CUNYChancellor Félix V. Matos Rodríguez Testifies at New York City Council Hearing on the FY 2025 Executive Budget Proposal

CUNYChancellor Félix V. Matos Rodríguez today testified during a joint hearing of the New York City Council’s committees on finance and higher education regarding the City’s Fiscal Year 2025 Executive Budget Proposal.

The Chancellor’s complete prepared remarks are included below:Ìý

Good afternoon, Chair Brannan, Chair Dinowitz, and other members of the New York City Council committees on Finance and Higher Education, staff and guests. I am Félix Matos Rodríguez, Chancellor of The City University of New York. I am joined this afternoon by ³Ô¹ÏÊÓÆµâ€™s Executive Vice Chancellor and University Provost Wendy Hensel, Executive Vice Chancellor and Chief Operating Officer Hector Batista, and Senior Vice Chancellor for Budget and Finance and Chief Financial Officer Sherif Soliman.

I want to thank Speaker Adrienne Adams and the entire City Council for your steadfast commitment to ³Ô¹ÏÊÓÆµ, our mission, our programs and, most of all, our students. Your support and that of Governor Kathy Hochul and the State Senate and Assembly have been critical in enabling ³Ô¹ÏÊÓÆµâ€™s continued, vital contributions to New York City.Ìý

Before I bring you up to date on our progress over the past year and goals and plans for the years ahead, I want to acknowledge the impact of the protests on college campuses across the country this spring, including at ³Ô¹ÏÊÓÆµ, and reaffirm our approach to demonstrations. Everyone in our community of 25 campuses has a constitutional right to free speech and a right to protest peacefully, in accordance with ³Ô¹ÏÊÓÆµâ€™s policies. At the same time, CUNYhas been, and will remain, committed to ensuring that every member of our university community is safe from violence, intimidation and harassment. CUNYtakes very seriously its responsibility to protect our community in the face of an emergency situation.

Five years ago this month, I had the great honor of becoming Chancellor. Although these past five years have presented many challenges, we have also accomplished many things working together as a community and with our partners like you.

I want to start by thanking Speaker Adams and the City Council for envisioning and funding CUNYReconnect, a program designed to engage New Yorkers who earned college credits but stopped short of getting a degree. I am thrilled to announce today that this academic year, CUNYReconnect re-enrolled 16,319 students. Over the last two-and-a-half years, more than 33,000 New Yorkers have returned to college through CUNYReconnect, in some cases many years after they put their education on hold. More than 10%, or 3,375 of those who returned through this initiative since 2022, have already completed a degree or are on track to do so this spring, and the majority of them were attending part-time. The program has greatly exceeded its enrollment goals since its launch, and we look forward to working with you as the budget process progresses to ensure funding is continued.

Last June, we unveiled our strategic roadmap, called “CUNYLifting New York,� a detailed plan for bolstering the already profound impact our university makes in the lives of our students, their families and communities, as well as on the city, the region and state. I invite you to review it if you haven’t.

We’ve had many recent successes that are already advancing our “CUNYLifting New York� strategy, and I’d like to tell you about a few of them:

  • We are advancing in our commitment to student success by preparing our students for careers and creating direct and sustainable pipelines to employers. Since I stepped into this role five years ago, CUNYhas connected over 17,000 students to paid internship opportunities through new and expanded university-wide initiatives. We’ve done this with over $34 million in support from the City, State, and private partners. Additionally, the CUNYInclusive Economy network has equipped over 3,100 students with preparation within their departments needed to secure paid internships and full-time roles. To support this, we’ve also engaged over 1,000 employers in offering unique opportunities directly to students – including Centerbridge Partners, Bloomberg, Goldman Sachs, Mount Sinai, and Con Edison.
  • We are fixing long-term flaws in our transfer system by ensuring that students who go from a CUNYcommunity college to one of our senior colleges receive full credit for the first two years of classes they’ve taken within their major. This saves them significant time toward graduation and an average of about $1,220 in tuition. And that’s money they can use for food, housing, child care and other living expenses.
  • We have added 125 fully online, high-quality degree programs across the university to provide access to working adults and those who need flexibility in order to obtain a college degree, bringing to 288 the number of certificate and degree programs that can be completed fully online. That’s a 198% increase since 2022.
  • We continue to draw increasing support for our mission from the philanthropic community. This year alone, CUNYreceived its two largest gifts ever:
    • In January, a $75 million gift from the Simons Foundation and Simons Foundation International earmarked $50 million to establish CUNYas a hub for computational science and $25 million to support our participation in the state’s Empire AI project.
    • And in March, The Steven & Alexandra Cohen Foundation awarded $116 million to create the Cohen Career Collective at LaGuardia Community College – the largest award ever to a CUNYschool and to any community college in the U.S. It will create a 160,000-square-foot workforce training center that will ensure economic mobility for New Yorkers while providing skilled workers for local employers.
  • Both of those gifts align with a wide range of new capital projects that are modernizing ³Ô¹ÏÊÓÆµâ€™s campuses and helping to advance ³Ô¹ÏÊÓÆµâ€™s core educational mission. For example, in February, we unveiled a state-of-the-art $95-million Nursing Education, Research and Practice Center at Lehman College. Lehman’s center is the latest example of state-and-city-sponsored, ³Ô¹ÏÊÓÆµ-led investments in New York’s public education and public health infrastructure. Last November, the master plan for the Science Park and Research Campus (SPARC) at Kips Bay was unveiled. When completed in 2031, SPARC Kips Bay will house modern facilities for three CUNYcolleges, including Hunter’s School of Nursing. ³Ô¹ÏÊÓÆµâ€™s nursing programs are a key player in the expansion of health equity and representation. CUNYgraduates an average of 1,800 nurses annually, representing about half of the nurses entering New York City’s workforce each year.
  • And we have been taking action to confront hate and be proactive in creating campus communities built on trust, understanding and inclusion. Over the past two years, we have taken many steps to combat antisemitism and all forms of bigotry. Among these, CUNYpartnered with Hillel International; launched a portal for community members to report incidents of hate and discrimination and initiated a campaign to promote that students and employees have a right to request religious accommodations for any scheduled academic or employment activities that may conflict with their religious observances. We also formed an advisory council on Jewish life, built a new Diversity, Equity and Inclusion Hub on our website and distributed $1.3 million in City Council and State funding to colleges for trainings, events and activities that address religious, racial and ethnic bigotry.

Mayor’s Executive Budget

I could expand on our recent successes and efforts but it’s important that I turn now to the challenges that jeopardize our continued progress in lifting New York.

The effects of several rounds of baselined PEGs have had a harmful impact on our community colleges – for our students, our programs, and college operations. It was welcome news to hear of the cancellation of additional PEGs in the Executive Budget, but the baselined PEGs for Fiscal Year 2024 that now total $94.1 million, and the estimated $95.4 million in Fiscal Year 2025, will continue to impede ³Ô¹ÏÊÓÆµâ€™s progress. To put this in perspective, the cumulative PEG of $94.1 million is 15% of the entire City contribution to our operating budget.

We have been relentless in our efforts to mitigate the harm from these cuts and preserve our academic mission and reputation as the nation’s leading urban public university. Still, the negative effects of the PEGs are now widespread and unavoidable. We appreciate that the Council prioritized in its budget response a PEG restoration of $40 million and we look forward to working closely with you and the administration, with whom lines of communication remain open, to achieve the restoration goal in the Adopted Budget.

CUNYis an organization of people, so naturally most of our operating budget, about 85%, is dedicated to personnel costs. As a consequence of PEGs, our community colleges are down over 400 positions, or about 7%, since Fiscal Year 2021.

Personnel reductions of this magnitude have impacted, and continue to impact, campus operations and student supports. Here are a few examples:Ìý

  • At Borough of Manhattan Community College, 73 positions are vacant. They include faculty, academic and student support services staff, buildings and grounds professionals, and instructional and administrative support. These vacancies have a direct bearing on student retention, academic success and graduation rates – and ultimately on pathways to career success.
  • At Hostos Community College, 77 positions have been cut. There are 10 unfilled faculty lines and vacancies in student support service areas – Financial Aid, Admissions, and Advisements – that remain unfilled. Departments ranging from IT to Custodial Services are operating with reduced or minimal staff supporting the campus community and handling IT and security issues.

Another example of the effects of the PEGs on several signature programs can be found on the funding of ACE. The Fiscal Year 24 baselined funding for our Accelerated Study in Associate Programs (ASAP) remained stable, and we thank you for that support. However, our Accelerate, Complete and Engage (ACE) program, which serves 2,800 bachelor degree seeking students per year, is not fully funded. The Executive Budget included $1 million for ACE and we are seeking $9.5 million more to ensure the continued success of the program. This is a program that achieves a 4-year graduation rate of 60%, compared with 41% for a matched cohort of students who are not in the program. Even after accounting for ACE’s $2,500-per-student investment, the program reduces the actual cost per graduate by 13%. Because funds must be sought each year and are not baselined, it is difficult to manage vacancies and caseloads – ultimately resulting in fewer students being admitted to the program.

As these representative examples reflect, the reductions imposed by the PEGs have long-term consequences for our students and by extension the city. These effects are magnified by the fact that many students are now enrolling with significant learning delays and intense needs because of the pandemic. They require more support than ever before.

Our situation is even more challenging because ³Ô¹ÏÊÓÆµâ€™s financial obligations exceed our available resources, largely due to post-pandemic enrollment declines and unfunded mandatory costs that the University has had to absorb. It has left us with a structural deficit that challenges us every day.

We take our stewardship of the money this Council provides very seriously. So let me summarize steps that we have taken, and continue to take, to address that structural deficit.

Since the pandemic, we have applied across-the-board savings targets and hiring freezes. Beginning with this current fiscal year, we are adopting a targeted approach, working closely with colleges exhibiting fiscal distress to achieve deficit reduction targets by reducing expenses and seeking opportunities to generate revenue. Our actions, combined with additional State aid, have led to the structural deficit being reduced by more than half of what it was two years ago, from $234 million in Fiscal Year 2022 to a projected $107 million at the end of Fiscal Year 2024, according to our latest projections as of the mid-year point of this current fiscal year. We anticipate that the projected year-end deficit will be even lower as of the third quarter as a result of additional operating aid in the enacted State Budget and actions that we have taken to navigate our fiscal challenges.

We are also implementing various system-wide shared services strategies to achieve additional savings and streamline operations. Among them are centralizing certain IT functions to benefit from economies of scale, pursuing a more effective deployment of maintenance and repair teams to campuses, and consolidating contracts to negotiate better pricing.

Our efforts are not limited to expense reductions. We are also focused on revenue strategies that can help our goal of fiscal stability. We continue to implement enrollment and retention strategies to ensure that students succeed on their educational journeys, and those efforts have led to an uptick in enrollment that helps increase revenues to the University.

Let me turn now to our facility needs. As Chair Dinowitz and members of the Higher Education Committee heard at a recent hearing, the upkeep and enhancement of ³Ô¹ÏÊÓÆµâ€™s extensive facility portfolio is critical to ³Ô¹ÏÊÓÆµâ€™s overall success. A PEG restoration in this budget could help ensure sufficient levels of facilities staff to perform critical maintenance, while additional capital funding will allow us to preserve the University’s infrastructure and achieve a State of Good Repair.

CUNYis home to 300 buildings across New York City, encompassing 29 million square feet of classrooms, labs, theaters, athletic facilities, and more. These spaces are vital for our students and faculty, and to the communities we serve. Our community college infrastructure has an estimated replacement value of $9.2 billion and common facilities management standards recommend a renewal budget of two percent of the replacement value, which translates into $200 million a year to keep these facilities in a State of Good Repair. Additional capital funding would mean that we could upgrade critical systems in our facilities to help achieve our asset preservation goals. We appreciate your efforts in allocating discretionary funding for many important projects and look forward to working with you to achieve our collective goals in modernizing ³Ô¹ÏÊÓÆµâ€™s infrastructure.

In conclusion, we respectfully request that you restore the PEGs to enable CUNYto regain what was lost by personnel reductions in our community colleges and invest in the programs such as ACE and CUNYReconnect that we know will lead to upward social mobility for CUNYstudents. Less investment in CUNYleads to a cumulative negative impact on the City economy – fewer college graduates, a lesser credentialed workforce, lesser ability to attract businesses to the City, lower personal income and business tax bases, longer term potential for more individuals requiring City services. Real investment in CUNYwill do just the opposite. We know this is a broader goal that we collectively share, and we look forward to working together with you to deliver a better future for CUNYand for New York.Ìý

Thank you again for the opportunity to testify, and we look forward to your questions.

###