February 11, 2025 |

Scholar of Romance Weighs in on Old Love Advice

By Anna Leah泭

Romantic love can feel nebulous. A Queens College professor has created definitive overviews of the peer-reviewed psychological research around why we pair up and with whom.泭

Social personality psychologist ���s recent writings feature wide-spanning literature reviews. They inform her chapter of The Oxford Handbook of Evolution and the Emotions, ������, and Oxford University Press��� Modern Relationship entry, ������泭

When you’re looking for a partner, there is no shortage of advice – magazines, smug married friends, folk wisdom. In honor of Valentine���s Day, we asked Brumbaugh what ���common wisdom��� has scientific credence.泭

���A single man in possession of a good fortune must be in want of a wife.���泭

According to Brumbaugh, research supports this. As much as societal roles have shifted, she says that men still seek out physical attractiveness in their partners while women look for someone who can provide. Studies of same-sex partners found the same patterns, but did not include gender-expansive sources.泭

For Modern Relationship, Brumbaugh and her co-author Jaclyn Doherty looked for shifts in romantic attraction since the year 2000. They found ���There wasn’t much change. It was hard to pinpoint things that maybe used to matter and now don’t in a partner, or vice versa.���泭

Brumbaugh says evolution still drives attraction. When men express ���superficiality��� in mate preference, they might be expressing a preference to a healthy mate who could bear offspring. ���The man is attracted to the prettiness,��� she says. ���But it’s the youth and health that accompanies physical beauty that’s really driving his preferences, unbeknownst to him.���泭

Traditionally, women are attracted to wealth and status to bolster a family unit. As more and more women work outside the home, they can adopt more ���male��� attitudes towards partners. ���Women who are more financially secure also tend to prefer hot, sexy, attractive, men more.��� says Brumbaugh. ���The physical attractiveness of men has been described as a luxury item for women.���泭

Other gender-based norms haven���t changed, with younger women still preferring men who make the first move. And some traits seem universal, ���like someone who’s nice and kind and intelligent. These are things that people like in other people and continue to like and have liked.���泭

“We all want to date our parents.���泭

Brumbaugh���s research refutes this.泭

���That’s sort of a Freudian idea, right?��� Brumbaugh asks rhetorically. She says the bulk of research since the 1970s has disproved the idea. Brumbaugh herself did into these attachment patterns, called ���transference.��� She says, ���I found that people were no more or less attracted to people who resemble their parents than they were to strangers.���泭

Her research showed that people do repeat previous attachments ��� to friends, siblings, even ex-lovers. ���The exception there was parents,��� she explains.泭

���Opposites attract.���泭

Not so, according to Brumbaugh. Research beginning in the 1970s found that people look for familiarity, similarity, and proximity in their partners. ���Similarity is attractive. It was and has been attractive. It signals safety, less threat. Familiarity makes interactions go well.��� says Brumbaugh. ���Opposites attract, no. Birds of a feather flock together.���泭

Common wisdom misleads people in another way. Brumbaugh says that does not suggest that people become crabbier as they age. ���We become nicer as we get older, against the crotchety old geezer stereotype,��� she explains. ���People actually become more agreeable as they age.���泭

As love-seekers move through phases of life, they look for partners who are more kind themselves. ���People did prefer more communal traits as they got older, like more sensitive, more warm, less superficial traits,��� says Brumbaugh. ���Sexiness mattered less, especially for women.���泭

Her research found the same across cultures, suggesting evolutionary reasons for the change. She posits that could be because people have children to take care of, as well as their own aging bodies. ���Having a nice, caring partner to take care of you as you age would also be beneficial.���泭