By H Conley
When you work with children as an educator or care worker, you become a mandated reporter. If you notice signs of potential child abuse, neglect, or maltreatment, you���re legally required to report it to authorities. Mandated reporting laws were originally passed to protect children, but they have come under for perpetuating harms against families ��� especially those who are Black, Indigenous or living in poverty.
A recent graduate from Macaulay Honors College and Lehman College, investigated how mandated reporting functions as a surveillance tool. She examined how it disproportionately tears apart Black families, particularly those with LGBTQ+ caregivers. Her paper, ���Better Safe than Sorry: Racialized and Queer Family Policing through Mandatory Reporting,��� won the 2026 Outstanding Undergraduate Research Award for and won a Best Poster award at the 2026 CUNYCelebration of Undergraduate Research.
St Fort became interested in the carceral system at a young age. Her mom was a corrections officer at Rikers Island but was critical of America���s policing and prison system. Living in Flatbush, Brooklyn, and Jamaica, Queens, St Fort saw the policing of unhoused community members. She developed her perspective while working with the organization in high school.
In college, she wanted to understand what surveillance looks like outside the policing system. That led her to mandatory reporting.
���Mandatory reporting is the entry point into family policing for many,��� says St Fort. ���So, it���s the best place to start, if you want to limit exposure to the family policing system.���
St Fort conducted research with a focus on the perspectives of impacted families. One invaluable resource was , a local New York publication written by parents who have faced the family policing system. She found story after story where poverty or lack of resources led to a family being reported. Often, mandatory reporters thought that families would be connected to assistance once reported, but that rarely happened.
���A lot of people report families because they think it���ll help them get access to aid,��� says St Fort. ���I came from the perspective of ���you don���t want a cop at your door,��� so I was surprised people would think help was available.���
St Fort also conducted interviews with experts advocating for reforming or abolishing the family policing system. They helped her form the solutions section of her research.
She discovered that, after a child abuse report gets made to the New York State hotline, there���s a screening process to determine if a case will get sent to Child Protective Services (CPS). If a case is sent to CPS, a case manager is required to investigate it. So, introducing an intervention at the call center could save many families from being investigated. Right now, 80% of calls are forwarded to CPS, which is the fourth highest rate in the country.
���Whoever���s picking up the phone call is assessing if it���s an issue or not,��� says St Fort. ���The majority of calls are getting moved onto the reporting process without the people at the call center asking follow-up questions.���
By introducing a questionnaire, screeners at the call center could better determine if a mandated reporter has enough information to justify the report. California has a procedure called Structured Decision Making, which has screeners ask questions like if there is a non-perpetrating caregiver who knows about the allegations and has demonstrated they can appropriately protect the child. The guidance breaks down a variety of indicators of abuse and factors that should be considered when assessing a child’s safety.
Overall, states including New York, Colorado, and California are considering major reforms to their mandatory reporting policies.
Another spot to intervene is to introduce reforms for mandated reporters. Teachers and other professionals tasked with reporting might have qualms about making a report, but fear being punished for not reporting. They might not have clear guidelines on when to report or a full understanding of what happens to families after they���re reported. Organizations such as and advocate for and educate about harm reduction techniques.
���Most people don���t go into professions like teaching because they want to police families,��� says St Fort. ���I have a lot of sympathy for mandated reporters.���
While St Fort hopes to continue her research on family policing, her angle will change next year. She was selected as a , so she will move to Beijing for a master���s program in global affairs. She plans to do comparative analysis of Chinese and American cultural values and its impact on the creation of laws about the well-being of children and their families. After that, she hopes to study law so that she can contribute to reform efforts.
