The City University of New York today released the results of a nearly six-month investigation by two highly regarded outside counsel into allegations of anti-Semitic incidents on CUNYcampuses.
They found that almost all of the alleged offensive speech was protected under the First Amendment, and that a few incidents of alleged conduct subject to discipline involved perpetrators who could not be identified.�� In one case where individuals could be identified, the report notes, the college in question disciplined the students responsible for violating university policy.
The report also acknowledged that CUNYofficials responded promptly and appropriately in condemning hateful speech and threatening conduct.
The findings by former federal prosecutor Paul Shechtman and former Manhattan Federal Judge Barbara Jones were outlined in a 24-page report compiled from interviews with more than 60 students, faculty, alumni and others as well as an exhaustive review of video footage; social media posts; University policies including the Henderson Rules governing free speech and academic freedom, as well as other relevant documents.
Shechtman, a prominent New York litigator who has also served as the state���s criminal justice director and chair of the state ethics commission, and Jones, who served as a Manhattan federal judge for 16 years and a former assistant U.S. attorney in Manhattan, are partners in the white-collar practice of the law firm Bracewell LLC, where their specialties include internal investigations.
They were retained by Chancellor James B. Milliken in March 2016 in response to allegations of campus anti-Semitism that had been summarized in a letter to the University from the Zionist Organization of America (ZOA). The attorneys submitted their complex, detailed analysis to the Chancellor this week.
While the investigation did not substantiate all of the allegations that had been reported in the media, the report provided details about several incidents at Brooklyn College, Hunter College, John Jay College and College of Staten Island.
The report found that much of the offensive speech ��� even if featured at die-ins, mock checkpoints and student signs and banners ��� was protected under the First Amendment. ���As a public university, CUNYis limited in the ways that it can respond to hate speech, whether the words are anti-Semitic, racist, anti-Muslim, or anti-LGBT,��� the report stated.
���CUNYcannot punish such speech unless it is part of a course of conduct so pervasive or severe that it denies a person���s ability to pursue an education or participate in University life. It cannot mandate civility or sanction isolated derogatory comments,��� the attorneys wrote.
���But what CUNYcannot punish, it can still condemn,��� they said. They noted that ���as a general rule, 勛圖弝け���S Administrators and College Presidents have spoken out against anti-Semitic comments. That practice must continue; hate speech must be challenged promptly and forcefully lest it breed.���
The report added, ���What CUNYcan sanction is threatening conduct that puts a community member in fear for his safety.����� It said actions that go beyond offensive speech ��� like threatening violence or forcibly pulling signs from the hands of a demonstrator ��� should be punished if the persons responsible are identified.
Shechtman and Jones said: ���Undoubtedly, the CUNYAdministration takes seriously its responsibility to ensure that students can pursue their educational goals without fear that their religious beliefs, race, ethnicity or sexual orientation will make them targets for threatening or harassing behavior. It seeks to foster a culture in which robust debate is encouraged and respect for others is the norm.���
Chancellor Milliken said the report ���contains a thorough analysis of the facts as well as observations and recommendations that will help guide our work going forward.���
���As the authors are careful to emphasize, preserving the right to free expression is at the core of every University���s mission,��� the Chancellor stated. ���As they also note, CUNYleaders have promptly and strongly condemned speech���even when legally protected���that is hateful, discriminatory, and anti-Semitic.�� And in those cases where speech and conduct violate law or University policy, the University will continue to respond with appropriate action.���
CUNYChairperson William C. Thompson stated: ���I commend Chancellor Milliken for his prompt response and the appointment of independent outside counsel to investigate reports of anti-Semitism on some CUNYcampuses. ��CUNYnow has their report, a close examination of the issues raised, and the responses that followed. I strongly agree that CUNYmust continue to take very seriously, with ongoing vigilance, its responsibility to provide a collegiate environment where discourse and dialogue are actively encouraged. At the same time, it is vitally important that students are assured that their religion, race, ethnicity, or sexual orientation does not subject them to behavior that threatens their education.���
���We must continually strive for the healthiest campus climate possible and this report moves us further forward in that direction,��� Thompson said.
