By Anna Leah
If your subject became one of the most talked-about topics in the country, how would you balance the urge to share information and the push to sensationalize it? One CUNYprofessor believes the crimes of elites deserve scrutiny, as he navigates between stacks of financial documents and others’ lurid curiosity.
³§´Ç³¦¾±´Ç±ô´Ç²µ¾±²õ³ÙÌý, at the College of Staten Island, began tracking the crimes of Jeffrey Epstein before the FBI arrested Epstein in 2019. Years before, Volscho stayed up late with his infant child, rabbit-holing internet news. That kicked off a research fascination. A scholar of money and power, he was surprised to see prosecutors indict someone with both.
With worldwide media attention on the Epstein universe, journalists compete for every story. As an academic, Volscho works on a different timeline. He often uncovers facts, only to see them later in a newspaper. He says, “I’ve been scooped more times than I want to count.�
Recently, Volscho started putting his findings – for free – . His articles dive deeply into Epstein’s finances and white-collar misdeeds. By publishing this way, he writes articles that no editor would approve – detail-heavy and understated. He doesn’t worry about sharing his hard-won information with readers.
“It’s all public record, but it may take a year or more to review everything,â€� he explains. His upcoming book will have different takeaways. He adds, “My originality is in my analysis.â€�
Volscho appears in leading Ìý²¹²Ô»åÌý about Epstein. He says journalists will often ask for the results of his Freedom of Information Act requests. “I’ve been generous at times,â€� he says. “But sometimes I think, ‘I did a lot of work. I’m going to pull back.’â€�
But Volscho swims in tricky waters. He writes about criminals – not just Epstein, but also Peter Nygård and Steven Hoffenberg. He knows some readers lionize the people he studies. Tabloid and clickbait headline writers travel the same waters as Volscho.
“I write in a very clinical way,â€� explains Volscho of his approach. “If you read a police report, they have graphical stuff, and it’s not because the police think it’s fun. It’s forensically important.â€�
Volscho mainly investigates the crimes of elites. In his class about money and power, he first showed Epstein’s picture from the sex offender registry. He urged students to note how rarely someone like Epstein faces consequences.
Even that image displayed an unequal application of justice. Volscho says a filter was applied, making the subject hard to see. He had not seen that in registry photographs of other people.
“We’re all equal under the law, right? But as an elite, you can actually create your own criminal justice system and subvert all the checks and balances and laws… that are there to protect the public from you,â€� says Volscho. “They have this kind of secret justice system, or injustice system, that people should know about.â€�
Volscho lists attorneys, government connections, publicists, and non-disclosure agreements as some tools of elite criminals.
In his research, Volscho found that elite human traffickers operate differently. They use their wealth and status to further their crimes, instead of using their crimes to make money. He also found that the elites use employees to perform various grooming tasks. Among non-elite offenders, a single groomer often performs those steps themselves.
One ethical weight of this work, according to Volscho, is the amount of unredacted private data he sees. From a deposition, he had access to Epstein’s social security number and bank account information while the criminal was still alive. Volscho dialed the bank to confirm the account’s status but hung up before accessing the account.
He has received information about survivors of Epstein. While that doesn’t present an ethical dilemma, it does place him under the moral responsibility to protect their privacy.
The quandary arises when people come forward who claim to be survivors, but one cannot verify their accounts. Volscho often relies on lawyers’ vetting, but he has seen high-profile lawyers fail with accusers in other cases. So, Volscho may set aside a harrowing story unless more information comes out.
But, Volscho doesn’t see an ethical dilemma in spending so much time and column inches on Epstein. He says the case raises awareness of abuse and grooming in society.
“I think if you hold yourself out to be morally upright because of your wealth – the fact that you’re a philanthropist – but that’s being used as a smokescreen to cover up deviant activities,â€� says Volscho. “That’s morally wrong.â€�
