By Anna Leah泭
In the 1800s, prospectors raced to California for gold. For the last few decades, the state���s tech-fueled success has tempted cities to泭 use their resources泭 to泭 trigger their own modern economic boom.泭泭
���All new technologies develop in specific places,��� says , sociologist and professor emerita at Brooklyn College and the泭 Graduate Center. ���They grow in specific places – and they change those places, whether those places are on the scale of individual workplaces or cities or regions.���泭泭
Zukin���s 2020 book, (Oxford University Press) explored how the tech industry shapes a city���s future. The title plays on both a development complex and a kind of inferiority complex local leaders exhibit if they feel泭 they���re being left out of the ���innovation economy.���泭泭泭
���Digital technology is a prime form of contemporary capitalism,��� says Zukin.泭泭
She explains city leaders become ���tethered��� to the tech economy, making decisions from installing traffic泭 sensors to limiting minimum wages to remain in favor with industry CEOs. She says, ���They do not dare to alienate tech companies, because then they won���t have a tech economy. And what���s a modern economy if it���s not a tech economy?���泭泭
Tech companies repeat similar protocols as they move into cities throughout the world. ���The categories of institutions are the same,��� says Zukin. ���Despite different ideologies and different kinds of politics, governments are all ��� they���re bureaucracies that run the state and control the levers of the state and control the purse of the state.���泭泭
She notes growths in public-private partnerships, in which companies fund ��� and profit from ��� services that the government previously provided. Zukin describes it as now a universal form of urban governance.泭泭
泭In the 1980s, New York City was unable to pay for some of the parks and schools it wanted. Zukin says that resulted in New York ���ceding influence to some part of the business community. It���s a transactional relationship, even though public-private partnerships are presented as being for the public good. Maybe they are, to some degree.���泭泭
Since the 1990s, partly because of the tech economy, sociologists have used the term ���triple helix��� to describe the triad of leadership that emerged. This braids the input of local government, industry, and universities.泭泭
���The influence of Silicon Valley has really been planetary, copying the concepts and the language that came out of the 70s in California,��� says Zukin.泭泭
One result is a scene that repeats from Palo Alto to Shanghai: third-wave coffeeshops with English signs, serving the same drinks from the same espresso machines. The same workers who migrate for the same jobs, using ���MBA-speak and engineering-speak.���泭泭
Zukin sees some differences in New York City. The San Francisco Area, she notes, leads in basic research. New York���s scene taps into existing financial infrastructure. Seattle excels at mapping technology. Boston has a hold on biotechnology, but one that New York works to supplant, using existing talent and teaching hospitals.泭泭
New York started out behind because of the intensity of the dot-com bust of the late 1990s. Zukin says the city experienced too much investment for too small a market. ���People said for years that ���New York will have no tech economy���,��� she explains.泭泭
Zukin found that the same people from the 90s went underground and kept working. They emerged after 2008 to lead New York���s tech revitalization.泭泭
Real estate and local government played their part. ���Land is always a crucial element of anything that happens in cities,��� says Zukin. ���If you make a model of what holds a city together, it’s land, labor, capital, and culture.���泭泭
Mayor Bloomberg prioritized the tech economy, gambling on universities and developing Cornell Tech. The goal was to educate engineers and hope they would spark invention. Before then, Zukin explains, the city hadn���t had any economic development strategy.泭泭
By the 2010s, though, tech firmly gripped the imagination of city planners. Hype hailed the deindustrialized waterfront of Brooklyn as the ���innovation coastline.��� Steiner Studios, the film production company, and New Lab moved into the Brooklyn Navy Yard. Industry City, with an array of tenants including coworking space opened its doors.泭泭
But Zukin keeps a skeptical eye on which tech industry promises are realistic or only sales pitches.泭泭
As her book research began, she sent first year grad student Max Papadantonakis to hackathons, where programmers compete in timed coding challenges. This resulted in which argued, in part, that the events socialize tech workers. They suggest a Silicon Valley-like job is presented as ���an extraordinary opportunity, a ritual of ecstatic labor, and a collective imaginary for fictional expectations of innovation that benefits all.���泭泭泭
Papadantonakis��� subsequent dissertation became Canary in the Code Mine (Temple University Press) about software engineers��� job precarity.泭泭
In the hackathons, Zukin saw the DNA of the tech ecosystem. ���Those organizations, they have a missionary purpose, proselytizing about the adoption of digital technology,��� she says.泭泭
泭Zukin teaches on occasion, but ���cannot resist working with a good graduate student.��� She is mentoring geographer Caroline Aung as she develops a research project about how institutions incorporate the discourse of artificial intelligence.泭泭
泭Recently, Zukin has moved towards documentaries. With the filmmaker Alice Arnold, she created to show people where, almost invisibly, tech companies exist in the city. The two filmmakers are now producing a one-hour documentary about the history of the artists��� community in SoHo. The Graham Foundation .泭泭
泭We use technology���s products all the time ��� from Google Maps to Door Dash. But Zukin says that might give us the illusion that we know their effects and can control them.泭泭
泭She points to Amazon, where customers buy products for convenience but then face sidewalks and streets clogged with delivery workers. City residents live with truck pollution and face serious environmental issues from data centers. Higher-paid AI workers flood the housing market, driving up prices.泭泭
泭She says, ���The power of the tech economy is all around us, but we don���t necessarily see it ��� even when we���re using digital technology.���泭
