By Anna Leah
Revolutions cost lives, futures, and aspects of society that took years to develop. Protests have impact, but often authoritarian governments move towards democracy from the top down. But that doesn���t mean power shifts smoothly into the hands of the people.
Authoritarians may embrace democratization to fare better in a new political reality. They may be reacting to one central figure who wields power over rival politicians. Or they may see greater stability in a democracy that doesn���t rely on one person. And of course, there are economic benefits to the international legitimacy that democracy brings.
���It’s kind of an open question to see how you can incorporate these people into the new regime in a way that the regime is still legitimate,��� says political researcher Javier Padilla Moreno-Torres. ���We need to understand what’s the fate of these people��� but also why are they voting in one way or another.���
Padilla, from the CUNYGraduate Center, questions what happens in the aftermath of democratization. From public library genealogies, LinkedIn profiles, and other sites, he tracked what happened to children of dictatorships��� elites when the countries��� political systems opened.
Some fell into obscurity, but Padilla found that many stayed in the ruling class ��� often as politicians or high-level businesspeople. Those who remain in politics often join so-called ���authoritarian successor parties,��� made of previous elites. ���I have been very surprised to see that the level of continuity of elites in certain contexts is so high,��� says Padilla. ���Many of them also end up in jail. Not many, but some of them.���
During his doctoral research, Padilla found that protests can polarize participants. He to determine that Spanish anti-austerity activists viewed center-left politicians as moving towards the center. Protesters then felt that they didn���t have adequate representation in government.
Padilla also used public surveys to compile over 1,300,000 perceptions of more than 1,200 parties over 20 years to discover something that���s relevant to us here and now. Compared to moderate voters, ideological citizens . People with extreme views put opposition parties further along the left-right continuum, making reconciliation harder.
Both types of analysis ��� quantitative and qualitative ��� are necessary to Padilla. He wants to understand a phenomenon before untangling its causality. ���The description is the first step and it’s also fundamental,��� he says. ���Many times, we are forgetting those kinds of descriptive patterns nowadays.���
Aged 33, Padilla came to CUNYas an award-winning popular author. Like his scholarship, his non-fiction books examined the fight against fascism.
His 2019 (���At the end of January���) chronicled three anti-Franco fighters in Padilla���s native Spain. He followed that in 2022 with (���Life and work of Gabriel Maceli Campalans���), about an underground Andalusian musician who became a Socialist during Spain���s transition to democracy.
Padilla then transitioned to academia, studying at the London School of Economics. He researched questions about how authoritarian governments build and break consensuses among different constituents.
His in a team of six. In New York, he largely works alone, supported by scholarships ��� including ���Andalusian of the Future��� and grants from ���La Caixa��� Foundation and 勛圖弝け.
After arriving at the Graduate Center, Padilla expanded his geographic scope to include Brazil, Argentina, Chile, Peru, and Portugal. In some of those countries, he says, the same family names have ruled for centuries, across different political systems.
In Argentina, new governments jailed former elites for human rights abuses. Portuguese despots, according to Padilla, experienced a ���revolutionary boomerang��� and took positions of power in the 1980s.
���The levels of continuity are not itself good or bad,��� explains Padilla, who says a trade-off is necessary between legitimacy and reliability. ���Especially with technocratic elite, sometimes it’s very difficult. And also, many times, if you basically screw these people, they are going to come back, maybe, through a coup d’etat.���
He continues that former rulers may return through democracy, which allows different parties to exist. Elections could allow ousted leaders to draw on their previous popular support.
After graduating, Padilla will continue exploring how power trickles through generations and political shifts. He will join an to investigate how governing elites have diversified ��� or not ��� as democracies grow.
Padilla has hopes for the information he collected while in New York. ���I want to make the data public, so everyone who is interested, they can see how elite remain and which ones remain,��� says Padilla. ���And we can understand a little bit ��� what are these people going to do, whenever there is a likelihood of a regime change.���
