By Anna Leah泭
Stoics might have a reputation for apathy, but Massimo Pigliucci says they have a lot to teach us about life ��� and love.泭
Stoics actually care a lot, according to Pigliucci. He says that Stoics emphasize the need for people to courageously use their reasoning to live in a pro-social way. Their reputation might come from the fact that they distinguish between ���externals��� (life factors they cannot control) and what they can control.泭
���The stiff upper lip notion comes from the fact that, in Stoicism, endurance is a virtue,��� explains Pigliucci. ���If something happens to you and there���s nothing you can do about it, throwing a tantrum isn���t going to help.���泭
At the beginning of 2025, the (and trained biologist) published . It includes life guidance from the ancient Greeks and Romans. To explore his interpretation of modern dating, he turned to his 2019 essay about the popular Netflix series, Black Mirror.泭泭
With existentialist philosopher Skye Cleary, he wrote ������泭
Reviewers have compared Black Mirror to The Twilight Zone, in that each edition of the anthology deals with themes of the near future and the meaning of life. Pigliucci often uses popular culture to explore these ideas, like his CCNY course about one of his favorite shows, Star Trek. ���Some of my, shall we say, traditionalist colleagues kind of frown on the notion of what they see as watering down the teaching by using pop culture,��� says Pigliucci. ���I just think they’re dinosaurs.���泭
Pigliucci continues, ���Philosophy, at its best, it���s being aware of what might be going on and questioning what���s going on behind the surface.���泭
In the episode, ���Hang the DJ,��� a digital ���Coach��� matches two characters and tells them how long their relationship will last. The pair falls for each other but is assigned various other relationships before reuniting. Towards the end, they must choose to accept their fate of a promised ���Ultimate Match��� based on the algorithm or exile themselves from the all-providing ���System.���泭
According to Pigliucci, the pair���s acquiescence to the Coach contradicts what both Stoics and Existentialists recommend.泭
He explains that the Existentialists focus on living authentically, even if a person���s essence is fluid. ���It’s not a fixed thing, and on this the Stoics would agree. Your ability to make decisions is the most important thing you can possibly have,��� he says.泭
���For the Stoics, you take responsibility for your decisions. So, you don���t let a machine, or an algorithm decide for you,��� Pigliucci explains. 泭
He says the Stoics had a sophisticated system of understanding emotions, which he compares to Cognitive Behavioral Therapy. ���All emotions have a cognitive component ��� there is no sharp distinction between emotions and reason.���泭
A Black Mirror-like algorithm might make better matches than people, but the process conflicts with both Stoic and Existentialist philosophies. “It would be inauthentic, because it wouldn���t be your choice,��� he explains. ���You���re alienating yourself from yourself because you���re not in charge anymore.���泭
Pigliucci says that modern psychology identify three stages of love: lust, romance, and attachment. He says that Stoics would encourage people to hurry through the hormones of lust and the fantasies of romance as soon as possible, before they make love-drunk decisions they later regret.泭
Here���s where Existentialists may differ, according to Pigliucci. The heavily drinking and smoking crowd of 1900s Paris indulged. He explains, ���They were famous for having love affairs all over the place, so clearly they had no problems with lust.���泭
The ancient Greek philosophers didn���t ignore love. Pigliucci describes drinking parties, where attendees read poetry and debated life. In , Socrates and Aristophanes gave speeches about eros. Alcibiades then crashed the party and passionately orated about his unrequited love for Socrates. ���There was not a large literature on philosophy and love, at least until recently. But you do find these gems,��� recounts Pigliucci. ���It���s one of the fundamental aspects of human existence. So, it would be really weird that philosophers not take a look at it from time to time.���泭
Philosophers also examine age-old human dynamics: money and power. Pigliucci reminds us that technology corporations devise and implement many of these algorithms.泭
Pigliucci says that good philosophy speaks truth to power ��� like the pre-Socratic Heraclitus, who gave up his throne to tell people they were sleepwalking through life.泭泭
Philosophy acts like good comedy. A philosophical argument and a joke share similar structures. ���The comedian leads you in a certain direction, you think, you know where it’s going. And there is a sharp turn somewhere and that’s the punch line,��� Pigliucci says.泭
���The reason comedians are funny, if they’re funny, is because they look at things in a different perspective – and the same is true of philosophers and their arguments, even when they are not funny!���泭
