October 16, 2026 |

Learning to Ignore a Nation

By Anna Leah

Victors write the history books, or so they say. In most of the world ��� including the U.S. ��� Russian history is written by both the winners and losers. As long as they���re Russian.

That can center Russians at the expense of other people. The College of Staten Island���s says, ���If you���re used to seeing everything through the lens of Russia, you don���t take Ukraine seriously.���

Unlike other fields of study, Russian history in the U.S. by a dominant group of immigrants from the former Russian Empire. American scholars learned their point of view. Smith-Peter now helps lead the way for that to be challenged, contextualized, and possibly put to pasture.

Smith-Peter says that when one side lost the Russian Revolution ��� or any number of conflicts or cultural repressions since ��� they fled the country, and papers with them. Many came to America. Some spoke better English than emigres from other countries, giving them a massive leg-up in conversations with government decision makers. That gave the Soviet Union a better chance of being recognized as the owner of territories occupied by people without effective advocates in the U.S.

More than that, Smith-Peter says, they brought a story in which Russians play the part of the main actors. The other nations are acted upon.

Recently, Smith-Peter received a PSC-CUNYresearch award to continue her explorations of the surprisingly diverse world of Siberia. Unlike the stereotype of a frozen wasteland full of gulags, Smith-Peter compares Siberia to Canada. She describes a region full of Jews and Muslims, Ukrainians and Indigenous tribes and Koreans.

Those groups borrowed ideas of federalism that percolated from America through Ukraine, and then farther East. Smith-Peter calls the Russian Civil War a moment of multiple George Washingtons. Many groups, including Indigenous people in Siberia, asserted themselves as nations.

Around the time of our Civil War, the Siberian regionalists even declared a United States of Siberia ��� possibly to federate with the United States of America. Russian authorities banished the ringleaders from the region, but they returned and advocated for a university.

Many Siberian regionalists were ethnically Russian, but Smith-Peter points out, ���It���s a very different way of Russians interacting with Ukrainians ��� more as partners.���

As the Russian Civil War raged from 1918 to 1922, the different groups set up their own parliaments and school systems. After the Soviet Union solidified its power, those groups lost control to Moscow.

History often omits the Ukrainians in Siberia, ignoring hundreds of thousands who lived there. ���Ukrainians are physically present through many places on the territory of the Russian Federation,��� says Smith-Peter. ���But they���re often just erased from the narrative.���

Throughout its history of empire, Russia conquered dozens of nations from the Asian steppe to the Baltic Sea. They imported this ideological subordination of multiple peoples as well.

Major universities established Russian studies departments, based on the intellectual contributions of Russian immigrants. In contrast, Ukrainians brought over archives but had to set up their own institutes for research and preservation.

Since Russia���s full-scale invasion of Ukraine in 2022, Susan-Peter sees some changes. Academics have started questioning foundational myths. More jobs in Russian centers have opened to Ukrainian scholars, as well as countries from the former Soviet bloc.

Federal funders have slashed support for some schools that teach Caucasian, Central Asian, and other languages. At Indiana University, scholarships have been cut, making the field less accessible to students.

In , Smith-Peter challenges the need ��� or appropriateness ��� of relying solely on archives within Russia itself. Historically and today, Russian authorities don���t allow scholars to use their archives if it might make the government look bad. Since the invasion of Ukraine, access has become even more limited ��� something Smith-Peter compares to Iranian archives after the revolution of 1979.

Traditionally, Russian studies scholars think that all the important documents are in the country. Smith-Peter pushes back, ���The amount of material that I can get to by subway is mind-boggling.���

A lot of Smith-Peter���s sources sit in the New York Public Library.

While the government censors archives, Russian scholars have their own omissions. Their ideas tend to ignore Ukraine and former client states. This causes more than a blind spot in academia.

This could stop advisers from advocating for arming Ukrainians, because they consider Russia���s reaction instead of Ukraine���s safety. Smith-Peter says, ���Many of the people who have been qualified for jobs in the U.S. government have been trained in ways that downplay Ukraine and Georgia and the Baltic states.���