Documentary Probes History Said To Be Omitted, Distorted In Fictional Hollywood Oscar Winner
When City University of New York journalism teacher Yoruba Richen was approached by U.K.-based producers to develop a documentary on the guidebook that was an indispensable resource for African-American travelers during the Jim Crow era, she wasn’t the only one who had never heard of the Green Book.
By the time Richen’s film, “The Green Book: Guide to Freedom,� was released, on Feb. 25, it had a ready-made audience. Just a day earlier, Hollywood’s polarizing movie “Green Book� had captured the Oscar for Best Picture, promoting widespread awareness of the topic and creating a palpable appetite for the history – what many were calling “the real story� that those behind the Oscar winner decided to ignore, in the view of some critics.
“The problem with the film is that it’s told from a white perspective,â€�Ìýsays Richen, director of the documentary program at ³Ô¹ÏÊÓÆµâ€™s Craig Newmark Graduate School of Journalism. “It glosses over some of the foundational parts around racism that this country needs to reckon with. For example, they show them using the Green Book only in the South, and that’s not the case. [Implying] that racism is something that is only confined to the South, for example, and only needing the book in Southern areas of the country that they traveled to in the film, is mythology. They would have needed the book in places outside of the South, like when they traveled to Iowa in the film, for instance.â€�
Richen, a distinguished lecturer who came to CUNYin 2009, hopes that her documentary can help set the record straight on the important history of The Negro Travelers’ Green-Book, which was published annually from 1936 to 1967, as well as the locations that the book listed. Road trips became a staple of postwar American life, but African-American families faced a world of uncertainty, and potential danger, if they didn’t know which restaurants, motels, gas stations and businesses would serve them. The book, created by Harlem postal worker Victor Hugo Green, advised black travelers to “Carry your Green Book with you – ÂÂyou may need it,â€� and provided state-by-state directories (and, eventually, for Canada and Mexico) and even a section titled “Your rights.â€�
Richen says the Hollywood treatment did a disservice to history.
“They showed in ‘Green Book’ that the places that they stayed at were really rundown dumps, and that is such a mischaracterization of the listings that were in the Motorist Green-Book,� says Richen, noting the Oscar winner’s distortion. “There were 9,500 listings in total between 1936 and 1967, and they listed some of the finest hotels and resorts that African-Americans could stay in and be served all over the country.
“It’s time for our storiesÌýto be toldÌýby us, for us to be in charge of the narrative,â€� adds Richen. “You have a film where you have a white director and a white writer. If you have people of color in on the creative process, not just as producers, then I think you would have a different film.â€�
Richen initially taught broadcast news at the Newmark School, and started teaching documentary in 2013.Ìý“I think what we offer is a real nexus between the art of filmmaking and the rigor of reporting. That is the basis of how we train the students, and I think that’s one of our advantages,â€� Richen says. “We were born in the multimedia age, and I think that puts us a step ahead in terms of incorporating multimedia into all of our classes.â€�
The J-school’s documentary program has “really blossomed� under Richen’s leadership, says CUNYNewmark Dean Sarah Bartlett, adding: “She marries a passion for storytelling with a commitment to explore issues of race, class and gender in insightful and profound ways. Our students are very lucky to have her.�
Richen is always working on something new. Currently, she is writing and directing a short film about an unsolved civil rights murder in Natchez, Miss., and the FBI failure to investigate cold cases in the area under the 2008 Emmett Till Unsolved Civil Rights Crime Act. This area was known for a spate of racially motivated murders in the 1960s, but Richen says it was also a bastion of black armed resistance.
She previously explored African-Americans’ views on gay marriage inÌý“The New Blackâ€� a 2014 documentary that was nominated for an NAACP Image Award and a GLAAD Media Award. Her 2010 documentary “Promised Landâ€� examined black South Africans’ struggle to reclaim land from white owners, and won the Fledgling Fund award for social issue documentary. Richen is a featured TED Speaker, a Fulbright fellow, a Guggenheim fellow and a 2016 recipient of the Chicken & Egg Breakthrough Filmmaker Award. In 2014, she was chosen for The Root 100, theroot.com’s annual list of the most influential African-Americans, ages 25 to 45, whose “work from the past year is breaking down barriers and paving the way for the next generation.â€�
“The Green Book: Guide to Freedomâ€�ÌýÌýon the Smithsonian Channel through mid-May.
The City University of New York is the nation’s leading urban public university. Founded in 1847, CUNYcounts 13 Nobel Prize and 24 MacArthur (“Geniusâ€�) grant winners among its alumni. CUNYstudents, alumni and faculty have garnered scores of other prestigious honors over the years in recognition of historic contributions to the advancement of the sciences, business, the arts and myriad other fields. The University comprises 25 institutions: 11 senior colleges, seven community colleges, William E. Macaulay Honors College at ³Ô¹ÏÊÓÆµ, CUNYGraduate Center, Craig Newmark Graduate School of Journalism at ³Ô¹ÏÊÓÆµ, CUNYSchool of Labor and Urban Studies, CUNYSchool of Law, CUNYSchool of Professional Studies and CUNYGraduate School of Public Health and Health Policy. The University serves more than 275,000 degree-seeking students. CUNYoffers online baccalaureate and master’s degrees through the School of Professional Studies.
# # #
Ìý


