By H Conley
The impact of conflicts and tariffs has brought the second Trump administration���s international policies front and center. Eyes remain on the Middle East, Russia, and China. Their approach to Africa has received far less attention.
���The narrative that has been dominant, especially in liberal foreign policy circles, is that Trump represents a disaster for the continent,��� says , professor of international affairs at Baruch College. ���That it marks this extreme departure from what came before.���
Mampilly disagrees.
His prior research looked at politics within African nations: how , the , and as nations fight colonialization. His investigates how President Donald Trump���s approach to Africa compares to that of previous executives.
Mampilly realized that the Trump administration largely continued what began under president Barack Obama. While there have been some prominent and destructive policy changes, such as the and towards African immigrants, on the whole Trump has not materially changed America���s Africa policy. Mampilly says the Obama, Biden and Trump administrations, ���demonstrated remarkably little interest in Africa.���
Obama���s most impactful Africa policy was expanding George W. Bush���s war on terror, continued by Joseph Biden and Trump. The U.S. gave money to authoritarian regimes and fostered militarization of countries across the continent. American troops have been involved in , , , , ostensibly in the name of the war on terror.
Some framed such involvement as promoting democracy, but that didn���t match reality. Mampilly says the U.S. forged tight relationships with autocratic countries like Uganda, which for four decades.
���Most Americans don’t realize, but in some ways you could argue that the locus of the war on terror is now in Africa,��� Mampilly says. ���It is very counterproductive ��� I find it deplorable, to be blunt.���
The so-called ������ of Africans crossing the Mediterranean to Europe started during the Obama era. ���African migrants were framed as this bogeyman threatening to tear down the walls to get into Europe and the U.S.,��� says Mampilly. ���Obama didn���t challenge that narrative at all.���
Trump pushed that idea further. He continued to demonize African migrants, and Biden did little to counter it.
Mampilly sees the terrorism and migration narratives as defining America���s approach to Africa. ���Both issues frame Africa as the problem that must be contained by the West,��� he says. ���There are long historical roots for that perspective.���
This attitude led to Africa opening to influence from other countries. China, India, Malaysia, Turkey, and Indonesia have all made substantive infrastructure and mining investments in the continent.
���There are problems with those relationships as well,��� says Mampilly. ���But, certainly, they���re an improvement over the United States and Europe���s archaic lens that Africa is a problem to be solved.���
The best comparison is between the U.S. and China���s approaches. China does not interfere in the domestic affairs of their trading partners. Scholars criticize China���s use of debt to extract favorable terms in trade relationships, but the country has also built ports, roads, and railroads.
���Certain cities have been transformed by Chinese investment across Africa over the past two decades,��� says Mampilly. ���In ways that you can critique, but it���s hard not to see that as a substantive transformation.���
In contrast, Mampilly has trouble seeing anything positive about how the U.S. and Europe have engaged with Africa during that time. ���Most African governments themselves don���t necessarily view the U.S. as a meaningful partner,��� says Mampilly. ���They continue to pivot away from the U.S., in a way that is astonishing considering how influential the U.S. was in the 1990s.���
Mampilly sees the United States’ deteriorating relationships with African countries as short-sighted and backward-looking.
Africa has the youngest population of any continent and is the only continent with a growing population. That means both growing markets and skilled labor pools. ���A lot of the conditions are in place for them to take off economically,��� says Mampilly. ���If I was advising somebody in the U.S. government, I would say, ���Invest now to reap the rewards later.������
