By Anna Leah
The two professors wore full lab gear ��� coats, face shields, masks, and gloves. But they stood outside. It was the height of the COVID pandemic. They passed a cooler full of long-sought wastewater samples through the Queens College gates.
For weeks, Monica Trujillo had sent emails to local agencies and wastewater groups, inspired by Dutch researchers. Across the Atlantic, they between the virus��� appearance in wastewater and in people.
In New York City, Trujillo wanted to see if the same could be found. But she received no responses until she connected with the Newtown Creek Alliance. Their help led the researchers to a city initiative already underway to test materials from New York���s 14 wastewater treatment plants.
Other universities ��� Stanford, Michigan University, and NYU ��� had already been recruited for the project. Trujillo, from Queensborough Community College, and , a virologist from Queens College, made sure that CUNYwas included.
Their small team tested the samples on the empty Queens College campus. The ��discovered something the others couldn���t: evidence of SARS-CoV-2.
Dennehy remembers they told the Department of Environmental Protection that every sample tested positive. The other universities��� teams hadn���t found that.
As they shared information, the CUNYprofessors saw the difference in the teams��� approaches. The others focused on a control protocol and looked for analogous viruses that proved difficult to detect.
���We didn’t worry about any of that. We just wanted to detect SARS coronavirus. We went right at the target,��� explains Dennehy. ���We figured out how to detect it, and then we started optimizing our protocol. They optimized first and then tried to detect it, and it didn’t work.���
The department awarded the CUNYteam a contract to develop a COVID monitoring protocol and train employees in their microbiology lab. During the pandemic, they tested wastewater samples every week for two years.
The capability to could unlock an entirely new method for ��and shifts of disease, as well as antibiotic-resistant bacterial strains. This could allow public health officials to focus their testing strategies or hospitals to react to specific outbreaks with ward-by-ward specificity.
���We see everybody, because everybody who uses a toilet contributes to the wastewater,��� says Trujillo, who spends up to four days a week at Dennehy���s Queens College lab.
���I love working in the Dennehy lab because these are the kinds of things that nobody has done before exactly the way I am doing them,��� she continues. ���It took 60 years of my life to think that I was doing something that was going to be perceived as useful.���
Dennehy adds that he was shocked by the number of diseases that could be detected this way ��� from COVID to monkeypox. Researchers could potentially follow samples back to a manhole source, which serves roughly 100,000 people. A team in Wisconsin traced an outbreak .
Both Dennehy and Trujillo recognize that detection could become very narrow, thus expanding the potential ethical considerations.
The Queensborough-Queens pair now helps organize bio-surveillance research in the city. With a team from the School of Public Health and NYC Health + Hospitals, they co-host a summit of state-wide stakeholders and researchers every semester. The Department of Health and Mental Hygiene has supported these efforts.
Public hospitals give the team a promising sample population of vulnerable communities, people with undetected health conditions, and a concentration of overlapping diseases. By , they can pinpoint a new potential pandemic or floor of patients who need extra testing.
But New Yorkers have sometimes misunderstood the group���s findings.
Because the city���s wastewaters combine as they enter drainpipes, it can be impossible to tell if specific waste comes from toilets or streets. The a COVID variant that showed mysterious mutations associated with rodents ��� unlike the original Wuhan strain. One publication claiming that rats drove the change. Through the Freedom of Information Act, the reporters accessed an email thread with the researchers��� Missouri collaborator in which they speculated about possible causes.
Dennehy says that led to city workers gathering rats from Prospect Park under the cover of night. But the team���s findings a more plausible source: immune-compromised people.
Major arose from our immunocompromised population, says Dennehy. Viruses will constantly adapt to aid their survival. A patient taking immunosuppressants, for example, might be able to fight the virus but give the virus an environment in which it can mutate. Then, the virus strain can be transmitted to other groups.
���We���re in an evolutionary arms race that has persisted for billions of years, literally from the earliest cells that appeared that were probably parasitized by viruses. It���s been part and parcel of life from the very, very beginning,��� says Dennehy. ���As life diversified, our viruses diversified along with us.���
Genome-attaching viruses caused some mammals to be able to develop placenta, moving them away from marsupials, cites Dennehy.
New Yorkers face another fundamental transition: climate change. The aging sewer system also collects street stormwater and becomes overwhelmed with sudden, high-volume downpours. The mixed, contaminated water bypasses treatment plants and floods subways, streets, and even basement apartments.
Dennehy mentions social media videos of people walking through that water. He says our flooding issues need urgent attention, especially with the number of infectious diseases in wastewater.
���Don’t worry, we’ll have another pandemic soon. It���s inevitable,��� he reassures. ���It’s not going to stop, and we just need to better prepare for them.���
