By Laura Tamayo
For the past several years, a young teen named John has had a kidney disease. He received a transplant, but his condition worsened. The kidney had to be removed. He now receives dialysis, which makes him very weak and generally unhappy. His mother is erratic and psychologically unstable. His grandmother is more concerned, but her presence is unreliable. Should John be allowed to reattempt the transplant? If so, who should make the decision?
Jeffrey Blustein has been asking these sorts of questions for decades. As at The City College of New York, he has studied topics in moral psychology from the ethics of memory to bioethics. He pioneered family ethics in moral philosophy with his 1982 book, .
In 2024, he co-authored with Johan C. Bester. The article suggests guidelines for caregivers to ethically interact with their children. It defines childhood interests as identifiable components of a child���s well-being that should help determine caregivers��� behavior. Two main facets exist: while children will grow to have different conceptions of a good life, they must have their fundamental interests secured – like food, health, and social interaction.
For many years, Blustein served as a clinical bioethics researcher at Montefiore Einstein Medical Center. There, he confronted situations in which a guardian���s desires did not align with their child���s interests or medical professionals��� judgment. Those moments raised questions about the limits of parental authority.
He has also studied whether biological connections should give priority to parents in medical decision-making and how conflicts between them and other caregivers should be adjudicated.
Difficult questions proliferate. Who has the moral authority to make decisions for young children? Does an adolescent have the capacity and moral right to make their own decisions? How can one assess a minor���s decision, if it conflicts with their guardian? May a parent ever do less than what is in the best interests of their child?
���The law is already making ethical statements about this, and not always correctly,��� states Blustein.
From their moral philosophical approach, Blustein and Bester suggested a number of guidelines for optimal relationships between physicians, guardians, and youth. The researchers weighed each party���s responsibility to each other.
In 2022, an expert working group of healthcare professionals, lawyers, and bioethicists endorsed the guidelines. The suggestions both affirm and regulate the voice of guardians, who must constrain the absolute agency of another person ��� their child, who faces practical restraints to their decision-making abilities. Likewise, the guidelines respect clinicians��� professional knowledge to intervene when the basic interests of the patient are threatened.
Children and adolescents are in a deeply impressionable moment of life, with little experience, so their autonomy cannot be total. Blustein and Bester argue that caregivers should create conditions for children to develop their own rational conception of the good. Of course, this is never as simple as it sounds.
To navigate these complexities, Blustein advocates a philosophical approach. ���What do parents owe their children? What does it mean to be a good parent? Or a good enough parent?��� he argues. “These are not terms that can be explained solely in psychological language.���
Indeed, they require many perspectives, including from philosophy, evidence-based medicine, and the law. As medical decision-making is unsystemizable, an ethical philosophy for youth in healthcare must be carefully considered.
Philosophy, as a field, pursues careful analysis and reconstruction of moral norms. It offers us a way to think about our relations with one another and provides paths of contemplation for healthcare professionals, medical researchers, and policymakers. Though the discipline cannot necessarily give clear-cut answers, it can offer questions and principles to reference.
���General truths about young people provide a starting point for understanding how to relate to them,��� says Blustein. ���It���s important to start with general standards and then analyze exceptions.���
This is just as true for the ethics of decision-making in pediatric healthcare as the practice of medicine itself.
