February 13, 2026 |

Another Look At Island Living

By Leandra Manon

Water sustains us but also calms us. It is necessary for our daily lives, but simply being close to it can impact our psychological wellbeing.

Biologist Wallace J. Nichols��� suggests that the presence of water can shift the mind into a restorative state, decreasing stress and anxiety. In some cases, living near a coast may .

At Guttman Community College, has analyzed how living close to water affects the lives of people on islands. For her study, she surveyed residents of Block Island, Martha���s Vineyard, and Nantucket.

These New England islands become popular tourist destinations in the mid-to-late-19th century, as the Industrial Revolution gave some people leisure time, disposable income, and transportation options. These seasonal visitors swelled the numbers of existing communities ��� primarily of whalers, farmers, and shipworkers.

Today, more than 36,000 people live year-round on Block Island, Martha���s Vineyard, and Nantucket.

An associate professor of human services, Kras��� research focuses on nature���s impact on human development and learning. Leading Guttman’s , Kras and her team take students out of the classroom and expose them to natural settings in New York City.

Kras��� own experiences with the New England coast inspired ���Island Blue Spaces.��� She frequently visits Block Island with her sister, Jennifer Keenan ��� a Boston University professor who co-authored the study. The pair wondered about the experiences of year-round residents.

���Oh, it’d be so great if we lived here all year. What do you think it’s like for people who live on these islands?��� says Kras, recalling the conversation she had with Keenan. ���That was kind of the spark for our idea.���

The sisters created a series of studies. Their first explored how New England���s island residents viewed They found the island���s natural environment positively impacted participants��� physical, mental, and spiritual wellbeing.

Their examined that impact during the COVID-19 pandemic. The island���s environment eased residents��� mental strains. Despite their serene surroundings, they faced food and supply disruptions and more limited access to mainland healthcare.

���Island Blue Spaces,��� the third study, continued these themes while diving deeper into residents’ pain points. Kras and Keenan looked at three main topics: reasons for living on an island, island versus non-island life, and the impact of tourism.

Kras and Keenan used a modified snowball sampling technique ��� when initial research participants referothers in proximity to them. Most respondents were women (69%), Caucasian (83%), and/or homeowners (75%).

According to Kras��� first study, participants were drawn to the islands��� confluence of the ocean, tide pools, and animals. One person boasted about the island���s seemingly endless opportunities to experience nature. They said their daily routine included walks on the beaches and moors, birding, sailing, and fishing. Another described the natural world as their refuge.

Others said the island���s landscape influenced them to change their mainland ways. One participant chose to go car-free, which encouraged a mindful approach to their everyday habits.

Kras’ third study reinforced these findings. Residents said that their main reasons for living on the islands included a sense of community, solitude, simpler lifestyles, and exposure to nature. Over 90% said that access to nature influenced their decision to remain.

Kras���s fourth study, ���,��� further explored that relationship with nature. Examining participant-produced images, she found 74% of photographs depicted the island���s natural beauty and serenity.

But all is not perfect on the islands. Participants noted low access to health care and limited transportation to and from the island. One participant expressed uncertainty around keeping up with chemotherapy appointments in Boston due to the cost of transportation.

Many participants flagged affordability as a prominent issue. Some questioned if they could remain on their island. The Vineyard Gazette reported median home prices in Martha���s Vineyard rose from $600,000 in 2012泭喧棗 . Kras��� study cites tourism as a significant driver of increasing costs.

���Especially in Nantucket, we saw that some were not able to afford to live there in the summers,��� says Kras. “Places that they live in were being rented out to people coming for vacation and they had to find somewhere else to live.���

The island boasts high tourism rates from June through August. Martha���s Vineyard���s population grows roughly ten-fold. Block Island sees as many as 20,000 visitors per day, in a community of roughly 1,400.

Tourism provides an economic benefit for the island-dwellers, but the changes create ambivalence in residents used to a small-town feel.

One participant regards tourists and summer residents as ���the backbone of the economy.��� But they say that mental stress comes from pressure to make a year’s worth of income in a three-month period. Another participant expressed distress over price hikes, or what they call ���rich people rates versus normal rates.���

���Many people go in with the mentality of, ���oh, you’re out on the beach and you’re relaxing,������ says Kras. ���Well, no, there’s people who are working two or three jobs just to be able to stay.���

Island living can be the opposite of relaxing for year-round residents, especially during peak visitor months. Despite these challenges, many remain adamant that they want to stay next to the water.