acceptance in the U.S. The same is not true in Europe.

釦喧棗娶娶棗滄���s explored how the European Court of Human Rights answered questions of surrogate-carried children���s parentage ��� especially in countries that banned the practice. The between different sovereign states.

Italy and France ban surrogacy. The Court heard cases brought by parents from each country who tried to gain legal status for their child born via surrogate in another country. In a French case, the father had a genetic connection. In an Italian case, neither parent did. The Court found the French couple had a right to have their parentage recognized, but the Italian parents did not.

Storrow says French law is probably ���concerned about how good it is for children, or how necessary it is for children, to be with their genetic progenitors. That’s really the gold standard of parenting in a French context.���

The Court sided with the French parents, finding that the case hinged on the child���s ability to assert their identity and, therefore, their nationality.

The Court allowed Italy, though, to set its own public policy. The Court reasoned that, without any genetic determinants, the government could make its own decisions about recognizing parents.

Much of Western Europe still opposes gestational surrogacy. In Eastern Europe, surrogacy has become an industry without a lot of regulation. The U.S. lacks constitutional legal guidance, so states legislate these questions. Storrow explains the laws��� roles are to determine, ���Who is the best person that we should name to have the responsibility to care for a child, so that the state doesn’t have to?���

New York State recently passed a law after decades of assumptions that surrogacy exploits the gestational mother. Storrow says that legislators made state-of-the-art regulations that include a . Its guarantees include that the surrogate retains the choice to terminate the pregnancy and make healthcare decisions.

Some lawmakers pushed back ��� in New York and other states ��� by trying to make surrogacy have similarly onerous screening processes as adoption. But laws are trending towards recognizing surrogacy as an agreement between consenting adults.

���Why wouldn’t we think that would be in the best interest of the child?��� Storrow asks. ���These are parents that want this child. They’re willing to create this child.���

It���s one thing to talk about human rights and civil rights, says Storrow. But such concepts move slowly ��� statutory law moves quicker, helping society move in a given direction. Storrow doesn���t see a children���s bill of rights on the horizon, nor a definition of the right to parent. But he does see American state laws opening to surrogacy regulation.

���Human rights are all about human flourishing and the most important role of the state or government is to encourage human flourishing,��� says Storrow. ���I don’t think humans flourish when they’re being dictated to about what they can and can���t do with their lives.���