September 9, 2025 |

The Moral Justification of Gentrification

By Leandra Manon

As housing prices have soared in New York City, middle class residents have looked beyond the five boroughs for stability, Newburgh, New York to be exact. Nestled in the Hudson Valley and only 60 miles north from the big apple, Newburgh offered incoming residents home ownership, waterfront access and urban charm. A city away from the city, newcomers settled into Newburgh���s historic downtown area. In their pursuit of housing stability gentrification followed close behind.

In case study, ���, he examines gentrification within the small city of Newburgh and how newcomers, often white and creative professionals, justify their existence in the city���s low-income majority minority neighborhoods, framing themselves as providers of opportunity instead of agents of displacement. As a professor of sociology at John Jay College and the CUNYGraduate Center, Ocejo has devoted his career to urban and cultural sociology, the outcome of his case study leading to the publishing of his book, , which takes his findings from The Virtue of Opportunity and expands on Newburgh���s history and the effects of small city gentrification.

Ocejo, who moved to a municipality close to Newburgh in 2016, reflects on his own move out of New York City which prompted his work. Like those in his study, he was priced out of the city but chose to move into a neighborhood closely aligned with his background instead.

���I moved to a municipality that very much matched my own social class background, whereas the folks who I studied, they chose to move to this majority minority disinvested city with the high poverty rate in which they would become part of a revitalization process or a gentrification process.���

Newburgh, located along the Hudson River, houses approximately 28,600 residents – 50.9% of those residents being Hispanic. With a booming industrial economy in the 19th and 20th century declining after the second World War and the construction of the Newburgh-Beacon Bridge replacing shipping business in the small city, Newburgh���s economic downturn led to disinvestment and unemployment in the area. Facing high poverty rates, vacant housing and low property values – this would later open a pathway for incoming middle-class residents to purchase homes and start businesses.

With Newburgh���s median property value resting at in 2023, it���s a stark contrast to New York City, where Manhattan���s reached a high of while Brooklyn���s soared to , according to . As middle class residents poured into Newburgh���s majority low-income neighborhoods, talks of revitalization and potential displacement were at the forefront of Newburgh’s incoming population���s conversations.

���A lot of the folks who I studied were coming from New York City where they lived in gentrifying neighborhoods,��� said Ocejo. ���They were aware of it and they had direct experience with it and so now when they move to this new place, they’re suddenly homeowners. Suddenly they’re property owners, they’re business owners. They have, you know, a little bit more influence or power.���

Interviewing 143 residents, he centered the study on the 46 newcomers, or gentrifiers as the study acknowledges them. Aside from six minorities, the majority of gentrifiers were white, with 39 of them being homeowners and others owning various buildings and businesses in Newburgh.

They justified their presence within Newburgh by framing themselves as providers of opportunity, enhancing the city���s economy through new employment and training opportunities and aiding in revitalizing the neighborhoods. Ocejo coins this mindset as ���conditional gentrification���, a term used to describe a type of positive gentrification that gentrifies “can control���, showing concern for their impact on existing groups while actively seeking to prevent harm.

They made it a point to position themselves as supporters of the community by aligning themselves with housing nonprofits and which help low-income residents achieve home ownership while simultaneously revitalizing abandoned buildings in Newburgh for housing. The combined efforts peaked gentrifiers’ interest as this would aid in preserving historic buildings, contribute to the city���s tax rolls and provide housing for those in need.

Aware of their position in the town, gentrifiers would talk about basing their decisions on the town’s structure. Liam, a furniture maker who moved to Newburgh, expressed wanting to open up a storefront or gallery in the neighborhood, but acknowledged selling a $12,000 credenza would be ���a slap in the face��� to low-income residents. While gentrifiers aligned themselves with initiatives they felt could help boost Newburgh’s economy and overall outlook, they were not immune to blind spots.

���The puzzle became why do people talk about what they’re doing in a way that makes it sound different from how it’s happened before when they’re only acting in ways that are pretty similar to how it’s happened before,��� Ocejo reflected.

Often placing blame on local city officials, five of their six elected officials being minorities, as impediments standing in the way of their ���conditional gentrification��� plans, Newburgh���s gentrifiers would cast them as the bad guys while portraying their own role as constructive and beneficial.

������It���s a common pattern that we’ve seen in other places. When you get non-white leadership in a municipality, like elected officials, then they’ll often get a disproportionate amount of blame or epithets leveled at them for being incompetent or being corrupt,��� states Ocejo.

Identifying as urbanites drawn to Newburgh���s diversity and resemblance to NYC���s urban aesthetic, gentrifiers would highlight their inclusivity. However, conversations around gentrification’s impact on different racial and social classes would be reframed into conversations around ���universality���, opting to acknowledge how ���gentrification is something that’s going to be positive and beneficial for everybody,��� explains Ocejo.

Tyler, a playwright, downplayed the severity of displacement based on the distance in which longtime residents had to move. ���[If] somebody���s got to move a block away, that doesn���t make me feel guilty.��� The guilt would arise for gentrifiers like Tyler if families had to uproot into a different town altogether.

Ocejo hopes his case study will empower local leaders and politicians to create policies based on their understanding of how gentrifiers’ use of moral framing can dictate their actions and perceptions of gentrification in a small city. ���Figuring out how to take those into account when coming up with policy ideas, I think could help us to rethink what it means to have an improving or a successful neighborhood,��� he said.