The White House’s March 21, 2019, Executive Order, titled “Improving Free Inquiry, Transparency, and Accountability at Colleges and Universities,� does very little to change the legal obligations of colleges and universities regarding free speech, especially at public institutions governed by the First Amendment. It simply requires that universities “promote free inquiry, including through compliance with all applicable federal laws, regulations, and policies.�
The City University of New York (³Ô¹ÏÊÓÆµ) notes that colleges and universities already “promote free inquiryâ€� because it is the very foundation of education in a free society. Further, colleges and universities must already comply “with all applicable federal laws, regulations, and policies.â€�
CUNYis concerned, however, with the partisan rhetoric used by the President of the United States when issuing this Executive Order. At the signing, the President railed against “ideological intolerance on campus,� which he characterized as “rigid� and “far-left.� He claimed that “universities have tried to restrict free thought, impose total conformity, and shut down the voices of great young Americans.� He threatened colleges with removing federal research grants, saying, “Every year, the federal government provides educational institutions with more than $35 billion in research funding. All of that money is now at stake.� He warned that this Order was “just the beginning of our efforts to protect free speech and advance our students’ rights agenda.� CUNYis troubled by the implications of this language and what it portends for free inquiry at colleges and universities.
CUNYwill always safeguard free speech, encourage deep and thoughtful engagement with ideas, and promote free inquiry. Exposing students to a wide range of viewpoints and perspectives is fundamental to all levels of undergraduate and graduate education. Academic freedom is essential for universities’ capacity to promote free inquiry through deliberation and debate. Academic freedom does not mean, however, that all ideas must be equally discussed and debated. A university community itself must determine the ideas and issues that deserve close scholarly attention, including the speakers invited to campus. These determinations will vary from campus to campus, in keeping with the diversity of American academe and what Frederick Douglass called our “composite nationality.�
In our democratic system, the government may not interfere with a university’s academic judgment on these matters. Any attempt to pressure colleges and universities to favor one side of the political spectrum would set a dangerous and unconstitutional precedent, chill creativity, and erode the scholarly exploration vital to robust academic life. Such governmental interference would also violate basic democratic values essential to a free society.
###