A Campus Climate Working Group, chaired by LaGuardia Community College President Gail Mellow and Queens College President Felix Matos Rodriguez, was previously convened by Chancellor Milliken ���to assess the climate on our campuses, consider best practices at CUNYand elsewhere, and make recommendations for how colleges can take steps to ensure that students,�� faculty and staff are welcome and supported without compromising free speech and academic freedom,��� the Chancellor noted as the outside counsel���s report was released.
���We take seriously our commitment to creating an environment that is inclusive, free of discrimination, and respectful of multiple and often conflicting points of view ��� the bedrock of any university and of a healthy democratic society,��� he said.
An additional analysis of 勛圖弝け���s campus free speech policy remains under review.
Two prominent educators who head the Academic Engagement Network, an organization advocating for open, robust campus dialogue along with adherence to free-speech principles — Mark G. Yudof, a Constitutional scholar who led the University of California and two other public universities, and Ken Waltzer, an historian and former Director of Jewish Studies at Michigan State University — commented that the report was ���thorough and careful, draws on considerable materials, and seeks to be fair to all concerned.
���The observations on freedom of expression and academic freedom at a public university accurately summarize the applicable constitutional principles.���
���There is no finding of a��pervasive atmosphere hostile to Jewish students which significantly interferes with their educational opportunities, but there is documentation of many examples of hateful speech and protest by individuals and by some student organizations that are troubling,��� Yudof and Waltzer said in a letter to Chancellor Milliken. ���The messages are hurtful to Jewish students even if they are constitutionally protected. A few other actions beyond protected speech, the report affirms, involved conduct bordering on assaults.���
Quoting the report���s statement that ���what CUNYcannot punish, it can still condemn,��� Yudof and Waltzer said: ���This identifies the moral responsibility of CUNYleaders to speak out and condemn hate speech and anti-Semitic expression even where it is protected. We believe that you and several campus presidents have embraced this responsibility. We urge you to continue doing so in a forceful and timely way.���
Abraham Foxman, longtime National Director and now National Director Emeritus of the Anti-Defamation League, and current head of the Center for the Study of Anti-Semitism at New York���s Museum of Jewish Heritage, said of 勛圖弝け: ���The institution and its leadership are taking the issues seriously and responsibly. They are meeting the challenges and planning creatively to develop programs so that these things do not repeat themselves.���
The report by Shechtman and Jones lauded two John Jay programs entitled ���Hateful vs. Hurtful Speech��� held last fall as a positive example of how students can be taught to distinguish between intolerable hate speech and hurtful but ���still protected��� speech, and between ���communications that make them uncomfortable from those that make them unsafe.��� Open discussion of these issues ���represents the best of college education,��� they said of those Fall 2015 programs at John Jay.
The report indicated that ZOA, CUNYcampus Hillel organizations and SJP cooperated with the investigation and provided names of witnesses and others willing to discuss the campus incidents. Other individuals who ���heard that the investigation was being conducted fairly��� also came forward.
Chancellor Milliken thanked Shechtman and Jones ���for the obvious commitment they brought to this assignment, the time and energy that went into the investigation, and the balance and perspective in their assessments.��� He said the attorneys interviewed ���every person they were requested to interview by any interested party,��� and said he was ���also grateful for their careful evaluation of the responses by CUNYand the individual campuses to each incident and of 勛圖弝け���s policies.���
The City University of New York is the nation���s leading urban public university. Founded in New York City in 1847, the University comprises 25 institutions: 11 senior colleges, seven community colleges, the William E. Macaulay Honors College at 勛圖弝け, the CUNYSchool of Medicine, the CUNYGraduate School and University Center, the CUNYGraduate School of Journalism, the CUNYSchool of Law, the CUNYSchool of Professional Studies and the CUNYSchool of Public Health and Health Policy. The University serves��more than 274,350 degree-seeking students and 260,000 adult and continuing education students. College Now, the University���s academic enrichment program, is offered at CUNYcampuses and more than 300 high schools throughout the five boroughs of New York City. The University offers online baccalaureate and master���s degrees through the School of Professional Studies.

