THE UNIVERSITY’S second biennial Faculty Diversity & Inclusion conference was a candid daylong discussion of its ongoing efforts to ensure that equity and inclusion are key components of CUNYlife and recognized as crucial to the public good.
Diversity conference keynote speaker Kenji Yoshino with Jennifer Rubain, university dean of recruitment and diversity.
The conference, held in March at the Graduate Center and attended by 270 faculty and 50 administrators, featured panels, presentations, talks and interactive demonstrations on virtually every aspect of diversity–from race and ethnicity, sexuality and gender, age, disability, language and religion to topics such as cultural competency, pedagogy for ESL students, and economic status and unconscious bias.
Although successes in eradicating biases, at CUNYand elsewhere, were appropriately applauded, challenges were also openly discussed, both formally and informally. “Yes, we’re very proud of our diversity at ³Ô¹ÏÊÓÆµ. But if we’re really serious about inclusion, we need a healthy dose of self-reflection in order to challenge our own assumptions,” said Jennifer Rubain, university dean of recruitment and diversity and the conference’s organizer. “That means listening carefully to those we work with and discovering their strengths, talents, and aspirations.”
Looking back at reactions to the conference several weeks later, Rubain emphasized that she was “so pleased” by its “ever-growing impact,” and said its “overall success was due to the dedication and hard work of the planning committee. They made sure the event addressed topics that most energize and engage the faculty.”
Chancellor James B. Milliken, enthusiastically attending the first universitywide diversity conference since his appointment in June 2014, observed: “Three out of four university students belong to underrepresented groups and 57 per cent today are women. We are clearly outpacing national statistics on diversity and inclusion but that is the way it should be. . . . We have come a long way. We lead the nation. But we still have much to do.”
Race relations–so much in the news both locally and nationally–were a focal point of the conference. Faculty members related the distressed reactions of students following the death of Eric Garner on Staten Island after he was put in a chokehold by police last July. Willie Tolliver, an associate professor in Hunter College’s Silberman School of Social Work who participated in a panel about classroom conversations about race, recalled students walking out of classes in protest after a grand jury decided not to indict the police officer in Garner’s death. “What the students said over and over was that we need you to help us understand race and racism in the United States,” Tolliver said.
In addition to faculty and administrators, the conference drew on the experiences and perspectives of students, including three from John Jay College of Criminal Justice who were part of a panel discussion of Muslim awareness initiatives at CUNYcolleges. The students–Nafij Ahmed, Yellda Balouch and Sana Nawaz– have compiled an anthology called “Finding Islam in Tomorrow.” Their presentation described efforts on several campuses “aimed at chipping away at the widespread negative stereotypes and images of Muslims as a monolithic group of extremists outside of mainstream American society.”
Four Graduate Center doctoral candidates also presented posters of their research on themes related to the conference. One, by Michael Dorsch, was an analysis of the racial and ethnic sociodemographics of the communities closest to CUNYcampuses.
The conference’s keynote speech was delivered by Kenji Yoshino, Chief Justice Earl Warren Professor of Constitutional Law at NYU School of Law. He addressed inclusion and equity through the perspective of “covering”– a term that describes pressure that racial and sexual minorities feel to continue to mute or downplay their “outsider” identities long after they have been accepted by the mainstream of society. Yoshino, author of Covering: The Hidden Assault on Our Civil Rights, gave a range of examples: Margaret Thatcher, who was instructed to go to a voice coach to lower her voice so she would be perceived as having more gravitas; President Obama, who was told that he could not win national office with two ethnic names; and Julie Chen, who was pressured to have eyelid surgery to become a CBS news anchor.
Drawing on data from a study he did with the Deloitte management consulting firm, Yoshino demonstrated that covering has a significant negative impact both on individuals and the organizations for which they work. Advocating a culture of greater authenticity, he recalled that as a gay man early in his career he was told to avoid writing about gay themes. He said he tried to take the advice for a while but realized he had cut himself off from his passion. He ultimately rejected the demand to cover, he said, and received tenure unanimously. He shared this story, he said, to underscore that while the melting pot ideal suggests that advancement is related to assimilation, it may be just as true that advancement is related to authenticity.
The nuances involved in the faculty hiring process were reviewed in an interactive presentation called It Depends On the Lens: Unconscious Bias in the Faculty Search Process by Cornell University’s Interactive Theater Ensemble. The group uses video, live actors and audience participation to address unconscious gender, age bias and other biases in faculty hiring.
A midday panel on “Women and Leadership: Empowering the Next Generation in Higher Education,” moderated by Vice Chancellor for Human Resources Management Gloriana B. Waters, offered strategies for advancement. Framed by the fact that only one in four college presidents in the United States are women, the panel featured nationally recognized thought leaders such as Joyce Brown, president of the Fashion Institute of Technology; Chancellor Nancy Cantor of Rutgers- Newark; Abigail Stewart of the University of Michigan; and the Graduate Center’s president, Chase F. Robinson. The panelists highlighted aspects of their own careers and offered practical advice for the next generation, not the least of which was: Love what you do.
Ann Kirschner, dean of Macaulay Honors College, delivered the closing remarks of the conference by sharing her personal experiences as someone who has felt like an outsider–“the other,” as she put it–at various times in her life.
Kirschner grew up in Jackson Heights, Queens, the daughter of a woman who survived a Nazi concentration camp and “learned English when I did.” After attending SUNY Buffalo, she went to graduate school at Princeton, earning her Ph.D. in English and teaching Victorian literature as a lecturer. Later, she shifted gears to become an entrepreneur in media and technology, launching satellite and internet businesses for the National Football League. She said she certainly felt like an outsider during that part of her career.
“The flip side of this is that being ‘the other’ and having a different point of view gives you certain advantages,” Kirschner said. “I see difference as an asset.” At the NFL, she said, “I think I saw new opportunities faster because I didn’t have the reverence not to start something new.”
She added, “You can make the moral and philosophical case for diversity. But you can also make the economic case. It’s the practical thing to do.”

