By Laura Tamayo
According , the number of women incarcerated in state facilities for drug-related offenses increased by almost nine times between 1986 and 1999. This phenomenon is intertwined with the war on drugs, beginning in the 70s and continuing through today.
Katarzyna Celinska, at John Jay College of Criminal Justice, began researching crime and prisons at the University of Warsaw. While criminology is typically housed in law departments in Europe, it is considered sociology in the U.S. When Celinska came to the University of Utah as a sociology doctoral student, she began connecting her interests in motherhood, women, and criminal justice.
���Two key factors help explain the rise in women���s incarceration. First was the expansion of punitive policies in the 1980s,��� says Celinska. ���Second was the war on drugs, which had a particularly strong impact on women.���
In a , Celinska and from Rutgers University worked with mothers who were either incarcerated or awaiting trial. In interviews with 74 women, the researchers explored how mothers experienced incarceration and separation from their families.
They identified patterns of coping mechanisms and categorized them as adaptive or maladaptive, emotion-focused or problem-focused. Many interviewees expressed continued dedication to their children and embraced their identities as mothers. This allowed them to actively resist the threats placed on their families, and it gave them defined avenues of purpose. Many planned their lives after prison with the hope of devoting themselves to their familial relationships.
���If it hadn���t been for [my children], I don���t think I would have cared,��� one mother said. ���Honestly, I wouldn���t care.���
Maintaining motherhood healthily in prison goes against the current odds. Building contact with children is a formidable task due to harsh prison visitation policies, difficulties transporting the child, high rates for telephone calls, and more.
In , Celinska���s team found that women visited by their children often engaged in more maladaptive self-criticism and blame. The authors write that was partly because of the poor quality of the visits, between the cumbersome journeys to the prison and the forced quickness of the conversations. On the other hand, regular phone calls with children promoted adaptive coping techniques.
Celinska believes that greater awareness could lead to programs that support positive visitation experiences, but research about and within prisons is not simple. Scholars must navigate bureaucratic obstacles, including long waits for research approvals and limited direct access to incarcerated people.
Celinska says, ���While these processes are essential for ensuring ethical treatment of participants and rigorous research methods, they can also be lengthy and complex.���
Gaining the trust of incarcerated people and prison staff can be difficult. Celinska underlines the critical need to build meaningful relationships grounded in mutual respect.
She explains that while conducting mixed-method studies in prison contexts is very important, qualitative research may be especially valuable. Hearing how women narrate their own stories not only provides important research data but can also empower the women.
Even with its challenges, Celinska insists on the necessity of more research. For decades, the United States has relied on criminal justice policies that prioritize punishment over rehabilitation. As a result, imprisoned mothers and their children frequently experience profound and lasting separations. These limit their opportunities for social mobility and too often overlook their humanity and need for care, connection, and support.
���I hope that academics can collaborate more closely with practitioners, policymakers, and prison administrators,��� says Celinska. ���I also hope that greater public awareness of prison conditions and the lived experiences of incarcerated individuals will contribute to meaningful institutional and policy change.���
