CUNYScholars Weigh in on a Historic Inauguration

We Asked CUNYExperts What This Moment Means to Them, Our Country, and How We Move Forward

Photo by Evan Vucci/AP

The inauguration of President-elect Joe Biden and Vice President-elect Kamala Harris marks a new chapter in our history. No matter your politics, there is no denying that the newly installed leaders will have to confront major challenges at a time when our country is the most divided it���s been in decades. How can our government and our society overcome such polarization? How can we move forward to eradicate COVID-19 and battle the wide range of other crises we face? Here, some of 勛圖弝け���s brightest scholars share their thoughts, reflections and perspectives on this historic and highly consequential moment. (Their views do not constitute an official statement on the part of the University.)

Vincent Boudreau

President and former Professor of Political Science

The City College of New York

���Democracies depend on the restraint of power, and when they fail, it is often because power shakes free of those restraints. The peaceful transition represented in this inauguration demonstrates the resilience of our threatened democracy, and that resiliency sends a message of hope for the future of our nation.���

Ted Widmer

Professor and Distinguished Lecturer

Macaulay Honors College

“This has been one of the hardest and strangest transitions in history, right up there with Lincoln’s in 1861. But at long last, we have come out on the other side, and let’s hope that Americans begin to work together again, in the way that was once the envy of the world.���泭

Patria de Lancer Julnes

Associate Dean of Academic Programs and Professor, Austin W. Marxe School of Public and International Affairs

Baruch College

���I am excited about the diversity of Biden���s cabinet. This is the first time that a cabinet comes close to genuinely representing the American experience. It is also fantastic to see that he has elevated the environment and science to ensure that we remain focused on preventing further damage to the environment and using evidence to make decisions, most of which are consequential not only for the United States but also for the entire world.���

Harold Holzer

Director of The Roosevelt House Public Policy Institute

Hunter College

���At his first inaugural in 1861���the most visibly guarded in history until now��� Abraham Lincoln summoned the ���better angels of our nature��� to promote national unity. But as we know, Lincoln���s eloquence was not enough to prevent civil war. We have to hope that we���ve learned the lessons of history and will remember and heed Lincoln���s other sage and relevant advice: there is no recourse ���from the ballot to the bullet.”���

Helen Chang

Assistant Professor of Political Science

Hostos Community College

���Political scientist Maurice Duverger (1984) believed that ���electoral mechanisms are strange devices���simultaneously cameras and projectors. They register images which they have partly created themselves.��� As we learn from the last four years and look to the next four years, we must remember that our democratic institutions are not immutable. American voters and our elected leaders are not simply constrained by the rules governing our political system, but together, we also have the ability to shape these rules and expand on who they work for.���

D���Weston Haywood

Associate Professor of History

Hunter College

���In the last four years, a comparatively short period of time in the long drama of American history, we have nonetheless witnessed and experienced an era racked by massive protests that played out in rather unprecedented ways. From Black Lives Matter to the Women���s March on Washington to March for Our Lives, a groundswell of grassroots protest inaugurated and indelibly marked this entire period, pushing America to finally meet its promises and ideals of equality and justice for all. Anti-lockdown protests pushed too, though with different aims in mind, aims that became especially clear in sustained attacks on the truth that culminated in the attack on the U.S. Capitol on January 6. If unprecedented protest shaped the last four years in this country, it is my hope that unprecedented solutions for inequality and injustice shape the next���and beyond.���

Heath Brown

Associate Professor of Public Policy

The CUNYGraduate Center and John Jay College of Criminal Justice

���This was a historically dangerous transition lacking in the most basic elements of a peaceful transfer of power that the United States is used to. The early days of the Biden-Harris administration will remain dangerous, and the quick confirmation of the cabinet and sun-cabinet is incredibly important to keeping the country safe.���

Charlies Tien

Professor of Political Science

The CUNYGraduate Center and Hunter College

���I am sad that this inauguration is occurring under the shadow of seditious behavior committed by our country���s leaders. However, I am buttressed by the knowledge that power is being transferred to the winner as spelled out by the Constitution. And I am hopeful that our country can reckon with the Trump presidency in a way that provides accountability and dialogue.���

David S. Birdsell

Dean and Professor, Austin W. Marxe School of Public and International Affairs

Baruch College

���Joe Biden���s inauguration and his first 100 days may be the most consequential since FDR took office in 1933. He must deal with the interlocking crises of pandemic, economic catastrophe, and harrowing inequality while at the same time bringing together a people starkly divided over policy, governance, and the very definition of what it means to be a citizen of this nation. His inaugural address must be inspiring and inclusive as well as sufficiently concrete to be able to make plain by May that government can deliver on its promises to address the nation���s needs equitably, effectively, and transparently.���

Molly Vollman Makris

Associate Professor of Urban Studies

Guttman Community College

���As a researcher who studies gentrification and educational inequality, the wealth, opportunity, and racial divides in our country, and in particular, how they influence the lives of children, permeates all of my work. As the new administration takes office, my hope is that we will see large scale, bold policies that address not just much needed pandemic-related relief but that will put our country on a path to long-term economic security for all families.泭 This should entail fully funded public education, childcare reform, and housing, environmental, and racial justice initiatives. These policies will support those individuals for whom the Covid-19 pandemic has exacerbated inequities that were already part of their daily experiences.���

Ernest Ialongo

Chair of the Behavioral and Social Sciences Department

Hostos Community College

���My only thought on the inauguration is that it cannot come soon enough. What these past four years have shown us, and what January 6, 2021 made abundantly clear, is that the democratic form of government is a fragile thing. Ours is a government of laws, but it is also a commitment to adhere to those laws, and not to give in to the desire to foment change through violence.

The storming of the capitol reminded us that all the processes we have in place for a democratic election can be overturned in an instant when a determined group of people seek to impose might over right. The insurrection was the culmination of 4 years of civil discord which had been enflamed by President Trump in an attempt at undermining faith in democratic institutions and focusing the attentions of the frustrated minority onto him as the savior of a purportedly failed system.

Allusions to Trump���s fascistic tendencies have been legion since he came to office: the press as the enemy of the people, the identification of the cult leader as the state itself, a demand for unswerving loyalty by the leader, a hyper-masculine ethos that seeks to humiliate and obliterate the political opposition, a pronounced nationalism and militarism, xenophobia, and a far too comfortable tendency to encourage violence against one���s enemies. Scholars of fascism pointed to these connections between Trump and Hitler and Mussolini early on. They were not taken seriously. Yet, as the years passed, and rhetoric became political action and legislation, and the violence at the heart of this rhetoric led to actual violence on January 6, 2021, such scholars are now being taken very seriously.

The inauguration of President-elect Biden and Vice-President-elect Harris will bring the country back to its best ideals, will put us back on the course where we continue to form ���a more perfect union���, and where we confidently face the challenges that lay ahead.���

Michael Sharpe

Associate Professor of Political Science

York College

���This inauguration, the historic presidential transition, and the Presidency of Joseph Biden are critically important because they will shape and test the norms, character and resilience of the U.S. constitutional republic, its institutions, and the trust and values of the American people. Moreover, the Biden administration has the potential to reestablish the rules based international liberal democratic order that has been the cornerstone of the post-World War II world. Over the next four years, I hope for a return and ever stronger recommitment to the belief and practice in democratic values, principles, and institutions, rule of law, equality, racial and economic justice, antiracism, truth, decency, transparency, integrity, respect, knowledge, education, science, expertise, international organizations, human rights, and social justice.���泭泭

Brian Arbour

Associate Professor of Political Science

John Jay College of Criminal Justice

���Joe Biden won both his party’s nomination and the general election primarily because of his favorable contrast with Donald Trump. Now he and his party must pivot to building up positive views of Biden and his policies.���

Anne M. Kornhauser

Associate Professor and Chair of the Department of History

The City College of New York泭

���The inauguration of Joseph R. Biden is without historical precedent. Tens of thousands of military personnel make it an unusually militarized affair. A raging pandemic will greatly limit the size of the crowd witnessing this uniquely American changing of the presidential guard. A pending impeachment trial of Biden���s predecessor adds yet another unprecedented dimension to this transition of power. Finally, Biden will be the oldest person ever to hold the office of the presidency. Still, I believe most of the country will root for the new president to set the country on a more peaceful, healthy, and economically just course.���

John Torpey

Presidential Professor of Sociology and History and Director of the Ralph Bunche Institute for International Studies

The CUNYGraduate Center

���The inauguration of President Joseph R. Biden, Jr., is an opportunity ���to bind up the nation���s wounds,��� as Lincoln put it in his second inaugural, and to begin to address the real challenges that confront us today. Overcoming division and restoring trust in government are the most important things we have to do right now because they are the foundation of effective responses to the serious public health, economic, and environmental crises we now face.���

Sarah L. Hoiland

Associate Professor of Sociology

Hostos Community College

���Dr. Jill Biden will make history by keeping her faculty position at Northern Virginia Community College (NOVA) while serving as First Lady of the United States (FLOTUS), which mirrors her decision to teach at NOVA while serving as Second Lady from 2009-2017. With these choices, she is modernizing the role of First Lady, asserting the importance of her profession, our profession, and maintaining her commitment to debt-free community college. In August, she tweeted from @DrBiden, “Teaching is not what I do. It’s who I am.”泭

Her use of “Dr.” has ruffled feathers; most notably in Joseph Epstein’s December 11th, 2020 WSJ Opinion in which he questioned her use of “Dr.” saying it “sounds and feels fraudulent, not to say a touch comic.” Thousands have since critiqued Epstein’s paternalistic and sexist tone as well as the basis for his argument while others supported the attempt to reduce her status and earned doctorate. Women and people of color constantly fight to be afforded the same respect white men are given with or without a title inside and outside academia.

I have many hopes for the next four years, but what I will demand is debt-free community college and full investment in our community college students, staff, and faculty as restitution for disinvestment from the communities in which we teach, and a commitment to a more just and equitable society. We don’t have to look any farther than the Hostos giants who fought to keep our College open 50 years ago.���

Jacob Segal

Associate Professor of Political Science

Kingsborough Community College

���The inauguration of Joseph Biden represents the culmination of his decades long search for the presidency and a return to post-Trump, normal politics even in the context of a pandemic.泭 It remains to be seen what Biden can accomplish given the extremely small majorities in the House of Representatives and the Senate.泭 Biden ran as a more liberal candidate than he has been in his career as a politician in office.泭 These policies are popular generally within his party, but opposed by a smaller moderate element, and so the success of his presidency rests on his navigating these two pressures.���

Andrew Sidman

Chair, Department of Political Science

John Jay College of Criminal Justice

���January 6th was a flashpoint; as saddening as it was alarming. Yet, the violence at the Capitol was another, albeit prominent, step down a road our nation has been traveling for some time. Over the last thirty years (and more), we have become increasingly divided as a civil, political society. Each ���side��� seeing the other as an enemy to be defeated, not as fellow citizens with different ideas and preferences. Our representatives at all levels of government have long since abandoned bipartisanship and compromise, both leading and following voter bases, coopted by extremism, that sees these virtues as capitulation. Leaders from both parties have worked to dismantle the norms that kept our government functioning. Over the last four years, however, we have seen the Republican Party abandon basic decency and all responsibility for protecting democracy, all, seemingly, for a poor excuse for tax reform and control over the judicial branch. Events like the invasion of the Capitol can also be symbols. I hope it serves as a symbol of what damage enabling President Trump has wrought. I hope it serves as a warning about what happens when power is pursued for power���s sake. Above all, I hope it is a wake-up call that our words have consequences. President-elect Biden���s inaugural address, I am confident, will be filled with the rhetoric of cooperation, of disagreeing respectfully, of restoring dignity to our body politic. While some will regard this as ���hokey,��� I hope seeing the violent culmination of the last four (or forty) years at least makes us listen.���

Marcus D. Allen

Professor of Political Science

Guttman Community College泭

���The inauguration of Joseph Biden and Kamala Harris is a beacon of light reminding us and the world that our republic still stands. It also compels us to be intensely aware that much work lies ahead to rebuild our nation. As President-elect and Vice President-elect, Biden and Harris represent the heart and soul of our democratic norms. As Vice President for eight years, Biden helped President Obama navigate the terse, turbulent waters of our social and political environment. In asking Harris to serve as his Vice-President, Biden powerfully affirms all that Harris embodies to a large swath of the American population.泭 As a Black woman of Jamaican and South Asian descent, a Howard University (HBCU) graduate and a member of Alpha Kappa Alpha Sorority Incorporated, Harris symbolizes centuries of striving among women, women of color especially, to realize equality at the highest levels of government and in all facets of American life. Kamala Harris���s historic election has further sparked the imaginations of many across the country to dream and aspire to the greatest of possibilities.���

Gunja SenGupta

Professor of History

The CUNYGraduate Center and Brooklyn College

���Posterity will remember January 20, 2021, as a watershed moment of new beginnings ��� a moment marked by the inauguration of the first woman ��� and she a person of color, born of immigrant parents ��� as vice president of the United States. The event captures the complex, often paradoxical spirit of American history: the promise of a multiracial democracy tempered by the burden of history ��� a history of racial slavery. The ascendancy of Joseph Biden and especially Kamala Harris to the highest political offices of our land represents a happy and historic reversal of four years of exclusionary politics, but against the ominous backdrop of extremism lurking in large corners of our society.

As a U.S. historian and naturalized American citizen of South Asian descent, I look forward to the resuscitation of public education and knowledge creation in the service of social justice and democratic pluralism for the next four years. The release Monday of a report by the Presidential 1776 Commission by the outgoing administration (on American history but produced without the input of professional historians) badly distorts the record of our past. It is a reminder that elections have consequences for the very survival of the university as a place of intellectual integrity and truth-telling. So it is with a sigh of relief that I welcome the new chapter in our collective history that Biden and Harris are expected to usher in on Wednesday.���

Jacob Kramer

Associate Professor of History

Borough of Manhattan Community College

���Every semester I teach my students that John Adams in 1801 established the precedent of a peaceful transition of the presidency that has lasted until the present.泭 Unfortunately it looks like I am going to have to rewrite that lecture.泭 On the other hand, in previous times of economic crisis and conservative governance, a coalition of progressives and radicals established significant new forms of governmental activism.泭 Hopefully the incoming Biden administration, with impetus from Black Lives Matter and progressive Democrats, will take significant action on problems such as student debt, global warming, economic inequality, and structural racism.���

Jeannette Graulau

Professor of Political Science

Lehman College泭

���Biden’s presidency comes at a time when U.S. foreign policy in Latin America is plagued with controversy and problems. U.S. credibility in the region is at its lowest point historically. The Organization of American States is perceived as a branch of the U.S. Department of State. During the last four years, U.S. foreign policy in Latin America regrettably aimed at suffocating Cuba and Venezuela, countries that opted for their own national political formulas.

This is the time for President Biden to put an end to sanctions against Cuba and Venezuela. The impact of U.S. sanctions has been detrimental to the ordinary peoples of Cuba and Venezuela enduring the devastating impacts of the pandemic.泭 Sanctions have deprived these countries of urgently needed trade partners, development aid, and even remittances.

There is global momentum for President Biden to end a disastrous U.S. foreign policy that has only eroded U.S. legitimacy at home and abroad. Prominent U.S. writers, politicians, and Nobel Prize laureates have called for an end to sanctions. U.N. Secretary-General Ant籀nio Guterres has also called for an end to U.S. sanctions, concerned about the immoral burden the U.S. has placed upon countries already affected by the COVID-19 crisis. Guterres’ call against sanctions came at a time when the U.S. blocked the shipment of humanitarian aid (masks, ventilators, PPE) to Cuba from a donor in China this past March.

President Biden, who promised to mobilize the unprecedented amount of US$ 1.9 trillion for solving the current economic crisis, has an incredible opportunity to show that the U.S. is changing for the better by forging horizontal cooperation with Latin American neighbors.���

Michael A. Krasner

Associate Professor and Internship Director, Department of Political Science

Queens College

���Beyond the immediate concern of whether or not our government can check right-wing violence and subtler forms of sedition, without compromising our civil liberties, are the larger concerns of checking the pandemic and the ultimate concern of dealing with the climate crisis that threatens all of humanity. Citizens who use every means – from writing letters to civil disobedience –泭 are the best hope of preserving democracy and a liveable planet.���

Keena Lipsitz

Associate Professor of Political Science

The CUNYGraduate Center and Queens College

���What we are living through right now is not a peaceful transfer of power. The fact that it requires a military occupation of Washington DC to ensure that the winner of a free and fair election can take office tells you that we have approached a dangerous precipice. My hope is that in the next four years we can pull back from it, but I am not optimistic. Too many Americans are willing to jump.���

Andrew J. Polsky

Ruth and Harold Newman Dean of the School of Arts and Sciences and Professor of Political Science

