By Anna Leah
Just because the camera flies doesn���t mean the rules of photography have changed completely.
���It���s the Wild West. It’s new enough where those kinds of boundaries aren’t as easily defined yet,��� says Travis Fox. ���We’re not there yet, like we are on the ground.
Fox, who at Craig Newmark School of Journalism, teaches his drone students (like this writer) about the laws and ethics of aerial photography.
In his 2020 book, , Fox explored the aftermath of racist housing practices, Catskill summer resorts, and human movements from a bird���s eye view. ���I started to see some distinction between man-made shapes and natural shapes,��� says Fox. ���I was looking for straight lines and lines that are not straight. And I was thinking ��� what are these? Who is making these lines?���
From above, the world looks different. And that was Fox���s goal. His project began by experimenting with newly available drones. Over a decade, he compiled enough images for the publication.
Largely, Fox uses the same ethical rules of thumb as he does on the ground. In most places in the United States, a person does not have a ���reasonable expectation of privacy��� in public. Fox points to the difference between someone sitting on their front porch and their back porch. On their front porch, anyone can see them and the expectation of privacy doesn���t exist.
Fox thinks people in their backyard should be able to expect privacy. Someone bathing on a beach might be fair game to be photographed by a drone (although that might present a safety concern). But, if they sunbathe behind a fence that would block someone on the ground, they should expect the same privacy from cameras in the air.
���Delta Airlines flies over your backyard… Drone rules are a subset of those basic aviation rules,��� says Fox. ���We can see Google Earth images of your backyard. Those are legal for sure. No one would think that’s an invasion. So where does it become OK and where not?���
Legally, the Federal Aviation Administration controls the air that begins immediately above the ground. Different localities pass their own restrictions. Fox cites ��when planes scared chickens to death. Aircraft flew as low as 83 feet, interfering with the farmer���s use of his property. The suit created one legal precedent for height of planes and drones, but the system remains patchwork.
Fox has worked at the edge of technological change before. His video journalism career began with the advent of online video ��� in 2006, he won the first Emmy for a web-first documentary short. It featured rescue efforts after Hurricane Katrina.
On sabbatical, Fox explores the potential impact of artificial intelligence on visual journalism. He uses machine learning to make large-scale prints at a higher quality than his camera can capture. He estimates that AI generates two-thirds of the information in these blow-ups, which can be 10 feet wide.
���But it’s based on a real picture,��� Fox says. ���I would argue that it’s fine, because it’s just an enlargement, right? It���s almost a workflow. But, it does make you question.���
Fox sees a horizon where automation and drones meet. Here, he predicts some potential red flags. He says, ���The drone that I flew for the book is like a flying lawnmower. It’s loud. It’s big. It’s dangerous when it’s close to you, and so no one wants that over their head.���
Flying as high as permissible, Fox stepped over several ethical landmines. He didn���t focus on specific private homes or gather identifiable information. That height also reduced the noise nuisance that people on the ground would experience.
While the ethical implications of the images might not change in the air, the dangers of making those photographs can be very different. When Fox flies, a human watches the drone from the ground. For Remains to Be Seen, his partner often served as the spotter. AI might not weigh the safety concerns that humans look out for.
���You’re allowing the AI to make decisions,��� says Fox. ���Maybe that’s better than humans in terms of safety, but in terms of these nuisance and privacy concerns, is it better? Maybe not. I don’t know.���
