March 11, 2026 |

Many Histories Under One Island’s Surface

By Laura Tamayo

When the average American hears “Iceland,� they may think of hot springs, volcanoes, and turf houses in a rugged landscape. The tourism industry popularized these images, contributing to an idea of Iceland as an untamed land. But the trope of an empty wilderness has invited intervention by outsiders and, according to Megan Hicks, colonization.

The at Hunter College specializes in the North Atlantic region and the Northeastern United States. She has conducted archaeological research in both places, primarily interested in community ecologies before and after industrialization.

Hicks practices collaborative archaeology, involving local communities throughout the decision-making process. This ranges from involvement in research permitting to excavation planning. She also works with educators to transform the work into teaching tools. Together, these steps ensure that many voices contribute to the research.

For years, Hicks has worked in Mývatnssveit, Iceland. Its agricultural community taught her about their historic farming and harvesting practices. In she and co-author �gústa Edwald Maxwell analyze the dawn of North Atlantic trade in Iceland. They discuss shifting cultural customs through archaeological and archival analyses.

Rural Icelanders saw changes in the materiality of their lives – new fabrics, building materials, and tableware. They built their own modes of production to retain local control. In Mývatnssveit, throughout the nineteenth century, they developed sheep ranching to enter international markets outside of the Danish colonial system.

Denmark wielded power over Iceland for hundreds of years. Denmark prioritized command over colonies’ economy and the exploitation of labor under stratified class relations. Until the late 1700s, Iceland exclusively exported its main commodities – wool and fish – to Denmark. Mývatnssveit farmers cultivated a cooperative trading movement to sell their live sheep, resisting colonial control.

However, “there is much more to the issue than this polarized struggle between Denmark and Iceland,� recounts Hicks.

She points to the differing community responses to both market pressures and the Danes. Icelandic elites benefitted from Danish rule while a growing middle class maneuvered away from it. European Enlightenment-born ideals of modernity, including free markets, began to crystallize in Icelandic society. Economic sovereignty meant engaging with international markets on their own terms. In 1944, Iceland formally gained independence.

To properly understand the community in Mývatnssveit, Hicks advocates for a multi-archival, multivocal methodology. This includes the thoughts, voices, and records of different people of the period, from farmers to scholars. She uses archaeological materials, primary documents from local archives, and academic literature.

“Different sources of information, whether they’re in writing or material, are complementary – they often fill in the silences left by the other,� says Hicks.

These methods converse with one another, complicating ideas of everyday life in history. Daily decisions do not get dismissed by general trends. We witness the attitudes, behaviors, and pressures that built modernity. Rather than take our contemporary conditions for granted, we see how they were socially produced. Furthermore, we can begin to imagine other possibilities.

By researching both elusive patterns of power and communities’ responses, Hicks hopes to challenge the idea of modernity as a universal, inescapable standard. Today, Iceland has integrated into the global economy, but outside observers often forget the island’s complex histories. Hicks advocates for greater nuance.

“Iceland is now embedded in the Global North. It identifies with Europe, with Scandinavia, but for a long time it was a colonial hinterland of these places,� says Hicks. “National identity isn’t natural or simply geographic. It was culturally produced in material tension with a broader colonial world.