Testimony of Senior Vice Chancellor Glenda G. Grace
The City University of New York
Higher Education Committee Hearing
Oversight: Examining Anti-Semitism on College Campus
Thursday, June 30, 2022
Good morning, Chair Dinowitz and members of the New York City Council Committee on Higher Education, staff and guests. I am Glenda G. Grace, Senior Vice Chancellor of Institutional Affairs, Strategic Advancement and Special Counsel at The City University of New York. I am joined this morning by President Robin Garrell of the CUNYGraduate Center and Vice Chancellor for Student Affairs Denise Maybank.
CUNYserves approximately 260,000 degree-seeking students, 185,000 in adult and continuing education programs, 18,400 faculty and 21,500 staff at our 11 four-year colleges, seven community colleges and seven graduate and professional schools. And I have had the privilege of working at CUNYfor 13 years – at Hostos Community College, at Queens College and, since 2019, at the Central Office.
The City Council has been a steadfast supporter of ³Ô¹ÏÊÓÆµ. And we thank you for that support.
As an institution of higher learning, the City University of New York takes pride in our unwavering support of free speech, academic freedom and freedoms protected under the First Amendment of the Constitution of the United States. We are legally required to allow the expression of multiple viewpoints on campus.
We understand that opinions of a political nature can create tension when members of our community stand on conflicting sides of polarizing issues and causes that are undergirded by deeply held convictions. We believe the best way to counter the resulting discord is to expand upon the work we do across our campuses to encourage scholarship, dialogue, tolerance and civil engagement that fosters understanding and a way forward. This is the hard and ongoing work that we need to embrace to counter the violence, hate, antisemitism and racism that can creep into our campuses, our country and the world.
Diversity, inclusion, and an environment free from discrimination are central to the mission of the University. CUNYunequivocally denounces antisemitism in every form. Arguably the country’s most diverse urban University, CUNYis not immune to tensions between different groups. Chancellor Félix V. Matos RodrÃguez has focused on elevating dialogue and building bridges between people and groups of different backgrounds whose beliefs and divergent experiences and histories sometimes place them at odds. This focus is evidenced by one of Chancellor Matos RodrÃguez’s early asks of former City Council Speaker Corey Johnson –- funding for the newly created CUNYDiversity, Equity and Inclusion Incubator, a multi-year initiative to support campuses in creating vital cultural and systemic shifts across CUNYcentering values of antiracism, justice and equity. Thank you for the Council’s continued support of this important initiative.
This is not the only concrete action CUNYhas taken to deal with antisemitism. CUNYhas been outspoken and unequivocal about decrying the increase in antisemitic violence and bigotry in New York City and the nation. Over the past year, the University has issued four statements that unambiguously emphasize the role that higher education can and must play in dismantling the many manifestations of bigotry and hate that have emerged and continue to spread. Let me summarize the messages conveyed in those statements, and then share ways that CUNYis working toward an environment that is free from antisemitism.
First, the University has made it abundantly clear that ³Ô¹ÏÊÓÆµâ€™s student and faculty senates, its faculty union and various membership groups are free to voice opinions on a wide range of issues, but speak for themselves when they do so. The positions they express are entirely theirs and do not represent the views of the City University of New York.
Further, the University has asserted and consistently reiterated that it does not support Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions (BDS) against Israel and, pursuant to New York State Executive Order 157, CUNYis prohibited from participating in or supporting BDS activities and is required to divest public funds from any companies that do.
Additionally, the University clarified the process by which a student speaker was selected to deliver remarks at the 2022 Law School Commencement. Student commencement speakers are chosen by their fellow graduates to deliver remarks. They speak for themselves, not on behalf of their school or the University, and the opinions they express are their own.
Statements are important, but we also understand that more has to be done. Students, staff, or faculty who feel that they have been discriminated against or harassed are able to bring a complaint under our Equal Opportunity and Non-Discrimination Policy. This policy protects against discrimination based on protected characteristics — which include race, color, religion, sex, gender, national origin, and any of the other bases prohibited by this policy — and harassment for all protected characteristics other than sex (Sexual harassment is covered under ³Ô¹ÏÊÓÆµâ€™s Policy on Sexual Misconduct). Students can go to Student Affairs officials, the campus Chief Diversity Officer or the public safety office to make such a report about potential discrimination and/or harassment. Faculty and staff can go to Human Resources departments, the campus Chief Diversity Officer or the Public Safety office.
As I stated, CUNYis engaged every day in the hard, ongoing and imperative work that we need to embrace to counter violence, hate, antisemitism and racism that exists in the world. Let me share with you some of this work.
In early April 2022, Chancellor Matos RodrÃguez, several CUNYpresidents, senior administrators and I attended the two-day Summit on Campus Antisemitism sponsored by the American Jewish Council, in partnership with Hillel International and the American Council on Education. During the Summit, expert-led sessions were conducted about best practices to fight anti-Jewish hate and a small group meeting was held with a group of Hillel leaders from CUNYcampuses to discuss specific concerns and ways we could better partner with one another to improve the lives of Jewish students on campuses.