Hunter College

���Joe Biden takes office facing a series of challenges unmatched since Franklin D. Roosevelt took office in March 1933. For Roosevelt it was the Great Depression, with the economy in freefall for the previous three years and unemployment as high as a quarter of the workforce. For Biden, it is the COVID-19 pandemic claiming 3000 lives per day, and an economy again slipping backwards, coupled with the aftershocks of an attempted right wing coup at the capitol and the ongoing unfounded assault on the legitimacy of his election victory. Roosevelt at least had a clear mandate to act and sizable majorities in both houses of Congress, advantages not enjoyed by Joe Biden. But if the challenges today are enormous, we should remember that crises also present opportunities for leaders prepared to act boldly. And bold action in turn creates new opportunities ��� a president can alter the political terrain by creating the public perception of being in control and effective, something neither FDR���s nor Biden���s predecessor ever managed to establish.���

Kristopher Burrell

Associate Professor of History

Hostos Community College

���The inauguration of President-elect Joe Biden is taking place in the midst of numerous social, economic, and public health crises. There will be much to contend with as a country during Biden���s term in office. Coming just two days after the federal birthday of Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr., it is necessary to utilize the prophetic wisdom of Dr. King in developing a democratic legislative vision for our country in the next four years and beyond. In 1963 in Birmingham, Alabama, responding to criticisms over the direct-action protests of Black residents in opposition to Jim Crow segregation, King argued that social tension was necessary for societal growth. The tension certainly exists in our country. We cannot be afraid of this tension. Neither can the incoming Biden administration. Our country can no longer prefer ���order��� over justice. Breaking down systemic racism, eradicating poverty, and reversing environmental degradation are extremely uncomfortable. However, it will be necessary for the new administration and us all as Americans to do the necessary work to address these issues in constructive ways.���

Clarence Hall, Jr.

Assistant Professor of History

Queensborough Community College

���Even if their legislative proposals and policies end up being less than perfect, I have every expectation that Biden and Harris will help restore civility to our public discourse. If they can help lower the temperature in the U.S., I think they will be successful.���

David S. Reynolds

Distinguished Professor

The CUNYGraduate Center

���To find an appropriate historical parallel to this week���s militarized inauguration you���d have to go back to March of 1861, when Lincoln was sworn in under the protection of an estimated 3,000 soldiers and sharpshooters. At the time, seven southern states had already formed a new nation based on slavery and white supremacy. You might call it a nation of Proud Boys.

Lincoln faced numerous death threats ahead of his inauguration, and to get into the city, he caught a late-night train in Maryland and snuck in under the cover of night. The carriage he rode in from the Willard Hotel to the Capitol building on Inauguration Day was so heavily surrounded by mounted police that the throngs of civilians lining the streets couldn���t even see it. And during Lincoln���s inaugural address, armed guards mingled with civilians on the National Mall. Even so, Lincoln was still taking a chance, given the fact that there was such electricity in the air.

That same electric dread is in the air today, 160 years later, as Capitol Hill braces itself against a possible attack on an incoming American president. Biden���s speech has yet to be delivered, but Lincoln wound down his first inaugural address back then with a plea to his fellow Americans: ���We must not be enemies.������

Wallace Ford

Professor, Department of Public Administration of the School of Business

Medgar Evers College

“The 2021 presidential transition is historic for the wrong reasons. A twice impeached president sought to overturn the election by inspiring a mob fueled coup attempt. The new president is faced with multiple challenges of a divided country that is facing yet another COVID tsunami while trying to address historical racial divisions and new age fissured inspired by social media lies and propaganda.”

 

The City University of New York is the nation���s largest urban public university, a transformative engine of social mobility that is a critical component of the lifeblood of New York City. Founded in 1847 as the nation���s first free public institution of higher education, CUNYtoday has seven community colleges, 11 senior colleges and seven graduate or professional institutions spread across New York City���s five boroughs, serving 500,000 students of all ages and awarding 55,000 degrees each year. 勛圖弝け���s mix of quality and affordability propels almost six times as many low-income students into the middle class and beyond as all the Ivy League colleges combined. More than 80 percent of the University���s graduates stay in New York, contributing to all aspects of the city���s economic, civic and cultural life and diversifying the city���s workforce in every sector. 勛圖弝け���s graduates and faculty have received many prestigious honors, including 13 Nobel Prizes and 26 MacArthur ���Genius��� Grants. The University���s historic mission continues to this day: provide a first-rate public education to all students, regardless of means or background.

###