November 11, 2025 |

Restructuring Care

By RIF Staff Writer

According to , war marked 2023. Hostilities between Israel and Palestine unfolded during ongoing conflicts in Sudan and Ukraine as well as countries across Africa, Europe, and Asia. Calls continue to grow for government responses to establish systems of care.

Researchers question if governmental frameworks provide care that betters communities or upholds systematic oppression.

Professor of Anthropology at the CUNYGraduate Center works to understand the human condition, as defined in and through political systems – much of her work has focused on care. Her research has explored how perceptions of the suffering body play a critical role in who qualifies as human.

Ticktin grew up in an immigrant family in the French-majority side of Canada, where universalism was espoused as a political principle, as opposed to the multiculturalism of the rest of Canada. Wanting to understand differences among people, Ticktin started her undergraduate career pursuing neuroscience at Princeton University. She reasoned that those dissimilarities had to originate in the brain. She soon realized, however, these differences were much more complex, influenced by political, economic, social, and cultural factors.

As she learned, we cannot think about differences without also thinking about power. A class in anthropology paved Ticktin’s way for her exploration of differences as manifested through migration.

Her recent piece, “,� is an afterward to a 2024 special issue of Focaal: European Journal of Anthropology, Care Beyond Crisis. The publication focused on vernacular humanitarianisms – a more grassroots, non-institutional approach to helping people.

Ticktin’s article reminds the reader that care is inherently political. Relations of power often control who is deemed the caretaker versus the receiver of care. In an effort to provide access to emergency care for those in need, current humanitarian institutions may do more harm than good without realizing it. Humanitarianism is embedded in our global order, but Ticktin’s goal is to introduce new approaches that have surfaced because of exclusion and domination.

Ticktin conducted her dissertation research in France as the unfolded. Translating to “without papers,� the movement was run by and for undocumented immigrants, to advocate for themselves. Ticktin explains, “I was interested in the newly emerging language of human rights as a universal language, a language of equality, which the sans-papiers used.�

The sans-papiers movement began with a series of occupations, the most important at the Saint Bernard church in 1996. More than 300 African men, women, and children took control of the church to protest increasingly restrictive immigration laws. Undocumented immigrants had been pushed into a state of illegality while policing and exploitation grew.

Ticktin saw that the system made it difficult for undocumented immigrants to obtain basic rights. But what she really discovered was that the government ignored their appeals and shifted its attention to humanitarianism, “a political form of care, even though it is seen as apolitical� as Ticktin describes it. People who wanted papers and rights had to translate their demands into requests for emergency forms of care, based on ideas of what suffering looks like.

“What really changed my idea about this was seeing the ways in which people use their bodies, politically,� shares Ticktin. “The most extreme case that I found were people trying to, or wanting to, infect themselves with HIV in order to get papers because they could qualify for papers if they were at risk of death.�

Ticktin learned that the police broke down the doors of Saint Bernard’s church to arrest those inside. After her exposure to the violent conflict between France’s government and immigrants, Ticktin realized humanitarianism was different in practice than theory. She asked how people could achieve equality in ways that are not structured by racial and economic inequalities.

“Care as Political Revolution?� critiques the most common form of global aid: humanitarianism. At its core, it aims to provide support and protection for those during disasters and conflicts. However beneficial to those in need, that is not without its downsides. Under the section of “Contaminations of Humanitarianism� within Ticktin’s article, she notes the distinction between helper and helped typically find those in the Global North providing aid to those in the Global South.

Ticktin pointed to a paradox: “One needs to fit the image of someone who is suffering to get humanitarian aid, but this same image paints one as pitiful and unable to care for oneself, as unequal.�

Humanitarianism’s racialized colonial roots impact who may provide aid. Solidarity care, while similar to humanitarianism, combines fellowship and help to dispel stereotypes of caretakers as only coming from Western, often white, regions.

During the “Mais Médicos� (More Doctors) movement between 2013 and 2018, the Cuban government partnered with then-Brazilian President Dilma Rousseff, to send Cuban doctors to impoverished regions within Brazil. While solidarity care centers on ideas of anti-colonialism and anti-imperialism, the doctors faced racial discrimination. The people being helped questioned the credibility of the Cuban doctors – often caretakers of color. Familiar with white doctors and other workers, the recipients of care were suspicious of the shift in roles and questioned the Cuban doctors’ abilities to provide proper aid.

Humanitarian care is embedded within systems of “colonialism, capitalism, racism, and hierarchy,� explains Ticktin. She insists that it is not reasonable to ask humanitarians or humanitarian care to solve larger societal conflicts. “Humanitarianism was never intended to solve political problems. It was there as an emergency response. Humanitarians never suggested that they could make structural changes,� says Ticktin.

Providing a bandage to the wounds of crisis can only address individual bodies, not structural change. The most recent incarnation of humanitarianism began with the French doctors in 1968, Médecins Sans Frontières (Doctors Without Borders). They did not purport to solve conflict, but simply provide care during and/or immediately after a crisis.

“In some sense, we’re asking humanitarians to do the work that we are not doing. We’re asking them to do political work because people here are unable or unwilling to deal with these issues,â€� says Ticktin. She explains that to reframe the current practice, people and political institutions must be willing to address the inequalities and exploitation that are part of racial capitalism which cause harm and injury in the first place.

Racial capitalism is the idea that economic systems rooted in capitalism not only produce but also maintain racial exploitation and inequality. The institutionalization of humanitarianism, in turn, perpetuates this ideology through the distinction of “helper versus helped” that Ticktin’s article discusses. To counter such practices, Ticktin highlights organizations such as , which address racial capitalism by implementing anti-racist frameworks.

Referred to as “abolitionist care� in the article, Ticktin argues that this type of care undoes the hierarchical distinctions between the helper and the helped. For example, she refers to and who advocate for their own incarcerated children as well as everyone victim to the prison industrial complex.

In these cases, those affected by systems of oppression are also the ones fighting for socioeconomic and political change. They challenge temporary structures of aid and liberal standards of humanitarian care.

“Abolitionism wants to get rid of carceral institutions such as prisons and detention centers, but in the process it also wants to build up the infrastructures that help people thrive. This includes schools and housing and roads and medical care,â€� explains Ticktin. “Scholars and organizers like Ruth Wilson Gilmore and Mariame Kaba have taught us this. It has to both undo and redo at the same time. These are the ways people are working to dismantle racial capitalism.â€�Â