In late April 2022, Chancellor Matos RodrÃguez led a delegation of 12 CUNYcollege presidents and deans to Israel to participate in a weeklong tour of the country’s cities, higher education institutions, and historic sites. The “Scholars as Bridge Buildersâ€� visit was organized by the Jewish Community Relations Council of New York (JCRC-NY), which has conducted visits to Israel with educational leaders for seven years and more general tours for 35 years. The delegation was able to explore education’s role in addressing the challenges of working to find common ground in a climate of complex political and religious significance, and gain an enriched perspective on the bridges that could be built by members of communities as diverse as ours here at ³Ô¹ÏÊÓÆµ. You will hear more about this trip from President Garrell.
There are also many other central and campus initiatives and activities combating hate in general and antisemitism specifically.
CUNYrecently hired a University Director of Student Intercultural Engagement and Dialogue. This newly established position in the University Office of Student Affairs was created to help develop and administer programs and resources that facilitate outreach and engagement among student communities that have historically experienced conflict and tensions associated with faith perspectives, race and ethnicity, and intercultural communication. This position will enhance dialogue, training and understanding around critical concepts including antisemitism, Islamophobia, racism, and xenophobia. Additionally, the Director will facilitate discussion and reflection about how associated lived experiences are inextricably bound up with the intersectional elements of identity. Our new Director is no stranger to CUNYas she helped lead the City Council-funded Diversity Incubator as well as the Center for Ethnic, Racial and Religious Understanding at Queens College (CERRU). With direction from the University Office of Student Affairs, this newly created position will help transform CUNYcampuses into models of equitable spaces that proactively work to eliminate biased and discriminatory behavior. You will hear more about central efforts to foster an environment that allows all students to thrive from Vice Chancellor Maybank.
I want to share a sampling of campus efforts that foster an inclusive environment allowing all CUNYstudents, faculty and staff to learn, dialogue and thrive. Campus efforts include:
- Academic Engagement Network’s Antisemitism Education Initiative: This Initiative is funded by $75,000 grant from Academic Engagement Network’s Antisemitism Education Initiative to Hillel at Baruch College; they are partnering with City College and John Jay College. AEN’s approaches include strategic mapping, advocacy, engagement, education, and coalition building around issues of Antisemitism. Education includes seminar speaker series and creating a comprehensive, scalable, user-friendly curriculum for students and staff.
- “We Stand Against Hate�: Throughout the past academic year, the Brooklyn College initiative featured lectures, workshops, concerts, programs, and events that reflect the college’s ongoing commitment to elevating dialogue, enhancing understanding and compassion, and celebrating the voices that make up the diverse campus community.
- “Confronting Anti-Semitism�: The Center for Jewish Studies at Hunter College launched an annual semester long program funded in part from a generous gift of $500,000 from Holocaust survivor Eva Cooper. The Center for Jewish Studies selected a diverse group of 15 students from all the schools of Hunter College to participate in the pilot program that launched in Spring 2022. The semester long program included a series of educational seminars on the history of antisemitism and methods of combating it. The program culminated with a trip to the US Holocaust Memorial Museum in Washington D.C.
- “No Place for Hate�: On April 24, 2022 at College of Staten Island, the Office of Pluralism and Diversity (Student Life), campus Hillel, and the Library Department offered “No Place for Hate,� where Jewish students, faculty, staff, and the campus community were invited to come together to share and discuss their experiences with Antisemitism in their lives, communities, and on campus. The hope is to create a safe space on campus to discuss this difficult topic.
- “Love Not Hate Summit�: On May 18, 2022, Kingsborough Community College held a Love Not Hate summit that brought together a diverse group of religious leaders, community leaders, elected officials, essential workers, parents, educators, and students (DOE and KCC) who represented the cultural diaspora that is New York City. At the Summit, young people strategized and developed action plans and next steps to mobilize their diverse communities away from hate towards the love that is needed to heal and move communities forward.
- “Americans and the Holocaust�: The New York City College of Technology library secured the exhibition “Americans and the Holocaust� this past academic year. The initiative is sponsored by the American Library Association and United States Holocaust Memorial Museum in Washington, D.C. City Tech is one of only fifty institutions in the United States to host this traveling exhibition.
- Israeli Hope in Academia: On March 14, 2022, representatives of Israeli Hope in Academia — an organization that encourages different parts of Israeli society to work together in academia, education, employment, and sports — visited Queens College. Prominent educators and administrators met with QC leaders to share information and experiences and explore potential collaborations.
- Under Siege Again? Holocaust Distortion and the Rise of Hate Crimes Against Jews: This discussion was sponsored by Queensborough Community College’s Kufperberg Holocaust Center and featured Michael Brovner, Chief of the Queens County District Attorney’s Hate Crimes Bureau as well as Mark Weitzman, Director of Government Affairs at the Simon Wiesenthal Center.
- Potential Partnership with Yad Vashem- The World Holocaust Remembrance Center: QCC’s Kufperberg Holocaust Center is exploring a partnership with Yad Vashem which would include a menu of workshops, trainings and programs on the Holocaust, Holocaust Distortion, and antisemitism.
- A number of schools regularly sponsor programs for International Holocaust Remembrance Day and in commemoration of Kristallnacht.
- A number of schools have held listening sessions with Jewish students about their experiences on campus.
We are living in very challenging times and CUNYis not exempt from experiencing those same challenges. However, CUNYis committed to fostering an environment where all faculty, staff and students can work, teach and learn, thrive and reach their full potential.
Thank you for your attention and I now ask President Garrell to discuss the trip to Israel. And she will be followed by Vice Chancellor Maybank.
###

