New Help That Really Works
By Neill S. Rosenfeld
Newly arrived in the United States and working in a restaurant, Qiong Zhou wondered: “Is this job I will have all my life? Wash tablecloths and cleaning table, clean up cups and the plates?�
She had left China in 2010 with a shaky grasp of English but a firm hold on her dreams. “My family preferred for me to work rather than study, but I was very determined to continue my education,� Zhou recalls.
And in two years Zhou had completed an associate degree at Bronx Community College and started a bachelor’s in nutrition at Brooklyn College. She credits her achievement to the University’s Accelerated Study in Associate Programs (ASAP), an initiative started in 2007 to help community college students earn their degrees and do so faster than is usual.
Community colleges nationwide have dismally low graduation rates, and many of the students who stick with it take years to earn their degrees. But Zhou is one of the ASAP program’s many success stories: Like 57 percent of the students who started ASAP with her in 2011, she earned her associate degree within the program’s three-year target. That’s more than twice the three-year graduation rate of a comparison group of non-ASAP CUNYstudents.
Zhou was hardly alone in beating the goal by a year. A third of the 2011 ASAP freshmen earned their degrees in just two years, nearly four times the rate of comparable students who didn’t join the program.
ASAP’s success has been noticed far beyond New York City. Its results are unmatched by any of the other initiatives launched by American community colleges and university systems, and it has put the University in the forefront of a national reform movement. Ohio education officials announced at a recent White House conference that their state is replicating ASAP on three campuses. Colleges as far away as Hawaii have imported the approach, and many more have shown interest in adapting the model.
While ASAP aims to keep students on track for timely graduation, it also has gained attention for a remedial program, CUNYStart. More than half of America’s community college students need remedial courses before they can tackle college-level work. The University provides remediation at its community colleges; in 2012, fully 82 percent of entering students needed remediation.
Most of America’s remedial students never complete the traditional sequence of courses and drop out. Many spend a good deal of their state and federal tuition aid taking and retaking these noncredit courses, leaving less aid for courses that lead to degrees. It’s part of the reason many give up and quit school.
CUNYStart students tell a different story. Between Fall 2009 and Spring 2014, some 3,300 students took the full-time, one-semester program (there’s also a part-time version); all had failed at least two of the University’s assessment tests and more than two-thirds had failed all three. Thanks to CUNYStart, about half tested proficient in reading, writing and math; another third passed two tests; and 82 percent enrolled in a University degree program the following semester. (More details below.)
The success of ASAP and CUNYStart has led to significant expansion of both initiatives. ASAP’s enrollment of 4,300 students this academic year is four times what it was three years ago, and Mayor Bill de Blasio awarded the University an additional $35 million to expand the program to 13,000 over the next three years. CUNYStart, meanwhile, has more than tripled its reach since 2011, to an anticipated 3,800 students this year.
The University’s innovations are crucial to President Obama’s push for more students to graduate from community colleges. Other countries “are working every day to out-educate and out-compete us,� the president has said, and community colleges, which enroll more than 7 million students, or 45 percent of all U.S. undergraduates, are a key to America’s economic future.
To achieve President Obama’s goal, community colleges need to overcome what reformers call “the leaking pipeline� of remediation: Each year, 1.7 million unprepared students enter U.S. colleges, and most quit at some point in the traditional sequence of remedial math, writing and reading courses. Failing to turn struggling students into job-ready graduates costs students and taxpayers an estimated $7 billion a year.
With such high stakes, colleges, university systems and some states are trying to raise their three-year community college graduation rates with initiatives aimed both at improving remedial education and encouraging matriculated students to stay focused so they earn degrees in reasonable time.
In California, a faculty-driven program helps instructors at the state’s 112 community colleges improve remediation. At last count, 195 colleges and universities, including LaGuardia Community College, have adopted a program developed by a Maryland community college English professor that mainstreams underprepared students in regular classes while providing additional class time to remedy weaknesses. And with the help of an influential advocacy group, Complete College America, five states have launched campaigns similar to one in Hawaii that encourages students to earn 15 credits a semester to earn associate degrees in four semesters and bachelor’s degrees in eight.
But it’s ³Ô¹ÏÊÓÆµâ€™s ASAP that stands out for being both academically successful and cost-effective. The program, which accepts both college-ready students and those needing up to two remedial courses, costs the University $3,900 a year per student above usual community college allocations, but that’s a money-saving investment. ASAP’s success at keeping students on track means it actually costs $6,500 less per three-year graduate than for those taking the typical community college route, according to a study by Henry Levin of the Center for Benefit-Cost Studies in Education at Columbia University’s Teachers College.
ASAP starts with tuition-free summer developmental courses, group workshops and opportunities to meet with an adviser. All students participate in a mandatory Summer Institute that builds community between students and staff, orients students to program expectations, and informs them about campus resources. Based on research-based practices that have been shown to improve student outcomes, ASAP requires full-time study in select majors, which will expand within two years to include more in science, technology, engineering and math. ASAP also offers a consolidated course schedule, which encourages rapport between students and helps them balance job and family responsibilities. And it provides close, hands-on monitoring by advisers — “intrusive advising,� as it’s called — along with career development services and tutoring.
To measure ASAP’s effectiveness, the University contracted with MDRC, an independent education and social policy research organization, to conduct a five-year study of 900 students at three colleges. It was a random-assignment study, the gold standard in research but a rarity in education studies. Two years in, MDRC found that ASAP students earned substantially more credits per semester and had higher graduation rates than similar students who followed the conventional route. The University’s internal analysis of the program demonstrated that across ASAP’s first five cohorts, 52 percent of participants earned degrees within the three-year goal, compared with the 22 percent rate for similar non-ASAP students.
MDRC researchers said that ASAP’s increases were “larger than the effects of any other community college program that has been studied to date using a large-scale, rigorous experimental design.� These findings indicate that ASAP is the kind of “comprehensive, extended intervention� that may be necessary for substantial improvement in community college graduation rates.
Qiong Zhou’s success illustrates what makes the program work. She came to the United States at age 20 with her mother and younger brother. Her father had been in New York for a decade, working six and seven days a week to pay off the Chinese smugglers who had gotten him into the country. When he got a green card, making him a legal resident, he sent for his family, but getting clearance from Chinese and U.S. authorities took years more.
Soon after arriving in New York, Zhou concentrated on improving her English. She completed a GED high school equivalency course and a city Department of Education college-transition program. Still, she says, “My reading was so-so, and I had no confidence.�
College would have been out of reach without ASAP’s financial incentives, Zhou says. They included a free monthly MetroCard that enabled her to travel to Bronx Community College, cost-free use of textbooks and a waiver of the difference between tuition and the amount of her federal and state financial aid.
“I thought it would take four years [to earn an associate degree] because of bad English, bad writing,� Zhou recalls. “But ASAP prepared me for college, and I tried my best.�
She says her English 10 class, a six-hour-a-week course incorporating remedial and credit-bearing work, prepared her for the University’s assessment test, which students must pass to take college-credit courses. But most important, she says, was Melanie Robles, her ASAP adviser at Bronx Community. “I always spoke to her, and she always say, ‘Come on, you can do it!’ which for me is a lot,� Zhou says. She adds, smiling, “My husband says that, but he loves me.�
Robles says, “We walk students through their whole first year, and it’s intense. A lot of what we do is coaching them through the things that are going on in their lives.� Zhou talked “not only about her classes, but also about her relationships and things she might be thinking and feeling. She passed all her classes with A’s, maybe one B … She was willing to take risks in communications. Immigrants sometimes hold back in the classroom because of how they sound; she wasn’t like that.�
Zhou earned her associate degree in January and wore cap and gown at the graduation ceremony in May to the cheers of her family. She’s looking forward to the next step, earning her nutrition degree at Brooklyn College, and then a career improving the diets of Chinese immigrants, particularly women, infants and seniors. “I want to tell them how to give good nutrition to themselves and their children,� she says.
Efforts Across the Country
During a White House conference on Aug. 13, Cecilia Muñoz, director of President Obama’s Domestic Policy Council, announced in a blogpost that the Great Lakes Higher Education Guaranty Corporation, a nonprofit student loan servicer, was committing $5 million to an experiment: A partnership with MDRC, the Ohio Board of Regents and CUNY“to replicate ³Ô¹ÏÊÓÆµâ€™s successful Accelerated Study in Associate Programs (ASAP) to support as many as 2,000 community college students in Ohio to help more students graduate sooner.â€�
It will be the largest replication attempt, but just the most recent example of the interest ASAP has drawn from higher education officials and reform advocates. Much of the attention stems from the program’s showcasing by Complete College America, an organization funded by education philanthropy heavyweights including the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation and the Lumina Foundation.
Complete College America was established in 2009 to help close the success gap in American higher education. “We’ve made progress in giving students from all backgrounds access to college,� the organization says, “but we haven’t finished the all-important job of helping them achieve a degree.� Complete College America invited Donna Linderman, the University’s associate dean for student success initiatives, to speak about ASAP at several of its national and state conferences, and audiences were intrigued.
Meanwhile, the University hosted an ASAP “Design Studio� last spring that attracted 19 colleges, 10 states and several research organizations. Groups also visited ASAP programs at five CUNYcampuses. This may lead to further replication.
Linderman and other reformers were invited to speak at a conference hosted by the Hawaii Graduation Initiative, a program launched by the University of Hawaii in 2010 to help 25 percent more students graduate in five years. After hearing Linderman’s presentation on ASAP, Hawaii educators traveled to New York to see it firsthand. They liked what they saw, and so far two of Hawaii’s community colleges have adapted the ASAP approach.
“We’re taking the best practices that show success and are doing a lot of professional development for our faculty as they customize what they’re learning to fit their course or campus,� says Suzette Robinson, director of academic programs for Hawaii’s community colleges.
Windward Community College, for example, started with a program for all full-time freshmen with developmental needs that includes an “intro to college� class and “early warning� from instructors at specified checkpoints in the first half of the term. The college also has started two grant-funded projects with intrusive advising for underrepresented Native Hawaiians.
Leeward Community College tried an ASAP-based pilot program last year at a satellite campus called G2FO (Going to Finish Ontime). Results were so encouraging that the college secured a five-year grant to expand it to its main campus. Aimed at students who commit to full-time study so they can graduate in two to three years, G2FO features a consolidated course schedule, structured course pathways, a common seminar course, free textbooks and $500 scholarships at credit milestones.
“ASAP was our model and we tried to replicate it as much as we could,� says Leeward’s interim dean of student services, Laurie Lawrence. The early results are promising. G2FO students took twice as many college-level credits in Spring 2014 as they did the previous semester. Meanwhile, enrollment in developmental courses fell because fewer students needed them. Besides a fresh instructional approach, Lawrence says, success came from “relationship-building, the support students received and the community they built among themselves to support each other.�
Much of the thinking behind efforts to boost graduation rates and the pace of students’ progress comes from research showing that many students don’t recover from the adverse psychological effects of early struggles. “We think that a few unsuccessful attempts at [remedial] writing or reading or math are all it takes to convince them that they are not college material,� says Peter Adams, an English professor at the Community College of Baltimore County in Maryland.
Over the course of two decades Adams has developed an approach, called the Accelerated Learning Program (ALP) that mixes remedial and college-ready students in a “gatekeeper� introductory college-level English course. After each class, teachers spend more time with the ALP students, shoring up their weaknesses. A 2010 analysis found that nearly twice as many ALP participants as traditional remediation students completed the gatekeeper course. This has led 195 community colleges and universities so far to adopt the ALP method.
At LaGuardia Community College, for example, 10 remedial English students are in a class with 12 proficient students. They meet together for four hours a week and the remedial students work three more hours with the same instructor to perfect skills needed to pass the University’s proficiency test. If they pass, they earn three credits. The success rate at LaGuardia has been comparable to Baltimore’s.
“I think this should be the default way we teach basic writing at LaGuardia,� says English professor Heidi L. Johnsen, who directed LaGuardia’s program for three years.
Math Innovation and CUNYStart
³Ô¹ÏÊÓÆµ, meanwhile, is pioneering an approach for improving remedial math that uses mainstreaming and workshops; it substitutes a statistics course for traditional remedial algebra. A recent study led by Alexandra Logue, the University’s former executive vice chancellor and university provost, compared the pass rates of math students in a traditional remedial algebra class with those who took a credit-bearing introductory statistics course plus a weekly workshop. The statistics students had a pass rate nearly 50 percent higher.
The math experiment is the latest University initiative to excite advocates of remediation reform, following the success of CUNYStart in improving student performance in remedial courses: Once matriculated, CUNYStart students take and earn more credits, earn higher GPAs and are retained at higher rates than similar students.
The program has a strong commitment to teacher training and instructional practices and curricula that build the skills, concepts and strategies students will need for college-level work. Adult literacy and education experts developed the program and serve as professional development coordinators for the participating colleges. Professional development is critical, and instructors take on their on classroom or advising caseload only after a semester of close training under a lead teacher or adviser.
CUNYStart is offered at six of the seven community colleges and at two senior colleges.
It has full-time and part-time versions. The full-time program runs 25 hours a week with instruction in reading, writing and math, the subjects of the three University assessment tests, along with a college success seminar. The part-time program addresses either reading/writing (taught as one subject) or math for 12 hours a week. The cost to students is just $75.
Classroom instruction is student-centered and highly interactive, with teachers encouraging “student talk over teacher talk� and advisers supporting development of effective communication, self-advocacy skills, time management and study habits.
After 12 weeks of core instruction by the specially trained CUNYStart teachers and support from the program’s advisers, students retake any required assessment tests in reading and writing or a common math department final exam. Three to six weeks of additional instruction are available if needed, followed by retesting. There’s also individualized advisement to help students complete the program and matriculate in a University degree program.
For students like Rosa Rios, CUNYStart has made all the difference. For most of her 42 years, she was challenged by an eighth-grade education, pressing family needs and weak training that led to unsatisfying jobs. “I fell through the cracks,� she says. When her mother developed Alzheimer’s disease, Rios cared for her until she died four years ago.
With a lot of hard work and support, Rios used CUNYStart to bring herself up to college level in reading, writing and math. “The student-faculty relationship is real quality and great. They prepared us for college,� she says. She became such a good writer that she won second place in a campus competition.
Now maintaining a 3.0 GPA at Queensborough Community College, she aims for a career as a registered nurse. When she encounters struggling students, “I tell them, ‘Go with CUNYStart and work your way up.’�
Slaying the Math Dragon With College-Level Statistics
It’s not often that a presentation about math at an education conference draws a standing-room-only audience, several rounds of loud applause and comments afterward of the “Thank you for doing this important work� variety.
But that’s what happened when CUNYfaculty scholars Alexandra Logue and Mari Watanabe-Rose presented the findings of their research aimed at helping improve college graduation rates by breaking down one of the key barriers for many students: Doing the math.
Lexa Logue and Mari Watanabe (right and left, seated) and the student workshop leaders engaged in a study on teaching statistics for remedial math.
Nationally, about 60 percent of new college freshmen need remedial courses, and math accounts for most — algebra, to be specific, and what happens next might be the ultimate math problem. “The percentage of remedial students who finish the courses is dismal,â€� says Logue, who recently left her position as ³Ô¹ÏÊÓÆµâ€™s executive vice chancellor and provost to do research. “They don’t pass the courses, they don’t take the whole sequence. . . . It’s clear that the whole approach to remediation is one of the biggest blocks to students getting their college degrees.â€�
Some community colleges around the country have started offering statistics for students who don’t intend to pursue degrees requiring advanced math. It’s an idea not without controversy — reformers say statistics is more practical while traditionalists consider it a lowering of standards — but in 2013 Logue and Watanabe-Rose set out to see how much difference it makes, especially in combination with another growing approach in remediation: building extra help into courses.
Logue especially wanted to test the idea with the rigor of a controlled laboratory study, something rarely done in education research because it’s difficult and time consuming to get enough consenting participants for a statistically valid sampling. The size of CUNYhelped get over that hurdle. Last fall, Logue and Watanabe-Rose began a study involving 721 incoming freshmen at three CUNYcommunity colleges: Borough of Manhattan, LaGuardia and Hostos. They were randomly assigned to one of three groups, and these were the results:
- Traditional remedial algebra class: 39 percent passed.
- Remedial algebra plus a weekly workshop: 45 percent passed.
- College-level, introductory statistics plus a weekly workshop: 56 percent passed
Logue first presented the findings at this year’s National Conference on Acceleration in Developmental Education, and they were so well-received that experts and advocates in the remediation reform movement have been talking about it ever since. The buzz has led to more presentations and coverage in education media.
“This is huge,� a researcher at the Community College Research Center, at Columbia University’s Teachers College, told Inside Higher Education.
Bruce Vandal, the vice president of Complete College America, a nonprofit advocacy organization, said the study supports an ongoing national movement to reduce the number of students in noncredit remedial courses. “This is just going to add more fuel to it,� he said.
The CUNYstudy may be the biggest answer yet to the sinkhole that remedial math is for so many students. For educators, it might come down to a simple question — one as moral as it is practical: Should a student’s prospects for earning a college degree — and the lifelong benefits associated with it — depend on passing one algebra course?
Logue says the conventional approach to remediation doesn’t take into account the often devastating psychological effects of stigmatization and discouragement. “What I learned from many years as an experimental psychologist is that it’s harder to be motivated for goals that are delayed,� Logue says. “So it’s hard for students to stay motivated when they think they’re starting college but instead they have to take what are basically high school courses for no credit, and they have to use up their financial aid to pay for them.�
— Richrd Firstman




