By H Conley
Like height and hair color, gender norms pass from parents to children. Beliefs, cultural traditions, and communities shape the gendered roles people play in society. Núria RodrÃguez-Planas, PhD, believes that economists have a lot to reveal about how gendered expectations impact mothers and everyone else.
RodrÃguez-Planas is at Queens College studying labor, education, and cultural economics. Her research over the past 15 years has looked at , , and through the lens of gender.
“Going into this research, I did not expect that culture would have such strong and long-lasting impacts,â€� says RodrÃguez-Planas. “Yet, the evidence shows that culture persists over time and across generations.â€�
In her research, you can trace two paths an average woman’s life could take.
On one path is a woman raised with progressive values, like women have the same rights as men to work when jobs are scarce or girls are just as good as boys at math. On average, she will probably (1) perform as well in scientific subjects as her male peers in high school, (2) continue to work and have a higher income as a young mother, (3) not be a victim of intimate partner violence, and (4) be financially literate.
This adds up to more productivity and better economic independence. She is also more likely to engage in riskier behaviors during adolescence, like experimenting with drugs. This phase doesn’t generally have long-term impacts on future earnings or employment.
A woman raised in a more conservative household is more likely to fall behind on math scores in high school and depend on her partner financially. That can make it harder to escape a violent relationship and generally lead to worse long-term outcomes.
The first five years after giving birth are critical. RodrÃguez-Planas and her colleague, , studied how grandmothers’ attitudes impacted the likelihood that their daughters worked after the birth of their first child. They used the , which includes data from more than 29 countries. Growing up with progressive beliefs increased the chance that the young mother works.
In contrast, young mothers from more traditional environments are less likely to work than women without children. This pattern doesn’t exist for men. When women become mothers, their income often decreases. When men become fathers, their income often grows.
Ultimately, RodrÃguez-Planas’ research aims to understand how an individual’s behaviors impact their lifetime productivity. Higher rates of productivity benefit the economy overall.
“Some people think that women acquiring more gender equality in the labor market will imply that men lose some rights,â€� says RodrÃguez-Planas. “But research shows that women aren’t taking pieces of the pie away from men. Instead, gender equality in society creates a bigger pie for everyone to share.â€�
While gendered expectations affect women, RodrÃguez-Planas highlights that they also impact men. Evidence shows that men raised with non-traditional gender norms tend to perform better academically in high school, are more financially literate, and are or perpetrate intimate partner violence.
“Several years ago, people were questioning the importance of researching gender norms because the playing field seemed to be leveling out for men and women,â€� says RodrÃguez-Planas. “But culture is like a pendulum that swings between traditional and progressive values, and now we’re swinging back to traditional norms.â€�
Politics and culture are closely intertwined. Policies promoting traditional gender roles both in the U.S. and internationally. RodrÃguez-Planas says her job is to analyze how institutions and culture impact individuals’ choices.
“I aim at identifying causation, not just associations,� she says. “Evidence seems to indicate that greater gender equity blurs the behavioral gender divide and improves outcomes for everyone.�
What the rest of us do with those findings is up to us.
