June 9, 2025 |

Democratizing Public Services

by Leandra Manon

, an associate professor of Philosophy and director of the Urban Sustainability Studies program at 勛圖弝け���s Brooklyn College, has been a longtime advocate for community led climate action and environmental justice. Menser serves as Associate Director for Public Engagement for the Science and Resilience Institute at Jamaica Bay in partnership with Brooklyn College, and his work reflects a similar ideology: climate solutions must include the voices and needs of the people most affected.泭

In 2022, Menser co-authored the case study, , which explores how public utilities, such as water and electricity, can be restructured to serve communities more equitably (and be climate conscious), including them within the process through democratic governance and without the reliance of private contractors. The case study suggests that in order for a public service to function, it must act as a co-production with citizens, community members泭 and practice participatory governance in order to deliver proper access to services, quality and pricing of utilities.泭泭泭

Democratizing Public Services was co-written with former , who led the remunicipalization of water services in Paris and created the largest public-owned water operator in France ��� .泭

���Anne is one of my heros���, said Menser who through his research came across Le Strat���s work which later served as the inspiration for their joint case study.泭泭

He met Le Strat through Aaron Eisenberg, who co-edited and published their case study. Le Strat visited Brooklyn College in the Fall of 2019 where they spoke about their shared beliefs of democratizing public services, becoming the foundation for a 92 page guide on rethinking power from the ground up.泭泭

The following year, the duo began working on the case study, often meeting at Bryant Park because of social distancing regulations at the time. With the support of the Rosa Luxemburg Foundation, Le Strat and Menser wrote their case study and published it in February of the following year.泭泭

Before co-authoring his case study with Le Strat, Menser was already looking into the concept of participatory budgeting ��� a process first started in Brazil in 1989 that introduced the idea of泭 allowing community members the opportunity to decide how a portion of the public budget will be spent.泭

���I’ve always been interested in participatory democracy. You know, how do we get together to make good, informed, fair, collective decisions? Not just relying on some boss or some president or some elected official to tell us what to do,��� said Menser.泭泭

His research led him to connect with former Chicago Alderman Joe Moore, who had introduced participatory budgeting in his district. Menser, feeling inspired, wanted to see if it was possible to utilize泭 participatory budgeting with public utilities in New York, which led him to come across Le Strat���s work in Paris.泭泭

Menser admits, however, he was initially hesitant to tackle electricity. It felt ���too complicated���, expressed Menser.泭泭

���[With water], you hold it, you drink it. [With] electricity, what is it?��� Menser continued. It was his students who pushed him to take this utility on and it paid off.泭 ���It took me a long time to wrap my head around it, and then I became totally fascinated.���泭

As it stands, the current electrical system finds itself reliant on private contractors who place profit and efficiency over environmental sustainability, often using fossil fuels such as coal, natural gas and oil to generate power. In New York City alone, there are 24 power plants that rely on fossil fuels to produce electricity. According to the , 70% of these power plants are over 50 years old, releasing air pollutants that contribute to poor air quality and related health issues for New York City residents ��� particularly in communities across the South Bronx, Jamaica Bay, East New York and South Shore of Staten Island.泭泭

Mensers case study suggests that democratizing electricity could lead to a reduction of greenhouse gas emissions and a less polluted neighborhood for low income communities who tend to house people of color.泭泭

You may be asking: ���How does water and electricity correlate? Aren���t these two different entities?泭泭

While electricity and water may operate differently, the way they are governed is the same: by private, top down systems that prioritize profit and efficiency over sustainability, equity, and democracy.泭泭

Although the Public Service Commission (PSC) regulates utilities in New York, it���s top down structure limits community involvement meaning customers have little say in how utilities are being managed or how rates are set. Aside from this, critics have been skeptical of PSC���s management of public utilities泭泭

According to , the PSC unorganized planning is harming New York City���s clean energy transition. Their usage of outdated data and incorrect calculations for planning purposes, cancellation of renewable energy projects and unreasonable estimations for the cost of transition have led to growing concerns that the state will fall short of its climate goals.泭

The act of democratizing public utility services, in this case water and electricity, is the process of developing and delivering public services and policies in partnership with citizens as a way to shift total power from governments and institutions to a co-production where citizens and communities are involved in the decision making process in regards to budget and long term planning.泭

泭The case study argues that democratizing public services like water and electricity is ���essential for a just, sustainable and resilient production and allocation of the public goods needed to promote human flourishing and a healthy planet.��� By involving the communities directly in the decision making process, utilities will not only become more equitable, but also better equipped to handle challenges brought on by the ongoing climate crisis.泭

The community centered approach extends beyond Brooklyn College and 勛圖弝け. Menser also serves as the co-director of the NYC Climate Justice Hub and was a member of the advisory committee on the ��� where the principles from his case study were put into practice and applied in real-world energy reform.泭泭

During the production of their case study, Hurricane Isaias hit the East Coast in August 2020. According to , the tropical storm caused widespread power outages across Long Island affecting approximately 105,000 customers. Menser, a Nassau County resident, was among the residents who endured the week-long power outage. after Hurricane Isaias concluded that the damage caused by the storm to the electrical system resulted in approximately 645,0001 customer outages.泭

���Our local paper, thank goodness, Newsday did a story on LIPA (Long Island Power Authority) and PSEG (Public Service Enterprise Group.) LIPA contracts out the maintenance of the grid to PSEG which is a privately owned utility from New Jersey and it came out that PSEG had lied to LIPA about being ready for the storm,��� said Menser.泭泭

The storm exposed LIPA���s dependance on private contractors and its lack of preparedness for climate driven disasters. Although LIPA is a not-for-profit public utility that owns the electric transmission and distribution system, it contracts with PSEG who manages the system, operates the utility and bills customers.泭泭

���We did the deep dive,��� said Menser of his work with the Future of Long Island Power Authority after the power outage left many Long Island residents frustrated. The mishandling of LIPA and their public utilities can, for many, come with a great cost.泭泭泭

Menser says his case study came in handy in discussions with LIPA. ���We’re like, this makes no sense. How do we create it? And I’m like, ���well, I just happened to have written an essay about how to democratize it,��� to the surprise and delight of the nonprofit, explained Menser. Through a series of meetings, they crafted a proposal based on Menser and Le Strat���s case study and fine tuned it to service the needs of Long Island residents ��� advocating for a push to democratize LIPA and remove PSEG completely in an effort to publicize the utility and come up with sustainable initiatives to deal with the changing climate.泭泭

After a series of public events introducing their idea to democratize their electric utility and pressuring elected officials to comply, Menser along with members of Future of the Long Island Power Authority created a law,泭 , to change the structure of the utility. The law mandates restructuring LIPA into a fully public, democratically governed utility and ending its third party management model. It also demands developing legislation that will improve transparency, storm response, public involvement and alignment with New York���s climate goals. However, not without roadblocks.泭泭

���We finished that law last year,��� said Menser. ���It got introduced in the house, it didn’t get introduced in the Senate.��� Contracting restrictions with PSEG halted the law from making its way into the Senate, however as PSEG���s contract is set to expire at the end of this year, Menser and his colleagues are hopeful they can get their law passed.泭泭

As PSEG���s contract is set to expire, the campaign to democratize LIPA continues and stands at a critical turning point as this could help transform how public services are run in New York. For Menser, this goes beyond energy reform. Passing this law could mean proving that publicly owned utilities with the oversight of citizens and democratic governance could not only service people much more equitably, but be tools for climate resiliency as well.泭泭