By Leandra Manon
A showed adults under 30 trust information from social media and national news media roughly equally. Questions about journalistic reliability grow every day, along with discussions about objectivity. On one side of the conversation, distance allows a reporter to accurately cover a subject. On the other side, familiarity with a topic can lead writers to deeper, more nuanced stories with fuller context.
Journalists like usher in a new sense of objectivity, one that doesn���t separate the reporter���s lived experience from the narrative. Instead, it acknowledges their own humanity.
���I don’t pretend that there is some kind of objectivity,��� says Villarosa. ���I bring my whole self to my reporting, and I think this is a newer way to report.���
The award-winning writer holds a joint professorship at the City College of New York and Craig Newmark Graduate School of Journalism at 勛圖弝け. Her work lies at the intersection of social justice and public health, covering topics pertaining to racial inequity and life expectancy.
In her 2017 article, , she explored America’s deep racial disparities in Black maternal and infant healthcare. The article centers on Simone Landrum, a young, expecting mother who had suffered the loss of her previous baby. After medical staff dismissed her concerns in the delivery room, she nearly died from preeclampsia.
The article blends personal narrative and traditional journalistic practice. The story follows Landrum and probes the healthcare system���s treatment of Black women and children. Villarosa also recounts her own birthing story, giving another intimate perspective.
The reality is that maternal mortality rates for Black women are significantly higher than white, Hispanic, and Asian women ��� at roughly in 2023. The mortality rate for Black/African American infants than infants nationwide the same year.
Villarosa���s story adds a personal element to the data. She helps show that some causes can impact Black women of all class backgrounds. This moves the conversation away from the harmful stereotypes that often target Black women from a lower economic background.
While reporting, Villarosa found herself in a sensitive environment. She witnessed Landrum���s birthing process and the harsh treatment healthcare workers gave her for the second time.
���Even though she had been so traumatized by her other birth, these people did not care,��� recalls Villarosa. ���It wasn’t hard [to remain objective], because the objective lens was also my personal lens. Objectively, they should not have been treating her that way.���
Attention to social justice issues has increased in recent years. Yet reporters of color are often questioned for their capacity to remain neutral, even if an issue���s personal resonance may allow them to add needed nuance.
Villarosa previously edited at Essence, a lifestyle magazine serving a Black female readership. There, she produced health stories in an environment that allowed her to follow her curiosity without needing to justify her subjects’ humanity. She says, ���You don’t get pushback when you’re writing Black stories for Black people.���
Later working for the New York Times proved a different story. A lack of diversity in the media led to hunger for the kind of articles she wrote. Black and Hispanic Americans make up about one-third of the U.S. workforce, but they represent less than one-sixth of newsroom employees. Still, Villarosa found herself having to advocate for her ideas.
Before they published her article on , Villarosa���s editors shut it down during the pitching process. Her friend and colleague, , urged her to pursue the idea.
���She took me aside and she said, ���We’re going back. We are going to get more data and we are not going to let them beat us down. They don’t know what we know,���” says Villarosa. ���We ended up getting a two-part series in the New York Times.���
Villarosa says developing evidence-based ideas and understanding the issues can help create pitches that editors don���t dismiss. Ethical reporting requires ensuring sources understand your position as a reporter and grant proper consent ��� regardless of your shared connection.
Villarosa also makes sure her sources are comfortable. She recounts going to a barbecue held by an LGBTQ support group as she reported her article, . Grilling ribs might not be in her job description, but Villarosa immersed herself in the community���s space. ���I wanted them to know I’m a real person,��� she says.
���I’m trying to report as ethically and with a layer of compassion as I can, because if you’re working on social justice issues, a lot of times you are dealing with people who have been affected by something bad,��� says Villarosa. ���I don’t want it to turn bad for the people who trusted me.���
