by Anna Leah
At the end of Fall 2024 finals, Lehman College history professor Joseph Dauben was frustrated. He was teaching a writing-intensive course about the history of science. For their last paper, he asked his students to critique reviews of James Watson���s The Double Helix, his controversial account of discovering DNA���s double helical structure.
Dauben���s goal was to teach his students how to write, but he could tell that many had the help of an unauthorized collaborator: artificial intelligence.
���Until a couple of years ago, I was reading a lot of, frankly, terrible essays. But that left plenty of room to help students improve their writing.��� Now, he says, he receives very readable papers that differ markedly from the messages his students send him. Moreover, they hallucinated reviews, even citing page numbers and authors not included in the assigned readings.
���I don���t need to grade a paper generated by AI,��� observes Dauben. ���I���d really much rather have my students do their own work, bad writing and all. At least it’s theirs and I can work with that.���
Earlier this year, Bloomsbury Academic (London) published a six-volume study, A Cultural History of Mathematics. Dauben co-edited it with one of his former CUNYgraduate students, David Rowe.
More than fifty scholars contributed chapters to this work tracing the story of mathematics from ancient Egypt to modern computing. Dauben especially focused on the Medieval and ancient Chinese sections, two of his areas of expertise.
Dauben���s career began with biographies of mathematicians ��� including Georg Cantor, who theorized about the actual infinite (inventing transfinite set theory) and Abraham Robinson, who explored mathematical infinitesimals (with his creation of nonstandard analysis).
For the first part of 2025, the Isaac Newton Institute for Mathematical Sciences at the University of Cambridge invited Daubens as a Simons Fellow. There, he���ll pursue a new historiographic project on the historians of modern mathematics.
Although Dauben doesn���t see many benefits of AI for college writing, he says that people of other eras often met technological revolutions with a mixture of optimism and skepticism.
In the early 1600s, Galileo Galilei unveiled his improved telescope, which he eventually refined to magnify heavenly bodies to look 30 times larger than with the naked eye. For the first time, users could see the moons of Jupiter, phases of Venus, and craters on the Moon.
Like AI today, according to Dauben, some critics suspected the fidelity of some observations. Many were not trained to look through a telescope and didn���t see anything at all. Others used lenses that weren���t ground to Galileo���s exacting specifications, resulting in distorted images.
���Some people had questions and others rejected what was being reported as being hallucinatory imaginings of people like Galileo,��� Dauben explains.
But despite such controversies, the Scientific and Industrial Revolutions stirred the popular imagination, according to Dauben. He points to historian Marjorie Hope Nicolson, who wrote about literary allusions to the discoveries of Copernicus and Galileo – like in the works of Shakespeare and Milton. Overall, he says, literate society was excited about the latest scientific and technological developments.
But, says Dauben, ���By the time you get to the 19th century, a wholly different phase of the Industrial Revolution, you begin to see people, the Luddites for example, and authors like Charles Dickens, who were not at all sure that the new technology, the machine age, was going to be for the better.���
Dauben observes that those machines took over tedious tasks, freeing people to do what machinery couldn���t.
In the face of AI, Dauben sees the literary works of Ray Bradbury and Isaac Asimov as having relevant warnings about the isolating and destructive potential of technology. He cites the ���Three Laws of Robotics��� from Asimov���s I, Robot as an example: a robot may not harm a human, it must obey humans, and it must protect itself (so long as each rule didn���t conflict with the preceding ones).
���The day may come when increasing leisure is something that people will have to deal with,��� says Dauben of the potential freedom AI could give people. He himself has begun transitioning towards retiring in three years. He intends to spend his newfound time with books rather than AI, including a stack of novels he looks forward to reading with the added free time that he hopes retirement will provide.
