By Andrea TamayoÌý
In 1986, Kyriakos S. Markides and Jeannine Coreil found that Hispanics in the Southwest . This was despite having lower income and education levels.ÌýÌý
This phenomenon, now commonly known as the “Hispanic Paradoxâ€�, has intrigued for over 20 years. Based at the CUNYGraduate School of Public Health and Health Policy, Borrell studies health disparities among Latinos in the United States and revisits the paradox to understand how it is changing. As Hispanic people face challenges that will worsen their health, she doesn’t believe the paradox will hold up much longer.Ìý
In the decades following the publication of Markides’ paper, researchers proposed many theories.Ìý
One idea was the “salmon bias,â€� that sick or elderly immigrants return to their home country to die. Scholars suggested the “healthy migrant effect,â€� the belief that healthier people emigrate. Neither of these theories has been shown to explain the paradox. Borrell believes that several factors contribute, including the health of the people who move, cultural norms, and social support within Hispanic families.Ìý
The Hispanic population in the U.S. is not a monolith, she says. They identify with at least 19 countries in the Caribbean and Latin America, with one in three born outside the U.S. They represent a wide range of socioeconomic statuses. People also vary in how they identify with race. This diversity impacts health outcomes. Cuban and Mexican Americans have some of the highest life expectancies, while Puerto Ricans and Dominicans often face more health inequities.Ìý
In the early 2000s, Borrell looked into racial variation among Hispanics. Racial assumptions had impacted her. An immigrant from the Dominican Republic, she noticed that many people thought she was only Black because she didn’t have a stereotypical Hispanic-sounding last name. “When I opened my mouth, everybody started to ask me ‘Where are you from? Where is the accent from?’â€� she said.Ìý
In 2005, she published , with special emphasis on racial identity and the number of Hispanics who identify as Black. “When we examine the health outcomes between the Hispanics that identify as white and the Hispanics that identify as Black, the advantage in the context of the paradox is among the Hispanics that identify as white,â€� she says.Ìý
Hispanics who identify as Black may be subject to the same disadvantages as non-Hispanic Blacks, including racial prejudice and discrimination.Ìý
The pandemic revealed a trove of health inequities.Ìý
In the first few months after the national lockdown was instated, government agencies didn’t collect race and ethnicity data. Fortunately, New York City had its own collection system, . Unfortunately, vaccine distribution efforts prioritized neighborhoods with lower infection and mortality rates. Vaccines were more available in places like the Upper West Side than Harlem, Washington Heights, and Jackson Heights, where many Hispanic people live.ÌýÌý
Hispanic people often live in multi-generational households, and many were essential workers, says Borrell. Often, they would go to work and then return home and transmit the disease to family members.Ìý
Tragically, Hispanic and Black people in the U.S. lost the most years, in terms of life expectancy, during the pandemic. Hispanics lost about four years. Yet, their life expectancy still surpasses those of white people by over a year.Ìý
Borrell thinks the “Hispanic Paradoxâ€� may soon end. Today, Hispanics or Latinos of all ages and health statuses immigrate. They are no longer the majority of young, healthy men that we saw in the early waves of migration. Acculturation has led to the loss of traditional social support, which benefits Hispanics’ health. And the new administration has imposed numerous, damaging challenges.ÌýÌý
Since President Donald Trump took office, he issued at least 16 executive orders aimed at immigration. Most target Hispanic people, says Borrell. Additionally, the government has slashed research funds for studying domestic Hispanic populations. Prior to these cuts, only a few national studies focused on Hispanic health. The most comprehensive long-term project, the has tracked health and diseases among Hispanic or Latino people since 2006. “But I don’t know if this is going to continue, given the new administration and the fact that they consider any targeted program as discriminatory against other groups,â€� says Borrell.Ìý
Borrell recently revisited the “Hispanic Paradoxâ€� in a special issue of the American Journal of Public Health celebrating Hispanic Heritage Month. In the , the researchers write “the Hispanic health advantage observed over the past 40 years is at risk [of] disappearing.â€�Ìý
She notes that a few things should be done. Researchers and policymakers need to consider the diversity of the population, “because one size doesn’t fit all,â€� says Borrell. “The other thing is that we cannot ignore mental health.â€�ÌýÌý
The threat of U.S. Immigration Customs and Enforcement arrests hurts the mental health of Hispanic communities, especially children. Lastly, she encourages collaboration among researchers who work to reduce health inequities. If an intervention works well for one group, it needs to be shared and developed to benefit the entire nation.Ìý
