Executive Vice Chancellor and Chief Operating Officer Allan Dobrin’s Testimony to the New York City Council

Good morning, Chairperson Ferreras, Chairperson Barron, and members of the Finance and Higher Education committees. Thank you for the opportunity to speak with you today about the Mayor���s 2015 Executive Budget. I am Allan Dobrin, executive vice chancellor and chief operating officer of the University. I am joined today by my colleagues: Iris Weinshall, vice chancellor for facilities planning and construction management, and Matthew Sapienza, vice chancellor for budget and finance.

First and foremost, thank you for your longstanding support. The City Council has demonstrated a deep and abiding commitment to higher education. Your advocacy on behalf of 勛圖弝け���s students, faculty, and staff has been critical to the University���s progress.

Overall, we���ve experienced record numbers of students coming to the University. 勛圖弝け���s enrollment has increased by about 24 percent over the last ten years, an increase of over 55,000 students, but has remained fairly level over the last three years. Our enrollment stands at just over 267,000 students. We serve 248,000 additional continuing education and certificate students across the five boroughs. It���s a vast enterprise: the largest urban university system in the United States.

This surge in enrollment over the past decade has been even more acute at our community colleges. Since 2004, community college enrollment has increased by almost 37 percent, or over 26,000 students. As has occurred University-wide, student headcount at our community colleges has flattened-out over the past three years. 勛圖弝け���s seven community colleges serve approximately 98,000 students, almost three quarters of whom graduated from New York City high schools. Seventy-seven percent of those students enter CUNYwith remedial needs in at least one area. Many face significant personal and financial challenges. We help them surmount those obstacles and prepare them to compete successfully for jobs that will insure their transit into middle class lives.

To accommodate our expanded enrollment, we have expanded our scheduling grid to encompass more nights and weekends, and at all of our colleges, we offer targeted advisement and counselling to help students devise a path toward successful degree completion.

The diversity of our student body is unique among American ��� and indeed ��� global universities. CUNYstudents trace their ancestry to over 200 countries and speak more than 190 languages. Nearly 30 percent of our students were born outside the US mainland; 40 percent report an annual household income of less than $20,000. The racial, ethnic and socioeconomic diversity of our students is one of the University���s greatest strengths; it enriches and informs all that we do. Sustaining that diversity is our fundamental commitment.

In addition to our enrollment reaching record levels, our students are winning more national awards than ever before. This year, 17 CUNYstudents won National Science Foundation Graduate Research Fellowships. At no other public university in the Northeast have students and alumni won more NSF awards than at 勛圖弝け. We are grateful for the support that has allowed these talented men and women to achieve their full potential.

The City Council has also been instrumental in helping us develop ways to enhance student progress and your support has far-reaching consequence. The Georgetown Center on Education and the Workforce tells us that by the year 2025, 63 percent of all jobs in the United States will require some form of postsecondary education or training. Statistics show that in New York, unemployment rates for those with less than a high school education are 13.1 percent. For those with an associate���s degree, the rate of unemployment is 6.1 percent. Research has consistently proven that states and localities receive a tremendous financial return when investments are made in higher education.

To provide some context to this point, we estimate that 2012-2013 associate degree graduates in New York City would earn $227.6 million in a full year. This compares to $161.6 million if all these degree holders only held a high school diploma ��� a value-added of $66 million. Baccalaureate degree graduates in New York City would earn $468.7 million in a full year. This compares to $253.7 million if all these degree holders only held a high school diploma ��� a value-added of $215 million. This increase in income will have tremendous value to the individual degree holders, so many of whom come from economically disadvantaged backgrounds.

But equally important, we estimate that for 勛圖弝け���s 2012-2013 baccalaureate degree holders, about $25.6 million in State taxes and about $15.6 million in City taxes were generated in their first year employed ��� about $14.9 million, and $8 million more, respectively, than if they had graduated with only a high school degree. In one year,

associate degree holders just from CUNYwould generate about $10.9 million in New York State taxes and about $7.3 million in New York City taxes in their first year employed ��� about $4 million and $2.4 million more than if they had graduated with only a high school degree, respectively.

