By Anna Leah
Police officers would like to work 12 hours at a time ��� stressing out in blocks of time, then going back to their separate home lives. When the Louisville Police Department began testing eight-hour shifts, 80% of its members didn���t want the change.
A Hunter College economist uses that real-world experiment to explore how longer and more consecutive shifts impact policing. and his California Polytechnic State University collaborator, are halfway through a two-year study. Their early findings show that as work hours run long, police officers become more dangerous, inattentive, and confrontational.
���They really would prefer those 12-hour shifts, but whether police officers like it and what the effect is on civilians is an entirely different question,��� says Ferrazares. ���That second question is��� in many ways, the more important question.���
Since 2020, people have paid more attention to the implications of police training and responsibilities. The research pair examines the role of fatigue in officers��� efficacy and use of force.
���Police officers make some of the highest-stakes decisions of basically anybody at work,��� Ferrazares says. ���When a police officer makes a decision, it goes from choice to decision. What’s the black box in between that?���
The search for an answer began with a massive data undertaking. In part, the availability of data is what drew Ferrazares to ask these questions.
They downloaded records for roughly 1,200 officers, matching names to arrest and use-of-force records from PDFs. That required a lot of manual data maintenance.
So far, the pair found correlations between longer hours and fewer investigatory stops. Those are the police actions that include questioning someone who matches the description of a suspect. There were also increased discretionary arrests ��� like defying an officer.
And police officers used force more often. The team is still in the middle of calculating the meaning behind these findings, but they have benefitted from detailed reports that include X marks where officers used force on civilians��� bodies.
Force could be the result of fatigue ��� these responses are more blunt and require less cognitive effort from the officer.
���Shift structure is not just a human resource question,��� says Ferrazares. ���But can really shape how police interact with the community.���
Ferrazares says the natural next question is whether those officers see less crime during shifts. The reports let him track officers across multiple shifts and times of day, with the largest variable being the length of shifts and consecutive days worked. He can track changes in the same officer under different working conditions.
In his nascent career, Ferrazares estimates he has sent hundreds of public records requests to government agencies. He also estimates that hundreds have been declined. Still, he offers, it never hurts to ask. Some, ���I don’t think I’ll get a response to, and all of a sudden I have a really cool data set,��� he says. ���Start early��� they can drag their feet a lot.���
Ferrazares hit paydirt with his grant from . He won the first grant he ever applied for. From colleagues and conferences, he had heard good things about the initiative. The non-profit funds data-driven, policy-focused studies ��� making Ferrazares��� work a natural fit.
In , Ferrazares suggests alternative time structures. Instead of five days on duty at a time, what if officers worked two days then had a day off? Or three days on, then two days off?
Ferrazares himself tends to work in four-hour spurts, blocking out specific days for research away from the responsibilities of teaching.
