By Emily Blackburne泭
In ever-progressive cities like New York, glittering new infrastructure, comes with forward thinking environmental developments���such as bike lanes, green parks, rooftop gardens, and urban farms. But beneath this more ecologically sustainable surface, a sociologically unsustainable trend���coined green gentrification���takes root. CUNYSociologist professors and have spent years researching it together, culminating in a often used as a reference by city planning officials.泭
Green gentrification centers on the phenomenon where investment in the environmental conditions of an area increases the property value and causes the area to become less affordable for its original, often lower-income residents���displacing them out of their original neighborhood and replacing them with wealthier individuals who can afford the increased property value.泭泭
���I did not set out to be a climate change researcher. I did not set out to be a gentrification researcher,��� Lewis admits.泭泭
Looking around the city and noticing the addition of bike lanes and waterfronts being redeveloped���not just in her Brooklyn neighborhood, but across urban spaces where green investments were flourishing, she was initially impressed with the investment in environmentally healthy infrastructure. But as a Sociologist, she also saw these changes through a sociological lens, and with these changes, noticed a pattern for the residents of a neighborhood.泭
���Invariably, these changes were bringing in more middle-class, wealthier, whiter people and displacing low-income people and people of color,��� Lewis says. ���And I thought, wow, there���s this irony going on here where we���re trying to make places better, but we���re also displacing people and not including them in the benefits.���泭泭
���Urban greening is not inherently bad,��� Lewis urges. ���But the way that we do it���when we don���t pay attention to issues of justice and equity���it can displace the very communities that environmentalism is supposed to help.���泭
Lewis and Gould���s research focuses mostly on , where huge federal and private investments in green infrastructure projects, such as the restoration of the and the improvements and additions to , led to rising rents and shifting demographics. These projects are often celebrated as progress without also recognizing who they���re excluding from it.泭
���When a bike lane goes in, or when a park is improved, it increases property values,��� Lewis explains. ���But if there aren���t policy protections in place, that increase displaces people.���泭
With this displacement, comes the emergence of what Lewis and Gould call the ���sustainability class������a mostly white, educated, and economically-mobile population that embraces ecologically sustainable living, often at the expense of long-established, working-class and lower-wage communities.泭
���There’s this whole set of values around environmentalism and sustainability,��� Lewis says. ���That���s a good thing. But the way it���s enacted���if we���re not paying attention to historical inequality���it can become a bad thing.���泭
Lewis asserts that the goal of their research is not to halt environmental improvements. Even urban processes like structural mitigation, or making existing infrastructure more resilient to environmental catastrophes���such as building coastal housing on stilts to avoid hurricane damage���can be potentially lifesaving for residents of an area.泭 For example, investments in sea walls after Superstorm Sandy could protect real estate along waterways. However, changes like this are often expensive and result in higher living costs.泭
泭Lewis and Gould advocate that along with these environmental improvements, urban planners and policymakers should have legislative protections in place for native residents of a neighborhood. These protective measures can include rent control, community land trusts, and mandatory inclusionary housing, to ensure that sustainability benefits are shared more equitably. For example, in Gowanus, city policy requires 30% of housing to be affordable rather than market rate, and other projects like , serve exclusively as affordable green housing complexes.泭泭
It���s not only ethical considering the well-studied of living in greener areas, but also societally practical to have individuals of varying socio-economic strata living in an area. For instance, San Francisco���s historically high cost of living has led to the displacement of local, lower-income residents for wealthier ones. Because of this, the city saw a and subsequent district enrollment decline due to the city���s high cost of living and disproportionately low wage for teachers.泭泭
In applying this to other jobs that allow society to function effectively���grocery and retail workers, restaurant wait staff, cleaning crews, to name a few���it becomes a disadvantage for the whole neighborhood to lose lower-income employees who keep neighborhood services running, due to unaffordable living costs.泭泭
���If you want to have a society that works, you need to have all different classes of people in all different categories of work,��� Lewis asserts.泭泭
Lewis���s recent work has broadened from New York to international settings, including post-disaster redevelopment projects in , noticing the trend that ���after a disaster, outside wealthy interests come in, using sustainability language to push out local communities,��� Lewis explains. Whether in Barbuda or Brooklyn, it���s the same phenomenon���environmental development packaged as progress but without policies that address social inequities.泭
Along with research, efforts at educating and collaborating across communities are also a means for raise awareness to the issue and implementing new policies. Problems like climate change are multidisciplinary, Lewis asserts, and integrating research from a scope of different research areas is imperative. Brooklyn College���s program is one way community and scholarship are brought together, as undergraduate students in the Urban Sustainability major specialize in diverse concentrations including Economics, Environmental Science, and Sociology���working together to apply their studies to sustainability matters.泭泭
Lewis also works with an interdisciplinary team of CUNYprofessors, including , Director of the Science and Resilience Institute at . Lewis and the team received a planning grant to work with the Futures Hub at Floyd Bennett Field, where they will bring communities together to talk and plan for climate change and solutions around it.
���If we really care about climate change and resilience,��� Lewis says, ���then we have to care about social justice. Otherwise, we���re just rebranding gentrification.���泭
For Lewis and Gould, the conversation must move beyond surface-level greening. ���We need to ask not just what we���re building, but who we���re building it for,��� she asserts. ���Are we creating a city that works for everyone, or just for the people who can afford it?���泭
The solution, she believes, is in environmental progress that also embodies equity into every policy and plan along the way.泭