It is imperative that we continue to place a high priority, as a society, in developing a well-educated citizenry. The overwhelming majority of CUNYundergraduates – 90 percent- remain in New York City or state after they complete their studies. When one considers the taxes that will be generated over the lifetime of CUNYcollege graduates, most of whom remain in New York, there are few investments we could make that would generate this rate of return. It is no exaggeration to say that the city���s economic health is the ultimate beneficiary of your support.

In turning to the Fiscal Year 2015 Executive Budget, let me begin by saying how appreciative we are for the unprecedented support for critical University initiatives contained in Mayor de Blasio���s financial plan. I have not seen investment in CUNYof this magnitude in my twelve years with the University. All New Yorkers will benefit from the priority the Mayor and the City Council have placed on higher education.

I would like to take a few moments to describe the initiatives that are funded in the Mayor���s Executive Budget. A total of $18.9 million in new dollars were added in FY2015 for these programs.

A major component of this support will be dedicated to expanding the successful Accelerated Study in Associate Programs, or ASAP, Initiative. ASAP has become a national model for community colleges and the program has won acclaim in the Chronicle of Higher Education, in The Atlantic, and the editorial page of the New York Times.

ASAP began in Fall 2007, with support from the Office of the Mayor���s Center for Economic Opportunity, with the goal of significantly improving���even doubling���graduation rates. There have now been seven ASAP cohorts totaling 6,400 students admitted across six of our community colleges. The differences in ASAP���s results are seen as soon as the first semester and continue at all junctures over three years. After three years, 47 percent of ASAP students with remedial needs and 56 percent of fully proficient students have graduated, versus 19 percent of non-ASAP students and 28 percent of skills proficient non-ASAP students. But best of all, for the first time we decided to measure 2.5-year graduation rates (the standard has been three years), and we discovered it is 46 percent, compared to 15 percent of the comparison group.

A key point for us: students in ASAP graduate at three times the national average for urban students, and ASAP students graduate at more than double, approaching triple, the rate of non-ASAP CUNYstudents. An MDRC study called ASAP ���one of the most aggressive efforts in the country to improve the success rates of low income students.��� We agree, and under the Mayor���s Executive Budget, we can extend this successful program to more of our students. In Fall 2013, ASAP served 3,225 students. With the city���s investment, expansion would increase enrollment to 4,352, 8,738 and 13, 090 in each of the next three years.

Next, the University will expand STEM research fellowships for CUNYstudents. CUNYundergraduates will be offered opportunities to work directly with faculty on research projects. In addition to a fellowship stipend, students will receive laboratory training, academic support, and counseling. Practical lab experience often intensifies student interest in pursuing STEM careers and provides valuable, job-relevant skills. Year-round fellowships of approximately 600 hours will be offered.

CUNYwill create a STEM cooperative education program to allow students earning degrees in technical fields to spend a semester working full-time in a technical position while also taking courses. Three hundred students per year would benefit from this program, starting in Year 3.

In addition, the city���s investment will allow the University to pay summer tuition for students in STEM-related disciplines. CUNYstudents receiving financial aid are not typically able to take summer courses, despite the fact that summer study is proven method of helping students to make significant and timely progress in earning college degrees. Approximately 4,500 undergraduates will benefit from access to these funds.

CUNYwill also bolster academic advisement to improve the quality of academic support services. One additional staff member will be added for each 1,500 full-time equivalent students at each campus, to update advisement systems and to provide attention and support to at-risk students. Through this initiative, all campuses will implement ���early alert��� systems to identify students facing academic challenges early in the semester and provide them with additional support. Improved academic advisement benefits all students, but especially STEM students because of the complexity of their degree requirements.

Turning to the year ahead, the 2015 Executive Budget adds $15.2 million to the community college operating budget pursuant to the maintenance of effort provision. In addition to the STEM Support Expansion initiative mentioned earlier, community college rental needs of $1.5 million are fully funded and baselined. The financial plan also adds $2.8 million for the Civic Justice Corps program at John Jay College.

The executive budget, however, did not include funding for the Dominican Studies Institute and the Center for Puerto Rican Studies, each of which is a leading national center for historical and cultural research. The Creative Arts Team, which provides learning opportunities for at-risk students, and the Joseph S. Murphy Institute���s campus-based worker education programs were also unfunded. Your assistance in restoring funding for these important programs would be greatly appreciated.

We are extremely grateful to the City Council that funding for the Black Male Initiative has been baselined in the City���s financial plan. This permanent source of funding will enable continuity and long-term planning in our work to support the increased participation and success of under-represented groups in higher education, particularly black men. It also sends an important signal to external funding agencies that the initiative is being supported on an ongoing basis.

We have heard the voices of 勛圖弝け���s elected student government leaders who are urging CUNYto support City Council Academic Achievement Awards, modeled after the Vallone Scholarships. That initiative provided financial aid to students who graduated with a B average from New York City high schools and who maintained that B average at the University. These new merit-based awards would be available to deserving students at both the senior colleges and community colleges. We are extremely encouraged and appreciative that these financial aid awards were included in the Council���s formal response to the Mayor���s Preliminary Budget.

We were also grateful that the Council���s budget response called for a full restoration of funding for another program that has proven to be successful, CUNYPrep, in the Bronx. This program was established in 2003 and is a collaboration of the Mayor���s Center for Economic Opportunity. The program helps students age 16 to 18 earn their High School Equivalency Diploma and enter college. CUNYPrep���s mission is to develop learners who have the academic, personal and social skills necessary for higher education. Unfortunately, there is currently no support for CUNYPrep in the Executive Budget for FY2015.

I am now going to turn to the issue of facilities and 勛圖弝け���s Capital Budget. CUNYhas 24 institutes including four-year colleges, community colleges and graduate schools. The facilities for the senior colleges are the responsibility of the state and the community colleges are funded 50% by the state and 50% by the local jurisdiction, the city in our case. 勛圖弝け���s seven community colleges, with the exception of Queensborough Community College, are all urban campuses that were established in buildings converted from other functions. Community college facilities comprise over 7 million square feet, and nearly three-quarters of it is at least 40 years old.

The City Council has been an outstanding partner to 勛圖弝け, especially to our community colleges, by providing funding and support for critical maintenance work as well as for major projects, such as the new Fiterman Hall at Borough of Manhattan Community College and the new North Hall and Library at Bronx Community College. Both of these buildings added much-needed space but have also enriched the campuses with modern, well-designed facilities that inspire students to learn. Thank you for helping CUNYto complete these buildings.

Funding from the Council also contributed to the success of the CUNYin the Heights program, which moved a few years ago into leased space on Broadway between 213th and 214th streets in Upper Manhattan. We were able to secure the lease and build out the new facility with $2 million generously provided by the Council, and a state grant. CUNYin the Heights is proving so popular that we are now looking to lease additional space to accommodate demand.

At the Senior Colleges, funding provided by the Council has contributed to expansion of the Performing Arts Center at Brooklyn College, upgrades to libraries at Hunter and Medgar Evers, construction of a greenhouse facility on the roof of Lehman College���s new science building, renovations to Queens College���s Kupferberg Arts Complex, and the addition of campus-wide site signage at College of Staten Island.

Thank you for that commitment.

For a moment if you will indulge me, I want to take you back a few years. In 2007 after decades of deferred maintenance, 勛圖弝け, with the assistance of the State University Construction Fund, completed a state of good repair analysis on all its campuses. The results were analyzed by Pacific Partners Consulting Group. Using a lifecycle model based on current replacement cost, CUNYwas provided with an estimate of the funding necessary to eliminate its backlog of deferred maintenance as well as the funding needed to replace or reconstruct essential facilities and their components and subsystems as they approach the end of their useful life (our renewal costs). In 2007, that analysis showed that our community college campuses, where the city is financially responsible for 50% of the costs, had a backlog of nearly $500 million of work to be completed. The study also said that if we did not address the work identified, the cost would continue to increase on average of $65 million per year. That proved to be true: when we updated the study in 2012 the backlog grew to be $730 million for the community colleges, despite the funds we expended to date.

That report was a turning point because it allowed CUNYto articulate its critical maintenance needs in a methodical manner and provide costs associated each component. It truly was the beginning of a renaissance for our facilities.

The Council was one of the entities that understood this and has been a steadfast partner helping CUNYaddress multiple projects at all our campuses. In particular, some of the largest, most intractable projects have progressed because of this body.

Over the past five years, the Council has provided nearly $90 million in funding to address health and safety issues and deferred maintenance on the community college campuses, along with funding for individual programmatic projects. This is in addition to funding from the Mayor and the borough presidents. Since we match all our community college funding with state appropriations, that means we gained $180 million dollars in projects with City Council support.

Here are just of a few of the largest critical maintenance projects that the City Council either funded or supported in the last five years that contribute to the well-being and operation of our community colleges:
繚 the first phases of campus-wide utility upgrades at Bronx Community College, costing $50 million;
繚 the first phase of fa癟ade repairs to BMCC���s 199 Chambers St. Building, $5 million ;
繚 a major upgrade of the campus central plant at Kingsborough Community College for $19 million;
繚 also at Kingsborough, renovations to the T2 classroom building, $5.2 million ;
繚 various ADA bathroom upgrades and roof repairs at Hostos, $1.8 million ;
繚 and at LaGuardia we completed a modernization and expansion of the bursar and admissions offices, $6.6 million.

Those are completed projects. Going forward, with funding already provided by the Council we will complete other important projects, including the fa癟ade for LaGuardia Community College���s Center 3 Building. The building���s enormous terra-cotta fa癟ade is 100 years old and must be replaced if the building is to be preserved. Because of a lack of funding, we had originally planned to phase this project, which would have added to the expense and duration of the work. But thanks to the City Council and the city���s commitment in the FY2013 budget, CUNYhas bid the work all at once, saving money and expediting the completion of this $120 million dollar project. Other major projects that will benefit from this funding in the future are:
繚 Bronx Community College���s ongoing major utility upgrades,
roof replacements at several of the colleges, and
繚 construction of a new dining facility and kitchen at Queensborough, and
renovation additional floors of the 500 Grand Concourse Building at Hostos Community College.

But as you can tell from the state of good repair report I quoted earlier, much work remains and you will continue to see requests for critical maintenance from our colleges. This year CUNYhas identified and prioritized over $250 million in critical maintenance projects at community colleges that need funding.

Now, turning to the details of the City budget just released by the administration: the Fiscal Year 2015 Executive Budget delays $108 million of Mayoral funding scheduled in the current year of the plan (FY14) to fiscal years FY15 and FY16. The majority of the delayed funding is for the new Hunter Science and Health Professions building. The delay is not a reduction in funding, but rather a re-scheduling of funds to better reflect when contracts are expected to be awarded. CUNYexpects this change to have little impact on program goals. We hope meet with OMB shortly and further discuss 勛圖弝け���s community college critical maintenance needs.

One of our priorities this year is funding for a new Allied Health and Sciences Building at Hostos Community College. Design will begin soon for this 170,000-square-foot building. The facility will provide modern classrooms and science labs for the college���s allied health programs in dental hygiene, radiological technology, and nursing, as well as its growing engineering and natural science programs. The building will provide dental and wellness clinics, where students will gain practical experience and the public will receive dental hygiene and wellness education. We look forward to sharing updates on the progress of this important new facility for Hostos Community College. To date we have $9 million, $4.5 million from the City and $4.5 million from the state, for this $215 million facility.

CUNYis also in the early stages of developing a strategy to identify a permanent home for Guttman Community College. The college is currently located at the former Katharine Gibbs School on 50 West 40th Street, under a lease that expires in 2020.We look forward to working with state and city officials to find a permanent solution.

The community colleges received $20 million for critical maintenance and projects that already have some city funding. The State in the last five years has consistently matched any funding for community colleges that was put up by the city.

Chairperson Ferreras, Chairperson Barron, and members of the Finance and Higher Education committees, on behalf of all of us at the University, let me thank you again for your support of 勛圖弝け. Your partnership has enabled a transformation that few thought possible. We���re very grateful for it and look forward to working closely with you on the budget in the weeks ahead. Thank you.